Switched at Birth
@Glitznglitter (389)
Canada
March 5, 2012 8:06pm CST
I have been watching the new series Switched at Birth on channel YTV (25 in Ontario) anyway I was thinking what if that happened and years later you found out?
Would you want to meet your biological daughter or would you just continue with the child you brought home from the hospital and raised as your own all these years?
Would you sue the hospital or would you just let it go?
How would you deal with this?
10 responses
@crazzydolphin (3636)
• United States
6 Mar 12
i started watching this show when it first came out but have missed most of it since but it is very hard to say exactly what i would do. that is one of those things that you dont really know until it happens to you...i would want to meet my biological daughter and get to know here but at the same time it would be very hard to just give up the child i have raised since birth..i think the way that the 2 families is handling it is about as easy as it gets. there are some things i would have done a little diffrent (from what i have seen) but other than that they are involved it both kids lives and i think that works the best for everyone :)
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
Knowing I raised one of the children loved her unconditionally to know that I have loved someone elses I don't know that I could share the one I raised. The bond would be there would it be there for the other child that you actually gave birth to.
Definately a need to be in the situation to know
@crazzydolphin (3636)
• United States
9 Mar 12
yes i agree it would be a very good bond with the 1 you have raised but i know if it was me i would feel bad by not meeting my biologicak child. i guess to sum it all up this is a very hard thing for anyone to have to deal with and i am sure it happens way more than we hear about on a day to day basis.
but like we both said i dont think any one can truely say what they would do but there are some people that would know exactly what they would do either way. for me i couldnt truely decide until it happened to me....i would really hate to be put in that situation tho. how about you?
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
9 Mar 12
i have watched the same here in a local tv series in primetime. eventually they got to live the lives they deserve. but then, i think that if you really do not know and has loved the child as your own and thought that he/she is really yours, i think i would want to get to know my child and see if i can still have him or her with me.
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
Having 2 families is defantly a viable option. Meeting and getting to know the child you really gave birth to over the child you were given in a hospital switch.
@mysticmaggie (2498)
• United States
6 Mar 12
Of course, I would want to meet my biological child, but could I give up the child I raised as my own. No, I don't think so, unless ordered to by the courts. That child would have received all the love my husband and I could give and would be as much ours as if I had given birth.
Sue the hospital? It's possible, but first, would I want our child to think we were so disappointed in him/her that we would sue the hospital? Would I want to bring them insecurity of that type. Hopefully not. I would hope for the wisdom to thank God for the child we were blessed to raise.
Only if our biological child had been given to abusive parents would I sue anyone, and that would be to get our real child back.
Hugs,
Maggie
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
Definately, in the case of the show they are both very well mannered children, older been raised for many many years with the switched parents. I have to believe it should be left up to the kids as they would be the most affected.
@penrockerchic (1903)
• Philippines
6 Mar 12
I've read about this show and it's pretty interesting. The concept isn't too original in my opinion. Still, it's one of my "to-watch" TV series especially since I am always craving for new TV shows to get hooked to. Now, for your question, I totally have no clue whether I should continue raising a kid that's not my own. I guess that would depend on the years. In my perspective, I think it would be harder to be detached from a child you've known for several years and raised as your own. But, I think if the switch happened a few months ago, then there's not much problem. Definitely. suing the hospital would be on top of my list 'cause for me, someone should always be present in the nursery room to ensure that the newborn babies are secured and taken good care of while the moms are still on the hospital bed gaining their strength.
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
When I had my kids they were always in the room with me and never taken away from my sight, all the tests they had to do were done right there with me by their side. I would be livid to know that someone switched my baby but I don't know that I could not love a child I gave birth to, I wouldn't be able to remove myself from the child I raised.
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
6 Mar 12
There are plenty of cases like these, there is also not one solution or answer what to do. I think it's useless to sue the hospital although it might be interesting to know how come babies are switched at birth.
The fact is many women/parents think it's not their child and if it grows up they do see the difference. But also a fact is you get used to your kid (no matter if you are the bio-parents or not) and the kid is used to you(r family).
I once read about one family who did find out years later it was true what they thought. One kid found her own bio parents but kept living with the other family. She had an extra family. But the other kid was not accepted by her own bio-family. They refused to believe it although you could already see the difference by the size of the families.
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
I know this happens, mistakes do happy its all in how the resolve the accident and what happens from there. In this case it was years before the switch came to light. The children have already been raised by their respective switched parents.
@ecaron (678)
• Canada
6 Mar 12
I heard about this show but haven't watched it. I don't know how I would deal with a switch like that. I suppose once a person makes a bond with their baby, it's hard to break it. I would probably still want to be in the wrong child's life just because we bonded as parent and child especially over long period of time.
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
I have to agree the switched baby is the one you believed to be yours, you raised it, nutured it, and brought it up to be a beautiful young person. How could you forget all those years?
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
6 Mar 12
That is tough one because by the time everyone knew, there would already be bonds established. I would have a tough time letting either one of them go I think. I would definitely want to establish a relationship with the other set of parents though because I am sure they would be devastated as well and would still want to see the baby they had raised all that time too.
I think I might get a lawyer and raise a stink about it though. That is a mistake that would hurt a lot of people. Especially if there was a medical condition involved.
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
Absolutely as in the case of the show, one of the daughters is deaf and uses allot of sign language the biological mom doesn't sign very well and has a hard time communicating with her daughter, whereas the daughter she raised is completely fine. These two lives were affected medically, the child with the disbility of being deaf was raised by a single mother, that had to be rough for her. The other very well to do. Both seem very happy in their respective lives.
@Tina30219 (82303)
• Onaway, Michigan
6 Mar 12
Yes I would want to meet my biological child .As for sueing the hospital not sure what I would do.This is a good show I watched it when I had cable television.
@toniganzon (72551)
• Philippines
6 Mar 12
Suddenly this discussion made me recall when i gave birth to my son. The moment he was laid on my tummy I really tried to look for any birthmark that would make me remember my son, just in case he got switched!
But in the hospital that i gave birth to, getting the babies switched by mistake is impossible, unless a person with a criminal mind would deliberately do it.
It's very difficult to deal with that kind of situation because putting my place in that parent's situation, i would have loved the child already and raised him or her as my own child. But I would be very confused and i think the first thing i would do is talk to my brothers and sisters, consult a lawyer and talk to the child, because he or she would be affected the most.
@Glitznglitter (389)
• Canada
9 Mar 12
Exactly I guess talking to all parties involved would be in order, to make the right choice on whether to meet and stay apart of each others lives.