In what circumstances can an electric fan cause death, and why?
By JohnRok1
@JohnRok1 (2051)
March 10, 2012 10:45am CST
If you look up "Fan Death" in Wikipedia, you will find it dismissed as an urban myth restricted to South Korea and for the circumstances described in the article there may be some truth in this. However, a friend of mine has just lost his cousin in Malaysia in the following circumstances: The young man came home from work hot and tired, stripped, and switched on the fan. He fell asleep under it before he could switch it off and then died. Another friend of mine, who used to work as a Pastor in a politically sensitive tropical country, told me he had buried at least three young men in similar circumstances and that it happened when for some reason people were living alone - normally someone else would switch a fan off when they saw their housemate asleep under it. He also said that occasionally a person falling asleep unclothed on a bare floor in the absence of a fan could die in the same way, but a fan being on markedly increased the probability of death. Apparently the person would wake up paralysed and unable to switch the fan off for themselves, and then die. The friend who's lost his cousin confirms this.
The Wikipedia article and talk mentioned hypothermia and dehydration as possible mechanisms, but I wonder whether the real cause isn't cramp - most cramps are of themselves not fatal (the unwelcome ability of crucified persons to survive for extended periods is historical evidence of this - but of course, they were awake and moving), but some may be.
Have other mylotters come across this, and if so, do you have other explanations of your own? And is some form of campaign called for, and if so, what?
1 person likes this
3 responses
@himzey (1321)
• India
11 Mar 12
Might be because of loose connections of screws.. continuous rotation and swinging might render some screws loose or might be because the quality of material used to make those screws was poor and could not hold the weight of the fan for that long. Have heard of such incidents and that was the primary reason in almost all of them..
1 person likes this
@JohnRok1 (2051)
•
12 Mar 12
I hadn't noticed thattttttttttttttttttttttt! (Wot a Stut t t t t t t t t t t ter!) I don't know how that happened - I hope my keyboard's not about to go on the blinkkkkkkkkkkkkkk!
You mean the fan fell on them? I don't think that was the case in the incidents I was writing about - I think my friends would have known about it if it were. But if so, it's frustrating - there's nothing one can do about badly manufactured goods outside the "plutocracies".
@urbandekay (18278)
•
14 Mar 12
I had never heard of this. I think dehydration is the most likely cause
all the best urban
1 person likes this
@JohnRok1 (2051)
•
14 Mar 12
As an UK guy, I'm not surprised you've never heard of it. It seems to happen to some people from cooler climes (e.g. higher altitude areas) who land up in big hot cities, feel desperate to cool down, abandon their clothes, lie down under a fan, and fall asleep. Whether it is something that would happen to anyone who does this, or whether there is a genetic weakness in one particular tribal group is something I was hoping to determine.
But have you never lain too long in a hot bath, so that it is no longer hot, and then felt stiff all over when you get out? Or have you never had a part of your body exposed to draft while relaxing, and ended up with a cramp in that part? Do you see what I'm getting at?
@urbandekay (18278)
•
14 Mar 12
I have slept under the stars and woke cold and stiff as a board but still I did not die and I could move
all the best urban
1 person likes this
@urbandekay (18278)
•
14 Mar 12
Also, in Japan I left with the air con on full blast despite being warned not to
all the best urban
1 person likes this
@Cutie18f (9551)
• Philippines
10 Mar 12
That's strange. I am sure there are other reasons for he deaths and it just happened that there were fans in all those deaths.
@JohnRok1 (2051)
•
10 Mar 12
Do you or your friends regularly go to sleep in almost the altogether with an electric fan trained on you, then, without taking any harm? Or is this sort of behaviour restricted to people staying in your area from a colder climate, of which kind of person you don't happen to have any?