Looks Like Child Abuse

Owie - A portrait of a 2 year old boy with a scrape on his face where he landed on his face when he tripped over a rug and fell down.
@nonersays (3335)
United States
May 11, 2012 10:15pm CST
My little boy tripped over a welcome mat and fell on his face today. He got the worst "booboo" of his life so far. A pretty nasty scrape on his face, from under his left eye to his upper lip, under his nose and on the tip of his nose. Also one of his arms is scraped where he fell on it. I told my husband he looks like someone smacked him across the face. Later he joked that he couldn't take him to buy my Mother Day gift now because he'd probably get arrested for child abuse. I told him, no, they wouldn't arrest him on the spot but DFACS might show up at our door about it. That did make me wonder though, when you see a child in public who looks battered, like my sons face, do you automatically assume child abuse, or just think its probably a clumsy kid? Just how many scrapes and bruises does a child have to have before you begin to worry about them?
3 people like this
11 responses
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
13 May 12
Very well asked. I always wonder too when it's child abuse or not. What people might think. By now I think many people will think that way since we are confronted with it daily. Even if it's not true, governments worldwide tell us when it is or not. And if childabuse shows up, it is false alarm you are still a suspect. Personally I would not think about child abuse that easily. Why? Because I was a victim of child abuse for 15 years and I know how a kid that is abused moves, acts.. it's way more as brushes. I know that in most times you are not able to see the abuse at all because they keep you inside and lock you up till it's over. Kids are kids and they stumble over their own feet, burn their fingers on the stove, fall from the stairs, out of their bed or from their bike. They "fight" with other kids. Accidents happen at school, at home, etc. It's normal and they need those experiences as well.
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160611)
• United States
13 May 12
Noner if you can keep him active it will be great. We go through life, once we get to school, being told to sit still and be quiet. It is no wonder we end up obese.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
I'm sorry you were a vitcim as well. I was a lucky child with a very loving family. I told my husband to be prepared. He was a very non-active child, and our son is very active. I told him that our little boy is probably going to get A LOT of scrapes and bruises in his life because he likes to run and play and not just sit in one spot all day watching tv or playing video games.
1 person likes this
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
14 May 12
My husband wants to home school. While I'm not against it I'm not sure we can do it with both of us working. However, if we DO homeschool, that will help a lot in keeping him active.
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
12 May 12
People with children will wonder if the kid fell or something of that nature. I am a parent and I have two boys that are 4 and 5. I know kids fall and get hurt all the time for a number of reasons but usually running and face planting. Just today my children were playing and running around only for my 4 year old to run into the door knob and so he has a small bruise on his head. He also then said the door knob hit him in true little kid style. Now people who don't have kids and have no real idea about kids will call child services in a heartbeat because your child looks like that. They will not understand that your child fell, not ask for your side of the story, but they will call and say you are abusing your kid. It can be as small as one bruise. My idiotic neighbor (who has no kids) wanted to call child services because I refused to let my (then 3 year old) child stay up super late and so he threw a tantrum. The police came to my house, saw my child and saw that he was perfectly ok, and told them that my child is fine he is throwing a tantrum. They didn't understand it but I wasn't giving in. They called child services as well and they said it wasn't child abuse to put my children to bed at 7pm. Those are the people you may have to worry about.
@GardenGerty (160611)
• United States
13 May 12
Consistent isolation from the family for no reason is child abuse. Giving the child a bedtime and making sure he follows it is good parenting that we do not see much of anymore. Good job.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
12 May 12
You gotta watch out for those doorknobs. They jump out and hit me all the time. I've always got knob bruises on my arms. Now that you mention it, since I became a mom my assumption IS always first that the little ones have fallen, or were playing rough and hurt themselves. Unless I see other harsh actions from the parents themselves. I didn't used to jump to conclusions every time before I was a mom, but I did sometimes. Not to the point of ever actually turning someone in, but I would wonder. I can't imagine calling child services because of a tantrum. Did they just hear him screaming and thought you were hurting him? My son is just entering the full blown tantrum stage himself.
