The evolution of music. Is modern musicof the same quality is older?

Greece
May 2, 2012 10:38am CST
I have been listening to music for my whole life. I have had musical studies and I compose my own music as well. I think that music evolves together with technology. With the creation of new sounds, new music genres get created. It's a good thing to evolve, but sometimes I miss the oldies. The warm sound of the analogue recordings from years ago. The 70's and the 80's mostly, since I grew up listening to that music, because it was playing all the day in my house because of my parents. In some genres like metal, I believe modern music is a lot better than the old-school. However in rock, blues and jazz, I think think the oldies are far superior!
5 responses
@CarlHalling (3617)
• United Kingdom
2 May 12
Golden Age Rocker? - Well not exactly; this was just me, many years ago now, performing in a pub.
I think every era produces great music, and this one is no exception. If you look hard enough, there are some supremely gifted acts operating today. But I'd say it's probably harder for them to achieve the kind of mainstream legendary success once enjoyed by Rock superstars than it would have been a few decades ago: there aren't the same kinds of opportunities...possibly because the sensationalism surrounding Rock music and culture is not as intense as it was during its hey day of the 60s and 70s; and to some extent also the 80s. Things have quietened down. At the same time, thanks to the internet, I'd say it's infinitely easier for young artists to be heard today than in times past. Of course, there's a lot of competition; but I'd say nonetheless that the opportunities for fame and success in music are quite phenomenally greater today than 30 or 40 years ago; there's simply no comparison. I wouldn't say that the older music is necessarily better...however, it was new; and revolutionary, which could not be said of modern music, which has perforce to borrow from the past. The golden age of Rock was such a startling era, for good and bad alike...both artistically and culturally...because it was so fresh and trailblazing.
• United Kingdom
4 May 12
Thanks for the best response, coldnpale. Yes, music fashions come and go. Rock was once seen - pretty well exclusively as I recall - as the music of youth; but it's not now. Now, it's another classic music form, like Classical; Folk; Jazz; Country. And for all ages.
1 person likes this
• Greece
3 May 12
Many interesting points you got there. I think also that it depends on what kind of music one prefers to listen. If someone for example was a lot into the 70's classic rock, he won't be able to find anything similar compared to that, maybe because rock has evolved into something modern, but still, you wouldn't be able to hear the signature guitar solo's and the screaming vocals...since they are kinda out of fashion now.
@ShadowSky (221)
• Bulgaria
2 May 12
To me the older music of much higher quality.Because right now I feel like if a song has actual music instruments or lyrics that don't repeat themselves at least 10 times then a song can't get popular. And this,even if it is an exaggeration, make me feel like quality music is going down the drain. There are still some extremely talented people that get a chance to become popular less and less because people have lost their sense of good music apperantly and prefer to just listen to songs that have computers instead of guitars and autotune instead of real talent. Things have gotten to the point of comparing Justin Bieber to Michael Jackson and this seems downright offensive to MJ, even if I don't listen to much pop music I still realize this. I'm sorry if my response has offended someone and I'm sorry that it turned into something more of a rant then a response...
1 person likes this
• Greece
2 May 12
Indeed. The repeated riffs and melodies in music are working probably as a way of brainwashing. You hear the same riff 100 times during one song, and then you hear the same songs everywhere you go, until the melody is inside your head and then you sing along even if you don't really like the track. It's all about promotion and marketing.
• Bulgaria
3 May 12
I've never really thought about it but you're right.And after you hear the same thing over and over again you start to remember it and recognize it and then it gets stuck inside your head.For me once a song gets stuck inside my head I can't get rid of it until I hear it for real and if there are more people like me than the strategy is working.
1 person likes this
@Nero11 (316)
3 May 12
Great songs are great songs. Great melodies are great melodies. Doesn't matter when they were written. Beethoven's 5th or Adele's Someone Like You - both extraordinary works centuries apart.
@Cranos (273)
• Belgium
2 May 12
Personally I'm more a fan of older music, even with metal (I love the 'feel good' hair metal from the 80s). But what the current problem is, is that there's no evolution anymore at all. New bands (especially in rock and metal) don't get a chance if they're too different from the popular music. Now I know that that has always been the case, but the current music labels are taking it to a new extreme because their business isn't going well. Bottom line is, in the 70s, 80s and 90s you see a clear change in music while in the last decade there's almost no difference at all.
1 person likes this
• Greece
2 May 12
You have a point there. Metal is getting a nice improvement over the quality of the production, with all the new recording equipment, amplifiers etc, however everything realeased from big labels get industrialized. It's like they use the same recipe with every band. Even bands that start out as something special, in the long run, if they sign with a big label, their sound changes according to the label's commercial strategy, which usually ends up making the music kinda unoriginal.
@doroffee (4222)
• Hungary
2 May 12
For me, as long as the song/musical piece has compositional value, it can convey emotion with its melody, and if it has lyrics, they are artistic, I don't think it's by default worse than classic music or oldies. Of course, mass-made autotune stuff with generic lyrics I wouldn't consider quality, but there are a lot of (even commercial) songs that are pretty quality in all aspects.
1 person likes this
• Greece
2 May 12
If a music creation has a the valuesw you mentioned, then by all means i can accept it as a great work. I am sure as well that there are commercial music pieces that are still very artistic. Worth mentioning are today's soundtracks in movies and video games. Therer are some REALLY talented people in this particular field that keep music alive.