Can you tolerate your partner to...
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
Philippines
October 16, 2012 3:00am CST
hit your kid or kids in front of you when they commit mistakes? Is it okay for you to raise your kid or kids to grow up with this set up? For me it's not alright. I just want my husband to scold my son and not hit him. We usually fight with this. Scolding is okay withme. Even if he will nag at him 24 hours, 7 days, the whole year. LOL. Hitting my child is the last thing I want him to do. What are your thoughts fellow mylotters? Feel free to share. Happy mylotting everyone.
3 people like this
14 responses
@Paper_Doll (2373)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
My father never hits us, but my mom seldom does it so when she hits us, we definitely know that she is very angry with what we have done. I think that it is okay to hit a child but you only do that in times that they have really cause big problems or troubles as if you hit a child even on small issues, the weight of hitting will no longer be effective. They would only think that you are just hurting them and that's it. They won't realized why they are being hit and won't really learn their lessons. And sometimes, this could make a child violent and would do the same to other kids. Because they don't understand why they are being hit by their parents, they have this tendencies to make revenge but not on their parents, but with other kids.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
I agree with you. Hitting them regularly isn't good. Instead of hitting them, we should just talk to them in a nice way and let them realize their mistakes. I hope that my kids will not hurt other children and I hope that he will not bring up his own children using his dad's strategy, and that's hitting. I hope he will eventually become more responsible to his studies so that he won't be scolded anymore. I know Grade 2 students are still that naughty. I remembered my naughty classmates way back elementary.
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
Yes, I already talked to him many times. I don't know why he usually forgets. He knows about his dad's temper. I hope he will learn his lesson soon.
@Paper_Doll (2373)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
Maybe it can help if you speak with your child after that so as to explain everything to him like why his dad hit him or how he can avoid being hit.
1 person likes this
@sjvenden27 (1840)
• United States
16 Oct 12
I would agree hitting a child should not be the first type of punishment.. What is the child going to learn? Not to do that again.. No thats not it.. your teaching your child to endure a little pain and then it will be over.. After awhile hitting will not phase him at all.. Unless your husband starts hiting him harder.. dont think you want that.. Have you tried timeouts? put him in a quiet place no toys no nothing for 1 mintue for each year.. taking stuff away?
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
Our son is already 8 years old and I think that he's quite old to understand what we mean. I want him to be considered as an adult now. I mean, no more hitting. He only needs to know what he did is wrong and he should not do it again, etc. I want my husband to talk to him in a nice way. I also don't want him to do the sermon during meal time. I usually lose my appetite and destroy our bonding moments. We only see each other on weekends but he still ruins my time with them. Last Sunday evening while we were having our dinner, he hit the top of my son's head with a spoon. We fought about that and I was sorry about my child. I got mad at them. I really said everything I wanted to say. My husband almost hit me because I couldn't shut my mouth but I didn't care. I dare him to touch me and it will be the end of our marriage. He shouldn't try my patience.
1 person likes this
@riyauro (6421)
• India
16 Oct 12
I mean where does he go the rest of the week if he comes home only in the weekends?? I can see that your hubby is not that attached to your son. And being away from home can be the reason number one.. Thanks for sharing and have a wonderful day ahead.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
I am the one away and he's the housekeeper. He's with my son most of the time. LOL. I can't go home from work every night because transportation isn't available. I have to stay in another city on weekdays and I go home on Saturdays and spend time with them until Monday mornings.
@mortysmadhouse (226)
• Australia
18 Oct 12
I agree with you, hitting/smacking a child is not right as it only promotes violence for later on in life. Tone of voice should be enough - you can get enough 'edge' in your voice that it literally cuts and hurts.
My partner smacked our eldest son (autistic) about 6 months ago. First and last time he did it as I reacted in a big way and nearly ended our relationship over it.
Just because his mother was like that with him, doesn't give him the right to be like that with our boys.
