Should I refuse a task from my boss?

Vietnam
April 11, 2012 11:34pm CST
She's my old colleague. But she assigned because she worked not well. Now, she has turned back with her friend to introduce a business plan. I read that plan. I think it's naive and paranoid! Her friend presented it in an incoherent way. I can't believe in him and my old colleague. However, my boss permitted them trying it! They picked some samples and they have not called back my boss for three weeks. My boss wants me asking them about the samples and the plan. I don't like to work with them. I don't like the plan. I know that they can't do anything which is benefit for my company. So, I tried to avoid them before. But now, my boss want me work with them! Can I refuse this task from my boss?
2 people like this
9 responses
• Canada
13 Apr 12
I think it would be a good idea for your to share your concerns about the business plan directly with your boss. However, do not say that you "think it's naive and paranoid!" Those are purely emotional responses and they will carry no weight in a business setting. Find concrete examples of how this plan will be detrimental to your company and ask your boss to consider them. If he/she refuses, then you can certainly ask not to be assigned to work with your old colleague - and your boss might not be confident in placing you in that situation anyway, once your feelings about the project are known. Ultimately, if you are still assigned to work with them, you don't have much choice about doing it -- unless you don't value your job that much or your working relationship with your boss.
1 person likes this
• Canada
13 Apr 12
Unfortunately, yes, that's true. If he feels their plan is worthwhile, he is going to go ahead with it anyway and you'll be stuck having to accept the task I hope it ultimately works out better than it sounds right now. I'm sure you are frustrated.
• Vietnam
13 Apr 12
When I said that about the plan, I must think about it much. This result is not from emotional responses. I will discuss to my boss about it. But if he doesn't think like me about the plan, I still must accept this task.
1 person likes this
@rekhum (2420)
• India
12 Apr 12
If I were in your shoes I'd accept the task, considering your boss is also your friend, and the type of task your boss is assigning you. On a positive note, it seems challenging.
1 person likes this
• Vietnam
13 Apr 12
Maybe you're right. I work for him. I must accept all tasks and works which he gives me. Right?
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
12 Apr 12
This sounds like a tricky situation. Does your boss know of your concerns? I don't think you can refuse this task without explaining why.
1 person likes this
• Vietnam
13 Apr 12
That's right. But it's difficult talking him. We can't talk to him in peace way in 3 minutes :D He only want us hearing him.
@ryanong (9665)
• Vietnam
12 Apr 12
You can talk all your thinking of that thing to your boss but all because of work, not based on the private relation. I think your boos will have decision about it. In case, your boss still want you to work with them, you can refuse that task. I am sure that you boss will understand your decision.
1 person likes this
• Vietnam
13 Apr 12
As me said on an other discussion, my boss won't hear the view of his employees, but he only likes ideas from his partners. He won't hear me. I express him that I don't like the plan and that persons. He understand it. But he still wants me working with them. He knows that the plan is bad but he still wants to try. I can't what he really wants. Why he must lose time and money with them?
@lifes97 (884)
• United Arab Emirates
12 Apr 12
you can talk to her and discuss anything you like in a good way, i mean you should not just follow what he or she says, they are bosses yes but they are human some of them are feeling but some are not, so the really one who should decide to say your feelings or no is you, you know her pesronality better, does she accept aruguaing or talking about orders or she is just bossy type of bosses, and is the task really worht it or not, its really up to you only to see and find out how and where or how to do that so
1 person likes this
• India
27 Jul 12
Being honest with your boss about issues at work is usually the best policy. When you feel in your gut that something won’t work, it is better to respectfully explain to your boss why you think it won’t work. He/ she will be grateful that you saved them from making a blunder that would have cost them. However, if they insist, then go ahead and do as they ask.
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
13 Apr 12
i think what you can do is to try to let him know you are still doing things at the time he or she is asking you to do something. he/she should understand what you need to prioritize at work, right?
@airasheila (5454)
• Philippines
13 Apr 12
good day tkonlinevn, with reference to your main topic, if i will be place in your situation, i will follow what's the boss instruction. since, i am working to the company where my boss is also engaged, so i will do whatever his instructions are. although, i don't feel comfortable to work on the team that handles the samples and plan, still, i will follow the instruction of my boss. thus on this part, i will just bear in mind that i am doing that task due to my boss instruction, hence in that way, i can somehow concentrate more rather than wander.
@dpinoy13 (13)
• Philippines
13 Apr 12
As long as this task really doesnt give you extra money, refuse it. you can be closer with your boss in many other ways :)