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
12 May 12
Well the thing is, I live in a side by side duplex so it's like a house connected to another house and still its own house. Sorry if that's confusing. However there is one wall separating both sides and the wall isn't the thickest wall out there. So she could hear me telling him that he had to go to bed and that was final. In full blown tantrum stage, he throws things (usually his toys or pillow), kicks, screams, etc. I refuse to give him what he wants when he acts like that and somethings like bed time aren't negotiable. It's part of a schedule he always follows. So when the police came for a report of "child abuse", I calmly talked to the officer, showed him my son and that the kid was fine, and he told them it was just a tantrum. Then they called child services the next day and one of them said I was abusing my child since I gave him a 7pm bedtime when he clearly wanted to stay up later, once the people from child services got here. As I said, child services said it was not child abuse for the child to have an early bedtime.
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160611)
• United States
13 May 12
I do not automatically assume child abuse, but some people do. I was babysitting some kids from our church ages ago. The youngest child always tried to be as big as the other two and she fell on some concrete and bruised her face. Evidently someone from our church nursery reported it. So one day on his lunch the dad had to take her to the child welfare office. (SRS here). The social worker said "yes, it looks like a fall on concrete to me." End of story. My son, at two years old, decided to turn somersault's on an aluminum chaise longue. He had a bruise on every vertebrae all the way up his spine. When in Kindergarten he was running on an icy play ground, slid into the tether ball pole. He had a bruise top to bottom on his face. These blond blue eyed kids look awful if they are clumsy.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
I would think (hope) that most experienced case workers would be able to tell the difference in a "normal" owie and a sign of child abuse. However, one of my dad's girlfriends had a daughter who tripped over something while she was carrying the baby, and when she tripped she fell, and fell with the baby. The baby ended up with a broken bone and child services removed her from her mothers care even though it was honestly a horrible accident. I can see how it would look worse on a fair headed child, especially if they are accident prone. My son is VERY accident prone and has lots of bruises, mostly on his legs and knees from falling and bumping into things.
@sacmom (14192)
• United States
21 May 12
That's a good question...and a tough one at that. This reminds me of an old "I Love Lucy" episode, even though it doesn't deal with kids. If I remember right, Lucy had asked Ricky to toss her a book. She missed and it smacked her right in the face. She ended up getting a very notice mark from it. She joked around with Ricky about how it must look to others. When their neighbors (and best friends) came over and saw it they got the wrong impression. They thought Ricky had beat her up! In the end, Fred and Either believed Ricky and Lucy about what really happened...but only because it happened to them as well! lol Accidents can be a funny thing. People tend to conjure up all kinds of thoughts and not want to believe the truth, especially when it comes to kids. Their intentions may be in the right place, but it can be frustrating just the same. Happy mylotting! PS Poor little guy. I hope he's feeling okay.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
22 May 12
Surprisingly nobody said anything to us. Though I did notice one mom with a little girl giving us funny looks when we went to Target with him. I'm happy to say he has almost completely healed. He still has a small red place on the side of his nose, and on his arm, but the scabs have fallen off his face, and it looks like there will only be a faint scar that will hopefully fade with time.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
12 May 12
Children can really be rowdy. They would just run or walk hurriedly, without looking at what they will be stepping at. Thus, accidents happens. And basing from your boy's picture, don't worry because it sure looks that he tripped over something and fell on his face.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
12 May 12
Good to know it looks like he fell, and not like we're smacking him around. I know I would never hurt my son, and neither would the rest of the family, but so many people are doing such horrible things to their kids these days I'm paranoid that people might think the worst when they see him.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
12 May 12
Parents have different styles of disciplining their children actually. ANd they can sometimes go overboard. But with the strict laws on child abuse, parents gets to tame their discipline styles.
@bjc66bjc (6730)
• United States
13 May 12
Hi nonersays, No I don't think child abuse...my first thought would be juust to actually ask what happen,,,most people who are not abuser will be happy to tell you where as an abuser would try to not answer any query...Children do fall and someimes get hurt pretty bad....
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
True, if anyone asked what happened I wouldn't hesitate to tell them. At least he didn't run into a door or fall down some stair or anything else that are commonly used as excuses for child abuse.
