Would you rather know you are sick and dying of something OR
By mommyboo
@mommyboo (13174)
United States
August 19, 2012 4:33pm CST
...would you rather not know until you GOT SICK or actually died of it?
I was having a conversation with a friend about this yesterday. I don't ask for nor look for trouble. Randomly, whenever NECESSARY, I will have a physical because I use birth control or I would have 7 kids, age newborn through 8 . I do NOT go to the doctor for any other reason or have any invasive tests or anything that has more than average risks of false information.
IF something were to happen or be found, I would choose the least troublesome and invasive of options to deal with it. I have NO desire to get into something that would make me longterm sick, cause me to throw up constantly, be unable to live my life, lose my hair, lose weight, etc. I'm not interested in any chronic stuff, one time deal-with-it like surgery maybe and only if it had a reasonable chance of getting rid of it. I'd even go that route more than once if it came back but I would NOT do all the other extra chronic crap and would rather avoid chronic medication too as that can cause OTHER problems.
My thought here is that if have no symptoms and are fine, why would you want to KNOW? I don't want to live an additional 15 years, sick, miserable, unable to do anything I love. I'd rather enjoy every moment of my life and then suddenly die of something that might have been 'diagnosed and dealt with' for years but never know. I am going out with a bang with my mind intact, NOT after pain and disease and drugs and misery have stolen everything. Not knowing is better, in my opinion.
What would you do? If you've been there, what did you choose? Would you do things differently if you could choose again?
4 people like this
11 responses
@Lucky12 (767)
• United States
20 Aug 12
There are so amny different things out there that can make you sick and even kill you. I have to say that I may want to know, so that I have a heads up on what is going on and if it can be treated or not. Maybe i would want to know so that I can find out, but sometimes it is some things out there that you cannot even get cured if tried.
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Aug 12
I think I'd want to know if it's something temporary that can be dealt with (fixed) without chronic treatment or medication or any sort of ongoing lifestyle change. If it's something in the second category, I would just hope I was able to be symptom free as long as possible, after which I would use whatever resources I could to get rid of the symptoms. Chronic illness is just not something I can deal with, and I've always known it, so my choice is not to deal and just live lol.
@rogue13xmen13 (14403)
• United States
20 Aug 12
Yes, I would want to know so that I can get ready.
I know that I am going to die one day. I have already lost my father, my younger brother, and my step-father is dying of cancer, so with this in mind, I know that I won't like that long either.
I already have a video will. Yes, I am 27 and I have a will. What to do with my three cats and anything else that I have. Also, I would start living everyday as if it were my last. I would go where I want to go and do what I want to do. I am going to die anyway, so why not live it out as I would want to?
@34momma (13882)
• United States
20 Aug 12
that's a good question. I think if I was ill, i would want to know. I would want to be aware of what's going on with me, so i can take the steps to correct it. I like you don't go to the doctor that often. But I guess i would want to know
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Aug 12
would you actually want to know in advance and then have to deal with things like radiation and chemo though? I wouldn't. And if I did find out anything, I would not do anything unless I started actually being physically sick to the point I couldn't function.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
22 Aug 12
I see what your saying and I think I am a bit torn. On one hand, I would want to know and fight with every thing in me. I have a lot that I still want to do. I hope to say all that I want to right now, but if I haven't or aren't, I would like to have the chance to do it.
On the other hand, suffering and pain scares me. I have seen it and I know how it takes a person from point a to point b. What if I didn't have the fight? Falling asleep is an often unrealistic desire, but when I go, that sure would be a nice way to do it.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Aug 12
I would totally do what I could that didn't make 'being' worse, if that makes sense to you. Anything that would benefit me as far as how I felt, looked, acted, enhanced my ability to live the way I wanted to - those are things I would take advantage of. Anything that detracted or took away from me, that made me feel, look, and act worse, I would avoid like the plague.
The problem is, a lot of treatments for things are horrible and cause people to downgrade fast in terms of being independent, feeling good, and keeping up with a normal life. That is in essence why I would prefer to avoid those things. With all the technology we have now, you would think we would have figured out how to 'breed out' side effects of things. It's been at least a century of research behind us, I've no idea why we are still so newbie in that area.
@Paper_Doll (2373)
• Philippines
19 Aug 12
If I am really sick, I wanted to know that I am dying so I could make preparations for my parents and siblings future and also, to have time with my husband to let him know how much I value him. But I do not want it to be very long that they still have to pay my hospitalization or medications. I do not want them to suffer financially if I will just die anyway. I think a couple of weeks or a month or two would be enough.
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
21 Aug 12
I think if I were physically sick to the point where there was no question there was something wrong with me, at that point I would probably be interested in figuring out what was wrong. HOWEVER. That doesn't mean I would want to do anything that would ADD to the symptoms, make me worse or feel worse - even short term - if in the end it wasn't going to really make a difference.
