Are low fat and "lite" foods really better?
By courtknee525
@courtknee525 (3742)
United States
January 22, 2012 3:07pm CST
A few years ago my chiropractor went over a whole meal plan with me and told me to stay away from anything low fat or low anything. I don't remember exactly what she told me, but I remember her saying something along the lines of that it's not healthier for you because they do so much more to the food and add artificial things to make the food low fat or whatever and it's actually worse for you.
Has anyone else heard this? I just got to thinking about it today because my boyfriend's sister is trying to lose weight and she bought a whole bunch of food (mostly frozen stuff and junk food) that all say low fat. To me, it didn't seem like the right way to start and she should've gone with fresh, more natural foods.
My chiropractor has always stressed the importance of organic (I hardly follow that) and staying away from fat free because it's actually worse.
What do you guys think or what have you heard about it?
3 people like this
7 responses
@kaylachan (71519)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
23 Jan 12
I honestly do not believe they are. I think companies say that to make a person think they are doing right by their bodies by eating such foods. More of a marketing stragity then a health benefit. What people don't realize, and quite frankly this is what companies are counting on, that people are going to over eat thinking 'as long as I eat this' I'll loose waight.
In fact, our bodies need fats, sugars and all of the things health experts claim are bad for you. However, what they don't impress is 'too much of a good thing'. Natural foods like fruit vedgies etc are good for you, only if you eat regurally and balance them out over the course of the day. Eating three meals is recommended (or six small ones), but really who actually is religious about that kind of thing? Not very many.
If your friend wants to really loose weight and keep it off, she just needs to stick to a regular schedule, eat normally and make sure to be active. Fat bulids if you just sit around and act lazy. If you're moving (no matter how you chose to do so) you'r in effect exercising. Don't pay attenion to people who claim there is a right and wrong way to do it.
The only thing you can do that's "wrong" is over doing and pushing yourself. this comes from being in a hurry. If you slow down and let nature take its course, you'll have a higher success rate then those who try diets, or pig out on so-called diet food designed to loose weight. pfft. No two people can honestly agree on what is healthy.. and what is right.
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
23 Jan 12
Any time you replace something natural with something artificial isn't good for our bodies and I really don't believe it helps with losing weight. I've always been taught that eating regularly with fruits and vegetables as well as other things, and doing cardio exercise is the best way to lose weight.
Too many people get sucked into the whole "low fat will make me lose weight" idea. In the long run, it really won't because eventually, you'll crave your favorite foods and then stray from your low fat diet, which to begin with, isn't very healthy for you. That's one of the main reasons diets are unsuccessful. Eventually we'll all crave the foods we were once used to eating and then go on an eating binge. The best diet to have is one where you eat the foods you regularly eat but just monitor the portions, don't overeat, and do cardio exercise.
@ShinDarkfox (152)
• United States
23 Jan 12
Short answer: No.
Longer answer is, for what they take out of the recipe, they add other chemicals in their place that carry little to no fattening qualities. These chemicals rarely are things your system can absorb or utilize thus always risks that they may settle and deposit somewhere in your body or your body may react adversely to it. I always tell my family not to buy into it because of this.
And yes, it is way more healthier to eat fresh things and more natural-based foods. I really do not approve of our current food being synthesized so much, our bodies are really not meant for it.
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
23 Jan 12
For sure. It's always worse for us when the natural ingredients are taken out and then replaced with artificial ones that the food industry claims are healthier. Really, it's not because you're taking something natural away that our bodies need and then replacing it with artificial things that our bodies aren't used to.
@ladym33 (10979)
• United States
22 Jan 12
Most of the time they are not better. In the case of dairy foods they are usually better but if it is a lite or a low fat baked good or other type of carbohydrate the lightness is not going to make that much of a difference and they use fillers in there that are not all that great. A carb is a carb and it will effect the body basically the same way weather it is lite or low fat or not.
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
23 Jan 12
I think that most of the low fat, lite, and low sugars are worse than the regular ones. Just think, to make these products low fat/sugar and lite, they have to take out all the natural fats and sugars and then replace them with artificial ones that end up being worse for us.
@cedythra (196)
• Finland
22 Jan 12
I've been reading much about this issue and I have been convinced that low fat stuff really is bad for people. Unless that food is naturally low fat. And yes organic is way better. It's pretty logical if you ask me. There hasn't always been factories where food is made/processed right? So foods that have naturally fat are good for you. Like milk or meat. If fat is taken away it's not as tasty anymore so something has to be added to make food tasty again. So something not so healthy is added and there is no natural balance in the food anymore. Our bodies are not used to that kind of thing.
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
23 Jan 12
I definitely agree with you. Our food is overprocessed and I hate to think of all the nasty junk that manufacturers put into it. I know that eating organic is the best way to go, but it can be hard and not to mention expensive. Personally, I don't eat completely healthy all the time, but I try to make good choices when it's possible. But I always stay away from anything low fat and especially low sugar, because when they take all the natural fats and sugars out, they have to add a whole bunch of other stuff that's a lot worse for us. The food industry is certainly endangering us with their products and it's sad that many aren't aware that the "good" choices they're making are actually worse in the long run.
@PointlessQuestions (15397)
• United States
23 Jan 12
What do they do when they take out the fat? They add sugar and lits of other additives. Your health professional is right. Instead of using light or low fat butter or margarine I eat dry toast. Eating margarine and even the low fat kinds is like eating plastic. You are just getting a lot of plastic like chemicals that you can't pronounce. I try to buy whole foods a lot of times instead of the heavily processed ones.
@courtknee525 (3742)
• United States
23 Jan 12
The artificial additives are a lot worse than the natural fats and sugars. Take Splenda for example, this artificial sweetener contains aspartame which has been linked to cancer, alzheimer's, and it basically eats away the brain. Aspartame is also found in diet soda. My mom drinks diet coke like it's water and already she's noticing a slight memory loss and sometimes she'll be really tired.
We don't use margarine anymore either after we learned that it's literally one molecule away from being plastic, and this isn't even the low fat margarines either. Instead, we use this brand called Smart Balance and it's actually not bad for you. It has vitamin d and a few other things that I don't remember. When it's cold it's a harder than your regular margarine but it softens up if you leave it out and I think it tastes just as good as the plastic margarine lol.
I'll be the first to admit that I don't always make healthy eating choices, but I do like to be aware of all the really bad things and my family tries our best to buy the more natural versions of food.
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
23 Jan 12
I think it's better to eat foods in their natural state, which is to say, regular fat not low fat, that sort of thing. I think it's better without chemicals added to make the lowfat stuff taste better.
Also, your body does need fat, so if you have natural fats like in whole milk and butter, it's good for you in moderation.