@peavey (16936)
• United States
12 May 12
Kids are always getting scraped and bruised. It's part of being a kid, I think. I can understand your worry, though, because it seems like "child protective agencies" hover around watching to see who they can catch next, more like vultures than protectors. I know that children are abused and some parents have no right to be parents, but for the most part, parents love and protect their children. It's human nature. I don't worry about a kid until/unless he is bruised or cut up over and over again. Also, if he acts afraid or brash or something you wouldn't expect of a child, there is probably something wrong.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
I was a tomboy and ALWAYS covered in scrapes and bruises. Its a different world these days though, when so many people do horrible things to their kids all the time, and the rest of the world is so eager to place blame on anyone for any reason. My son has LOTS of bruises, but he's a rough and tumble little boy. He never acts afraid though, and other than wanting to yell "Help me!" whenever he doesn't get his way I don't think he acts like an abused child.
@cupkitties (7421)
• United States
12 May 12
An abused child will display much more than just physical injuries, so it'd be a rather ridiculous assumption to make. I'd look to his/her behavior and those who are raising him to determine if something like abuse has happened.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
That is true, I suppose. My little boy is fearless, but has a disturbing habit of yelling, "Help me, help me" if he doesn't get his way. That might raise a few eyebrows. lol
@shylade (3132)
• Philippines
12 May 12
Kids are really clumsy and are prone to such incidence. My son had an accident almost two months ago that left a mark on his face and chest, but we thank God its disappearing now. He had a burn accident that resulted to second degree. He got the thermos with hot water and unfortunately the stop lock was not close so the horrible thing happened. I was really devasted that day and to think it was my husband's birthday. It is natural for us to think there is something wrong when we see a child with such a bad scar on his face, a bruise etc. And i know people will think how bad the parents are for letting such thing happened to their children. But hey, they don't what happened. I just thank God that my son does not incur severe wounds and that we are really extra careful now.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
Ouch! Burns are the WORST. I drink a lot of coffee and I'm always afraid my boy is going to accidentally get it spilled don him. I'm glad your son's marks are fading and he is healing from his bun.
@569841 (4)
• Nanjing Jiangsu, China
12 May 12
well,kids are kids,the scrape is a witness point of their growth .
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
12 May 12
True. And anyone who ever raised a child will know that scrapes and bruises are very common. I'm just used to scraped knees, not scraped noses.
@NailTech (6874)
• United States
12 May 12
Awe, the poor kid. I have had some things like that happen to me as a kid. It seems I was allergic to peanuts, as the teacher sent me to the nurse to check out a rash on my face once in 1st grade. The teacher said she thought it looked like a "mark" like someone had smacked me, but it wasn't. My mom took me to the DR and he said I had the allergy so she had to stop giving me peannut butter and jelly sandwiches which I loved. Awhile later she started giving them to me again as this was her nature, she would only stop something like that for a short time and then continue on as normal not even thinking of if I would have another rash or not. Funny things is I didn't get another rash and later in life I started getting diagnosed with eczema, and started getting them again in my late 30's. Now I stayed away from the chocolate and peanuts again, but later when I gave in my mom would nag me about giving in to it, when she did the same as me as a kid. Anyways, my point is just that some things can't all be interpreted as child abuse, it very well may be something like a fall, etc. I wouldn't turn the parents in for child abuse. However if I hear and see my neighbors here smacking their kids and stuff I did want to call the police on them, they seemed pretty rough on the young ones. One Spanish lady dragged her small young daughter by the hair out in the front of their yard one day, and another Jamaican lady started hitting on her 14 yr old son in the front of their house for having a few friends over. My mom saw it too and she was so angry at the mom. The kid looked like he didn't even wanna go back in the house with the rest of the family then. I wasn't sure what to do. I'm not all that friendly with my neighbors anyways but those Jamaican kids were sweet kids, just alittle naughty like most kids can be. Hitting him like she was (more like punching) just wasn't necessary. Those are only a few cases I recall, I'm always afraid that the people and my family here would say I was interfering too much and should let it go. However, if it were an animal I would turn them in in an instant without anyone else's approval.
@nonersays (3335)
• United States
13 May 12
My husbands sister was always getting hurt. Maybe our son inherited it. lol Oh yes, if I ever witnessed actual abuse instead of just scrapes and bruises I would never hesitate to call the police. I beleive there is a difference in a "spanking" and a "beating." If a parent punches a child, or slaps a child in the face, or hits them anywhere with a fist, or other than an open handed swat on the behind, I consider it abuse.