I would prefer to measure the pros and cons like I do with everything else - if the benefit outweighs the trouble, MAYBE. If the benefit is equal to the trouble, probably not. If the benefit is less than the trouble, nope. I hate seeing people suffer and I don't understand why some people will suffer for so long, and how some people even welcome it.
Living doesn't mean simply being alive. It means being alive in the capacity you want to function and live. I would never ever want to be a vegetable.... like if I were in an accident that rendered me braindead. I would not want to be kept alive, a prisoner in my body, unable to communicate, maybe even in a coma for years. I can't even imagine what something like that would be like.
@sweetaprillynn (207)
• United States
19 Aug 12
Hello mommyboo,
Personally, I would not want to know. I worked as a home-health aide from the time I was nineteen years old, until about a year ago. Throughout those years I have seen a number of people diagnosed with cancer. You will never believe how fast the transformation goes from being a healthy human being to one that is dieing. The word 'cancer' seems to be just as dangerous as the actual disease.
I would probably not deal with the psychological aspects of being terminally ill. If I were to have cancer in my body, for example, I would rather just die from it one day, than to constantly live being sick and going through treatments.
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
21 Aug 12
I absolutely agree with you, which is why I wrote this discussion. It's hard to know EXACTLY what I would do because I haven't been there, but I have watched other people die and I know from between what they have expressed and wanted and knowing what kind of person I am, I would not be able to stand dealing with KNOWING. Some people have all sorts of prenatal tests too and say they want all this info, all I needed to know was do I plan for a boy or a girl. I had zero interest in finding out anything else, because regardless, it would have no impact on my life with the baby. SOME people choose to end a pregnancy or figure out all sorts of other stuff. I would rather keep life as normal as possible instead. I think it would be terrible to be stressed out your whole pregnancy or dread giving birth, and that's what would happen if you knew something bad was going to happen.
Some people are obsessed with knowing everything, I only need to know the things that matter to me to accomplish my goals and be happy. Psychologically, I doubt I could deal either. I'm not a good patient and the only time I was ever actually admitted into a hospital was when my daughter was born. I wanted to leave IMMEDIATELY. I got about 2 hours sleep total in 3 days there and went home with my daughter and actually rested more/ate better the first day home, which some people say is the hardest because then you have to 'do everything yourself'. I would prefer to do everything myself, as I pretty much trusted only my husband and older kids at that time to take care of me and not do something I didn't want lol.
I'm not a 'sick' person... I never have been. I might get really sick once a year, or injure myself to the point where I can't do anything for a couple days... a week, but again, it's not something I do on a regular basis. The idea of having some chronic illness would make me pretty angry, I would ignore it as long as possible lol.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
20 Aug 12
hi mommyboo I have diabetes and have had it for a long time but
this is a chronic disease one can control and live a long
and happy life and I am doing that and enjoying my old age
my lotting a lot,I would want always to know what my health
is as its positive to care for little things so they do
not become life threatening I enjoy life myself.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Aug 12
As long as you take care of yourself, diabetes doesn't become terminal like cancer though... you'd be unlikely to be made sick or worse by the treatment used to control it, right?
Did you get diabetes later or did you have it as a child... insulin dependent? I know people who seem to be just fine as diabetics and some who are sick as dogs all the time. That would be a tough one for me because I love to eat, and I love to eat everything. I can't cut out things - and I run about 40-50 miles a week lol! I know exercise is supposed to be good for diabetics but I'm not sure if THAT much would be.
@wonttakelong (3555)
• United States
2 Sep 12
I honestly cant say how I would react or what I would do
I have many friends with long-term illnesses
some of them dont have any problems with treatment but others become real sick while on treatment
ALL of them though have taught me that life is too short and you should treat every day as if its your last
always cherish the little things and take nothing for granted
@RawBill1 (8531)
• Gold Coast, Australia
25 Aug 12
If there was no option of cure then I would want to suddenly just get sick and die with a short period of pain and knowing it was the end. I would not want some illness to kill me slowly.
But having said that, I do believe that if you can catch these terminal illnesses soon enough, then with the right attitude and the right treatment plan, you can cure yourself of them and continue to live a happy life.
@asliah (11137)
• Philippines
28 Oct 12
hi,
for me of course i will choose to know i am sick and dying to prevent that sick in my body or to more become more prepare on what will happen to me in the future,i want to know it so that i can still do what i still wanted to do while i am still alive.
@majuuyaitai22 (93)
• Philippines
20 Aug 12
For me, I would like to know so that I can learn how to spend my life right and correct every mistake that I would do. I'll be more careful and cautious with my life. I 'll give all the time and spend it to those whom I love. I would like to know but I'll decide not to say it to anyone so that I can make memories to them. I would like to know but I would not be paranoid about it. I believe in the saying that if it's your time, it's your time. And I don't want to leave something that might be regretful.