Good luck and ((((( BIG HUGS )))))
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
18 Oct 12
Oh, yes. That's right. The way his parents brought him up should be different with the way we should bring up our child or children. If his experiences were that bad then he should not let his son to undergo them, too. Oh, it's good that your partner never did it again. Goodluck to you too. Thanks for posting and happy mylotting. (Big hugs)
@skyandgrassplot (1497)
• China
17 Oct 12
If my partner hit our kids hardly and frequently then it is wrong definitely,and I will stop her with no doubt.But sometimes I think some hits can not be avoided if my kids commit a big mistake then I will hit them but of course I will not hurt them,we need to control our strength.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
18 Oct 12
Yes, we should not hurt them I guess constant scolding, and hitting will make their self-esteem less. Instead of getting confidence, they will think that all they do aren't right. They will develop self-pity instead. Thanks a lot for posting and happy mylotting.
@fatlex06 (895)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
Like you, I don't want my partner to hit our future child ofcourse. Specially for the mom, we are the ones who will carry or who carried the baby for 9 months and it is not right to watch our children be hit with our partners. I think talking is the best thing to do with our child.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
Young children are afraid of getting hit but I guess my son isn't already. He's already 8 and he got hit many times already. I don't want him to suffer anymore so I want my husband to discipline him by talking with him in a nice way and not by hitting him. Our son can weigh things already but I don't know what is his problem. I don't know if it's his fault or his teacher's fault. My husband always compares him to his classmates. They belong in a special class for these past few years so I guess my husband doesn't want him to be in a regular class. If he will not do his best, he might be in a regular class next school year. I don't want my son to be pressured. I just want him to learn and enjoy his studies. I don't care about the competition. If he is already old enough to know the value of education, I guess he will behave well and he will try his best to concentrate in his classes and he'll eventually get good grades. For now, he's only in Grade 2. He's not old enough to be responsible that much. Thanks for posting and happy mylotting.
@ztuberi (395)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
Respect your husband as the Father of your child. Though, you can discuss things and agree on things on how you want to discipline your child. But, remember that it is better not to react in front your son, if your husband is hitting your child. Your child must learn the authority of his father over him. Opposing to your husband in front of your child is a big NO. Your child will get confused of his parents. If you want something to oppose, not in front and knowing of your child.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
Oh, thank you so much. I guess you are right. I will try to do my best not to react in front of our child again. I just can't tolerate him hitting my child. He has a stick at home and he said he hit our son with it. On his chest. One time, I saw my son's leg with some bruises and he didn't tell me about it but my husband admitted that he hit our son. I'm afraid that it will cause him some traumatic experiences. I want the hurting to stop. Scolding by nagging is enough for me. Happy mylotting.
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
18 Oct 12
You are right. It's not good. I forgot to mention "head" too sometimes. I will discuss it with him the next time he will get angry. The last he got angry, he told me to bring our son with me already and he also with leave the house. I know he didn't really mean it. So, I told him " Why, are you already giving up your role as his father?" LOL. We reconciled after that. I hope there will be no next hitting, etc.
@ztuberi (395)
• Philippines
18 Oct 12
Oh, that really hurts. Something to use on hitting is ok instead of our own hands. Because we use our hands in caring them. But not to hit a child on the chest or legs. Usually, on the palm or on their butts. And not that hard that may cause bruises. Maybe you should discuss that with your husband, that it will not be safe anymore for your son. (Maybe its the way his parents disciplined them).
