Love / Arranged????Or Mix???
By Dassodils
@Dassodils (2010)
India
January 10, 2012 11:15am CST
Hai friends...
I am really confused...Some of my friends said that love marriage is good..But Some other people says that Arranged...I like to love one person..Then after some years or months, we will get married with parent's blessings..Means Love come Arranged marriage...So that I can realize the main character and all relatives will be with us to support us in any situations..Right???Thank you...
8 people like this
42 responses
@koperty3 (1876)
•
10 Jan 12
I know that I would marry person that I love. I don't think arrange marriages are good in 21st century. I'm in this position that my family really likes my future husband but if they didn't I would marry him anyway. This is my life and none will decide for me. Also I don't think family should interfere between couple, unless there is violence in the relationship.
3 people like this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
O.k.nice reply..I like to live like my wishes as you..
1 person likes this
@prettyruby (350)
• United States
12 Jan 12
I agree - I think people are much more individualistic these days so arranged marriages aren't really suitable for most people anymore. Especially for women, since women are much more independent now. I don't think arranged marriages are bad, necessarily, but I think most people would prefer, and maybe be happier, picking their own spouses.
@albto_568 (1268)
• Costa Rica
11 Jan 12
I believe that a decision as important as the person who will be with you for the rest of your life, depends, primarily on the couple, of course, family is a factor that should be considered, but the love and commitment between the couple is the one and most important matter.
2 people like this
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
11 Jan 12
yes. this is the trend in western countries. But in India parents help the groom find partner. 90% marriages succeed. 10% of them fail. Here also luck plays an important role.
2 people like this
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
11 Jan 12
Nowadays in the tamil brahmin community we find it difficult to get the boy a match. yes. number of girls is probably less and/or the girls demand too much and put down many conditions. Interesting. In the next fifty years or so --boys may have to give dowry and marry girls.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
In my view, I believe that Luck is the main part...We should hard work and luck should be there to help us...Thank you Albto and Ravi..
1 person likes this
@yanzalong (18988)
• Indonesia
11 Jan 12
Parents' approval is important but what most important is that you and your boyfriend love each other to begin with. Knowing each other's character takes a long time, In two years' time I don't think you will know exactly how he is. Some people said that the truth about each other will reveal itself after years of togetherness. Arranged marriages may lead to the situation that you expect or that you try to avoid. In most cases, arranged marriages tend to fail to give you the best.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
I am watching some people's experience..My sister's marriage was arranged and she live very happily now...I believe that god blessed her with a good husband...Thanks... :)
1 person likes this
@madugulagopi (1093)
• India
10 Jan 12
No Matter whatever marriage you go for, make sure that you know that person's nature completely most importantly the negatives in that person. If you are ready to accept the negatives in that person then only prepare to marry him/her. Also don't think that someone will come and help you if your marriage is in trouble. No one will come. Its your life and you have to make it right. In a country like India its always better to marry the person you love by getting parents blessings. Now a days parents also started thinking and are accepting love marriages with big heart so convincing parents might not be a big task. Anyway all the best to you and just keep one thing in mind before you love a person that is Love alone is not enough for leading a happy life :)
2 people like this
@madugulagopi (1093)
• India
12 Jan 12
I also agree that Love always comes first but I am telling with experience that you cannot live a happy life with just love :) We see in movies that hero and heroine will just be in love and then with that love they will be living very happily but that doesn't happen in real life. Money is a secondary thing in love but lack of money will surely put a dent in your love. Money has no boundaries, so make sure that you love a person who is well settled so that money wont enter between you two people, then in that case your life will be wonderful :) My best wishes to you :)
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Hey Madu..
I am seeking for a person who loves and cares me always and an ability to face any problems..I will definitely select a person with confidence and will power..That will be an educated one..So I believe that there have no place for financial matters...By getting a job, We can earn other things...So I believe that Love is first... :) :)
@marie2052 (3691)
• United States
11 Jan 12
Through many cultures ways of love are different.
I remember watching the movie Fiddler On The Roof. Tradition stated the matchmaker would do the matches. But the girls each thought of modern times for that time in history and made harsh decisions for their love of whom they loved plus the love of their family.
During King Henry's time he gave permission to the court whom they could marry.
And if he wanted one of the ladies of court he refused marriage for them.
The United States, awe the good old days, we married for life. But then came the D word Divorce, and now you hear all the time if we dont like each other we will just get a divorce.
The stability of family and home are so far lost to single parent homes with children today.
My token was always loyalty to family and faith.
But even that is broken at times when some cultures need money and food and consider a boy more important in life than their daughters and sell them.
Memoirs of a Geisha movie showed us a look into one culture.
In Africa, if a young man of one village wants to marry a girl from a different village he has to show proof he is a man, and he also has to bring either animals or grain or money. The father can determine how much the daughter is worth to give over to the young man. I watched this on a National Geographic show.
There is so much to learn from cultures and the ways of each it is indeed a mystery to learn and admire and sometimes not agree with the ways of cultures.
