Religion and politics should not mix
By kingparker
@kingparker (9673)
United States
June 26, 2012 9:15pm CST
On Sunday morning, there were 2 persons knocking on my front door. They were people from church, and the first thing they asked me is how do I see about religion and politics. Can we use religious principle to our government policy, or else? I have no absolute answer at the moment, but from what I read from the past history, religion and politics should not mixed. Think about the Dark age in Europe, many religious persecution occurred, and many people uphold religious rights to start war against each other. So, what do you think? Should religion and politics mix together?
2 people like this
10 responses
@valerious (222)
• Indonesia
27 Jun 12
i agree with you.
Politics and religion is an 180 degree different.
1 person likes this
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
8 Jul 12
While I agree that government should not impose any religious doctrine or dogma on citizens, I don't agree that religion and politics should never be discussed in the same conversation.
The first amendment of the American Constitution reads;
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
It is obvious by this that the original framers of this amendment did not want government establishing a 'government religion'. But in also saying that they could not PROHIBIT the free exercise of religion, they also were saying government should not stop people from practicing their religions.
"Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other." -John Adams
While it is very true our founders here in America recognized the danger of giving government power to dictate to people what they should believe about God or religion, they were also very aware that if people did not have a moral base such as religon they would not be able to make the decisions necessary for governing themselves. It is only a law abiding and moral people that can truly govern and still retain freedom.
It is in our world view, our belief system that we judge from. And how can we judge between right and wrong for our neighbors....governing, if we cannot judge correctly for ourselves....religion (worldview, morals, etc)
I am not saying atheist cannot be moral here. It is not only faith in God that constitutes the moral worldview. I will not go into how atheism is a 'religion' in its own right (consider Buddhism with NO GOD yet a 'religion'). Our 'worldview' our 'belief system' is our 'religion'. And it is how we judge between 'right and wrong'. When we cast a vote for who will rule over us, who will govern us...we are judging who is 'right or wrong' and therefore, imposing our worldview on others, so we are in effect, mixing religion and pollitics anyway.
@rogue13xmen13 (14403)
• United States
27 Jun 12
I couldn't agree more. I don't think that politics and religion should mix because when people make decisions about politics based on religious beliefs, then you begin to exclude people, or you begin to make decisions that might be illogical or detrimental to the situation. The problem is that many of our rules and laws are based on religious beliefs or ancient methods of doing things, and they do not always apply to the current state of things.
@doroffee (4222)
• Hungary
27 Jun 12
To an extent, politics should care about religion, like helping out churches that do community work and stuff. But I don't agree with pushing down certain religions on our throats, giving most schools under their surveillance, using religion to get more votes and so. And no way should any religion be priviliged in schools and education. Let the kids decide for themselves and let the parents bring up/teach them how they'd like to.
I mean, I know about a religios school, which wasn't even religios in the start, it was ordered by the government that the church would be the supervisor instead of the local authority, and they introduced compulsory religion classes (when there were students who didn't believe in that religion), and there was a huge scandal when a girl kissed her boyfriend in the school. I mean, there should be some morals that should be kept, but I don't see what's so unmoralistic and trashy about a single kiss.
@misstee58 (22)
•
29 Jun 12
In my opinion, politics and religion are the same thing. They are just fought in different arenas most of the time. They are both all about the same thing...Control! Deliver me from religious dogma and politics both.
@kukueye (1759)
• Malaysia
27 Jun 12
It hard to see, because anything that is good u put into human being hands, sooner or later it will corrupt that goodness.Even without religion , politics can be dirty , religion is just another excuse for politicians to start war.Beside religion , people can use race,ethnics ,poor or rich classes, caste and other to suppress the will of others or persecution them.Hence i think it made no differences.
@viji_v2 (727)
• India
27 Jun 12
I believe religion and politics have many similarities. Both should be pure and should be with divine thoughts. What happening now is entirely opposite. People make politics with religion. And the political parties are following one religion and playing with the other by harming or abusing. Both the circumstances cannot be stopped by any means.
@ForSouls1234 (720)
• United States
27 Jun 12
I would try to find out first what angle they are coming from when asking me. Why did they want to know? As soon as I found that out I would find out whether I agreed with them or not.
Then I don't think I would care about mixing them. I would just care about the issue at hand. They must have had some sort of agenda.
@KCLGphilsBSA (372)
• Philippines
27 Jun 12
in an entire basis, the state and religion should be separated. Some aspects of community are distinct from each other in terms of their perception. They can but noT in most cases. Let's have lawmaking bodies which are obviously part of the government and still some if their laws are based on divine laws which are taught by our religion. There are also cases wherein the interruption of deep morals can aleviate the situation of the entire community.
Also, there is no definite religion and beliefs of people in one country that's why the state should be separated from religion. The government cannot be in favor of one belief and discredits the interest of the other side.