Nanny York City-seriously proposed ban on soda

United States
June 26, 2012 12:32pm CST
Bloomberg has said the drink ban is an attempt to fight obesity in the city. His first-in-the-nation ban, formally announced May 31, would limit sweet drinks to 16 ounces at venues across the city -- from restaurants to street carts to movie theaters. However, the proposal allows refills. The ban would not apply to diet sodas, fruit juices, dairy-based drinks or alcoholic beverages. Nor would it include drinks sold in grocery or convenience stores. Food establishments that don't downsize would face fines of $200. The New York City Restaurant Association is fighting the drink proposal and is considering legal action of it goes into effect.Association spokesman Stefan Friedman recently called the proposal "zealous." He said officials should seek solutions that are actually going to curb obesity. At a meeting Tuesday, members of the New York City Board of Health expressed support for Bloomberg's proposal. They then started brainstorming other ways to cut the fat, according to MyFoxNY.com. Member Bruce Vladeck proposed limiting movie-theater popcorn containers. "The popcorn isn't a whole lot better than the soda," he said. Another member suggested limits for milkshakes and "milk-coffee beverages." First of all goverment has bigger things to worry about like not making it harder for businesses to make a buck. secondly popcorn is a fat free healthy snack it is what you put on it that makes it unhealthy. thirdly if people want it they will buy it and it is just going to cost more to buy 2 16 0z soda's instead of 1 big gulp. this story can be found on foxnews.com. I googled ny soda ban and got this info.
1 person likes this
7 responses
• United States
27 Jun 12
i say we just move out of ny state.... put everything we can in the car and just drive... what do you say... roadtrip?!?!?!?!?!?!
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Jun 12
I'm in!!!! where do you wanna go? not that it matters. anywhere out of NY is good.
• United States
27 Jun 12
YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY i wish lol
1 person likes this
@Shellyann36 (11384)
• United States
27 Jun 12
I don't think that this is a sensible way of targeting obesity. It is just taking away the people's rights to make their own decisions. Sounds rather silly to me. I do hope that the officials come to their senses...
• United States
27 Jun 12
thanks for responding. I agree.
@lampar (7584)
• United States
26 Jun 12
Obviously New Yorkers have got themselves a nanny mayor in their city. AT least his legit. excuse is that he believed the solution to his obese residents is to ban the sales of large can of sweet soft drinks in the stores, cinemas and restaurants across the state, it is quite a wishful thinking on his part that no one will want to think all the obesed consumers will just buy one 16 oz sweet drink obediently to quell their thirst. It is not only ludicrous but infringe on individual consumer and business rights to freedom of choice. Either he has too much free time on hand while sitting in his office, or he firmly believe there is no bigger issues facing NY city other than telling store owners and restaurant owners how to run business in his city and forcing his soft drinks residents to pay more on several small cups instead of one single large can which cost less. It is quite a smart way to make more bucks from soft drinks consumers in his city.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Jun 12
that we do! very good point that it will bring in more bucks. that is what it is all about with the government.
@millertime (1394)
• United States
29 Jun 12
I swear, it must be right on the application. "Are you a complete idiot and have absolutely no common sense?" Yes? Okay, you can be a politician. Bloomberg has got to be the biggest moron on the planet. Does he actually think that this law is going to do anything at all, except inconvenience people and business owners? Is he that stupid? Obviously, yes he is. What's to stop someone from buying the smaller "Bloomberg sized" soda and then refilling it as many times as they like? Nothing... What's to stop someone from buying two sodas in the first place? Nothing... How is this law going to effect anything? And now they want to ban popcorn and other things. This is how we lose our freedom. One little ban at a time. If we let them get away with this, then who knows what they will ban next. Maybe they will just ban McDonald's altogether. Well, people need to wake up and do something about it. Namely, vote this knucklehead out of office. As long as they keep electing dimwits like Bloomberg, they will have to suffer the consequences.
• United States
29 Jun 12
you are so right!
• Valdosta, Georgia
26 Jun 12
Soon the government is going to control everything we say, eat, think or do!! I think it is crazy. If we want to be overweight and die from obesity that is our choice. This is supposed to be a FREE country. If they are controlling things like this, we are NOT free! Soon enough we will all be controlled. What do they care if we choose to be unhealthy and die??? There will be more people born to take our place and pay taxes to them...Who Cares!? I do not understand it at all.
• United States
26 Jun 12
that is so true! I see it more and more everyday the government taking away our rights. it is out of control. I also read this: New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg doesn't want New Yorkers super-sizing sugary drinks, but employees at the media and financial information company he founded can guzzle all the free soda they want while they work. Bloomberg, for his part, has stressed that soda-lovers angered by calls of a “nanny state” are free to purchase more than one sugary beverage. thanks for responding
• United States
26 Jun 12
hi ladybug! do you think this will seriously happen...it seems like it would be difficult to regulate to me....also it just seems wrong to tell other people what they can and cannot eat and drink...even if people make poor or unhealthy choices...something similar to this happened in the beginning of the twentieth century...it was called prohibition...people were not able to buy alcholic beverages...it did not work, in fact there was a big underground industry and people called rum runners, etc...the prohibition act was repealed because it was basically illegal and so should this idea...people are going to do what they want to do...if they want more than sixteen ounces to drink, they may just buy two, or get refills...i am with you, i think that the government has a lot more important things to deal with, like poverty, homelessness, the war, the environment, etc.etc.etc.....
• United States
27 Jun 12
hi psychoartist, honestly I hope not but it really could happen. they said they would fine the resturants that sold them. kind a waste of government resources if you ask me.
• United States
2 Jul 12
Its always up to the person, whether or not they go certain places the get certain things. There are always ways to get what you want, government or no government