Such as the movie The Stoning of Sayarah. Because her husband wanted a younger girl to marry he convinced the town that she had committed adultry.
That was very hard for me to see a man do to his wife. But I learn, and it makes me realize how easy Americans have it and I want to help these kinds of women. It does not matter race. No woman alive deserves to be stoned or killed.
So it is still a mystery if true love really exsists.
I know my parents were married in 1947 had me in 1952 I was an only child. My mother always had something to say bad about my father. He always worked, came home,did not drink, provided for both my mother and I. He was a very quiet man. I did not learn much from him but from his father my grandfather, I learned values of a man and woman's love. They never divorced it was against their age and society back then but they were not happy.
So maybe having family choose your husband as long as you are both close in age to grow together in love and family, and join families together is not such a bad thing.
I tend to like the idea myself but unfortunately I was not born to a culture of that integrity. I had to be one of the Divorce statisics when my husband left me 7 months pregnant with our second baby.
Blessings on your discussion and happy mylotting.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Oh...
Thank you very much for such big reply..:) :)
1 person likes this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Are you married???Do you have any experience????Thanks...
1 person likes this
@emdjay23 (1575)
• Philippines
10 Jan 12
Marriage is Sacred.. if you will marry someone it must be the person you really love.. not just arranged marriage, the downside of it, you don't know much about your partner, don didn't even know what he wants, dislikes, like and everything.. Maybe you need to settle to the one you love and most specially with the blessing of your family..
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
I don't think that my family will support me..They are looking for a person who have a good job and financial status...Thanks...
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (166761)
• Boise, Idaho
11 Jan 12
I think that loving someone is paramount. If you don't love someone a marriage is more of a business arrangement. I guess if that is what someone wants then that is fine. I think the perfect situatuon is one where you choose the person you love. You marry this person and you parents and family honor your decision.
@celticeagle (166761)
• Boise, Idaho
14 Jan 12
...And I am sure you will want to do what your parents want you to.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
I will do like that...But I am not sure that my parents will agree that...Thanks..
1 person likes this
@srik11 (482)
• India
10 Jan 12
Yes you are kind of on the right track. If you love someone then you can talk with their parents and get to know more about the family. Or if you parents arranged a match for you, you can spend some time interacting with the person and bond with him/her.
1 person likes this
@madugulagopi (1093)
• India
12 Jan 12
And no one said that there will not be any love if you go for an arranged marriage. You can go interact with the person whom your parents have seen and know more about the person before saying an Yes. Now a days parents are broadminded and even in an arranged marriage parents wait for the gal to say Yes before proceeding.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
I really hope so Srik...But some times, That's not practical..I will try my best to find a good one..Thank you..
@AJsMom (157)
• Philippines
10 Jan 12
Marriage for me is for couples who are deeply in love and willing to be committed to one another. And even with great love for one another, most marriages do not last a lifetime. If a couple is deeply in love with one another and yet they cannot make their marriage work out, how much more if the reason for being together is because other people arranged it for them. However, it still depends on how people treat the situation. Some can make it work out. Fixed or arranged marriage is not for me.
2 people like this
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
11 Jan 12
This is the topic I gave in my class yesterday for engineering II year students. Of course they did not discuss properly --made a lot of noise.
Arranged marriage --this system is there in our country only. In almost all the other countries boys and girls choose their life partner.
In our context -- it is good to have arranged marriages with proper reference -- so that in case of problems parents may support.
yesterday in Times of India "The problem with arranged marriages " has been discussed. I am not able to post the link because it has not come in archives of TOI.
1 person likes this
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
11 Jan 12
After posting the above I had been to a saloon for hair cut. I read a report from a local newspaper --- Parents tried to get their 19 year old daughter - studying in B.Sc. to a man 50 year old - blind man- drunkard. The girl ran away from the house and made a complaint to the police. Girl's parents came and hit the girl and the lawyer who was trying to help her.
This type of arranged marriages are totally bad -instead the boy or girl can choose their partner after giving sufficient thought.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Yaa.. I like to find a perfect person and make an arranged marriage..But we can't to realize that if it is a fraud..Thank you...
@boyuancy (1708)
• India
10 Jan 12
I've had this discussion with my friends so many times. I like love marriage, to know and love a person completely before you get married to her.
For some of my friends, they prefer arranged, as meeting a new person and falling in love with her would be a different experience altogether.
So it depends from person to person.
1 person likes this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Ya...Most of the people who got married as love, will be fail..They says that the all love ends after marriage...Somme of my friends are suffering now from love marriage.. Thanks..
1 person likes this
@boyuancy (1708)
• India
11 Jan 12
Now you cannot really generalize all the cases into one, I mean there have been so many success stories.
But most I have heard, like yours, have been bad ones. Like the girl falling in love and marrying without checking the background of the guy, and the guy turning out to be a freak. It is so hard to hear all that and takes my belief off of love.
@Kalebtheman (530)
• India
10 Jan 12
love come arranged marriage is best in the long run. marrying the person you love is the sweetest thing that can happen in life...:)
1 person likes this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Ya...Other things will automatically come to us..Right???? Thanks
@victorkrish (1614)
• Malaysia
11 Jan 12
Me too in same situation. Arrange or love.which is better? I also wanting to know the perfect answer.
1 person likes this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Same to you Victor..
I don't know what to do...I think that I can realize that from this discussion.. Thanks..
1 person likes this
@ankit_620 (496)
• India
10 Jan 12
Whatever runs in the family.The traditions which family have followed and from what culture they belong it all depends whether a person is going to have a love marriage or arranged.Ofcourse there are some may go against their parents will or something like that but that would be an extreme step to take.We do feel like it is wrong that we are bound by our parents decision on arranged marriage but the the truth is that our parents do know better.One can become blind in the starting wind of love but don't realize what will happen in future.
So i will say if your parents approve of your decision and you have though abour it thoroughly then well and good go for it but if not then go for arrange marriage you won't regret it either.
@thanks1961 (7035)
• India
12 Jan 12
I think you must have got a better and detailed understanding about the topic, even though I didn't read all of them. However, wish you all the best to get a perfect match for you when the time comes.
All the best,
Thank-s
@thanks1961 (7035)
• India
16 Jan 12
Hi dear,
Good morning.
As you siad, when it comes to reality, I always think a lot. A life with a different person makes a lot of curiosity, especially getting married and living together. For some people, it is just like a usual matter and nothing more on it. Especially these days, many are already lived like h/b & wife and only for the name same they will get married.
But when it come to reality, and also if it is a person with whom we like or wished, the experiance would me more lovable and special. In fact a life before the marriage with the dreams and expectations may be the best time for everyone as we foresee them in our minds and experiences with imagination. The reality may be anything, but the dream and imagination could be alwys with our own thoughts only.
Even I am having such imaginations and dreams about the better half who come in the real life. However, too much expectations may end up in little despire as it may not compact with real life. So, a moderate at the same time with a practical approach towards our would be can be fruitful for the rest of the life.
Whatever it may be, a life with imagination and expectation is a wonderful experience till we get married. It can be a failure or success, but we never try to end up our dream with a failure. So, for me, the dream about such a life is giving a lot of pleasure and happiness. The rest all will be afterwards. The best things to be noted is that we all need to try our life to a success one, because we don't have an appropriate other life to experience it. So, adjustment with whoever we live is the best way out to success and the love with a whole hearted approach will get back the love what we are giving to the other party, who ever it is. If we give him/her the pure love from the heart, they would always indebted to give it back, in other words, we lock them up with love, this is the way I feel about it...
Thank-s
@CTHanum (8234)
• Malaysia
12 Jan 12
I am still single and I am fine with any of them but it does not mean my parents can decide when I should get married and I will only do so when I am ready to do it.(^^) If I am in love with someone or my parents have someone for me but I am not ready to married him it is no use too. So wait till I am ready and willing to do so only then I don't mind if it's my or my parent's choice.(^^)
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
12 Jan 12
I am not in a marriage age..But I can't to make a final analyze on this topic that's why I started this discussion...If my parents are finding a person for me, I will try to adjust with him...Thanks
@dilrajj57 (1757)
• Pakistan
13 Jan 12
how u can say that you are not in marriage age, now u are in marriage age, thats u can enjoy.
@cearn25 (3456)
• Philippines
10 Jan 12
I will the one who will decide whom I am going to marry. My parents and relatives are there just to support me. They can't dictate whom to marry. I have my ownself with mature mind. I will marry a person whom I believe I love more than anything else.
1 person likes this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
11 Jan 12
Same to you friend..All girls are hoping for a person with heart full of love..Thanks..
@ShyBear88 (59347)
• Sterling, Virginia
11 Jan 12
That isn't an arranged marriage is you get the blessing of your family which I think is just silly when your in live and want to marriage that person. An arranged marriage is a marriage to a person you might not no nor want to be with and arrange marriage is normally something the parents set up and not there child choicing. I'm glad where u live arranged marriages aren't done. People choice who they want to be with regardles of what anyone else thinks. When your love it doesn't matter who does or doesn't like the person that you love a long as you love them and want them. Your not marrying that person family just that person.
@trinkabelle (432)
•
11 Jan 12
i completely agree with you on this, i would never allow any of my family to arrange a marriage for me, it just wouldn't happen, plus i am English and our culture do not do things like that, we are free to do what we like and choose our own partners, love comes naturally, so yep, i do agree with you
@ShyBear88 (59347)
• Sterling, Virginia
11 Jan 12
Oh tribkbelle you english and us Americans think a lot a like in a lot of ways.
@parascevi (313)
• Greece
10 Jan 12
I prefer to marry of love and not of interest. Some people prefer money and a good cosy life with someone they are not in love with, but i prefer to be in love with the man i will marry. I had some opportunities in my life to make mariages and relationships out of interest only but i simply could not do it. I think that is a matter of character and personality, some people can and want to do it and some other do not.
1 person likes this