1 person likes this
@Iriene88 (5343)
• Malaysia
16 Oct 12
I am just like you. I believe we should point out and explain to the child
about the mistake so that they will understand. Beating them will have bad
effect when they grow up. I read some article on 'bringing up children the right way'
mentioned that we should not scream and hit our children, this might cause the child
psychological problems at later years. Hmmmm... I hope your husband will change and hope both of you will agree to be "the good and the bad guys" method used by many families
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
I guess my husband is very stubborn. He likes to do his way of disciplining our child. I told him that if he was brought up that way, I hope he won't do it with his child. He doesn't listen to me. We've fought about this many times already. I am telling him that this can cause some traumatic experience. I hope he'll change in the future. Thanks for posting and happy mylotting.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
I sometimes would spank my child if he really something bad and I want him to realize that if he remains to be a good kid, he would never ever be spanked again. I think for some, this would not be approved. But in my own view, it is part of instilling discipline on the kids. The spanking would not be that hard, it would just be like catching their attention and a reminder of the wrong thing that they have done.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
If the spanking is not that harsh I guess it's okay and it should be seldom. My husband's hands are quite strong. I think he can't control his anger sometimes. He should watch his temper. Thanks for posting and happy mylotting.
@riyauro (6421)
• India
16 Oct 12
I would not tolerate it either. kids are kids and they need to be told politely and not by hitting. It is worse than anything. kids retaliate later in life and will have the hatred for the parents. Thanks for sharing and have a wonderful day ahead.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
I guess you areright. I hated my father because he was so strict and he hit me when I was young. LOL. My husband also hates his father until now when he remembers the way he disciplined them before. I hope he will not become like his father. I told him that he should cheange his style because he's like father. Thanks for posting and happy mylotting.
@aejey322 (1004)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
I also do not like my child to be hit or in any way be physically hurt... I also would like to train them just by scolding and talking firmly to them. Because I have read that hitting may make them become more bad. My son is still 2 years old and I know he still cannot understand the way we discipline him. especially that he is in "terrible 2" stage where he needs to get all that he wants. and he is super hyper active, but not an ADHD... Sometimes it will really test your patience, but I see to it that I must always be in myself so I could remind myself that hey you are dealing with a 2-year-old My 2-year-old is smart and advance in his age. He is like having a mind of a 4 or 5 year old. that's why sometimes his actions and words makes me forget that he's only 2.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
Oh, children nowadays act older than their real age. I hope they will behave well so that they won't get so much scoldings. Yeah, we have to remind ourselves that they are just children. Goodluck to all of us in raising our children. Thanks a lot for posting and happy mylotting.
@Daisy_22 (1229)
• Philippines
20 Oct 12
I am a disciplinarian person but i never did use force to do that. There is no such powerful tool as words in trying to soften the heart of a person. Communication is greatly a very important instrument to change a person even the worse individual.
@rizzaspeaks (391)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
I don't think hitting the child after each mistake will teach him a lesson. Scolding is fine as long as you don't use vulgar words that will hurt him emotionally. Disciplining a child is letting him realize his mistake. If the child understands the consequence of his actions, he will avoid doing the same act again. Often,the most common mistake of parents is not letting the child understand the mistake.
I was once hit by my father, it served as a lesson for me, I understand my wrong act and so I didn't do it again. It is also one way to remind me to never lose respect to the people older than me, esp. my parents.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
Yes, I agree with you. Scolding is better than hitting them. I hope our son won't lose respect to us. I'll do my best to talk to him abut his mistakes. Thanks for posting and happy mylotting.
@meowchie (992)
• Philippines
16 Oct 12
My father have not hit any of us yet, it's because our faults are counseled by my mother first. :) Only when my mom can't take it and tolerate anymore that she will ask for dad's help, but glad to say- mom's look are fiercer than my dad's!
Hit? I don't know about the hitting he does.But I have always believed that discipline using the rod or hands/butt is the common way of punishment. Only that after doing so, the parents need to talk with the child immediately and explain and let the kid reflect too.
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
I guess our son is reflecting about his faults too; however, he's so forgetful. Sometimes his teachers tells them some thing and he forgot to tell his dad. My husband asks other students and wonders why my son doesn't tell him. I guess my son isn't that attentive at school because he's talkative. I hope the teacher will correct him and be strict but what they do is tell my husband about his behavior and my husband will do the scolding and maybe spanking. He has a bad temper.He doesn't know how to manage it.
@Magz1989 (271)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
Well, in my part, there are times that you need to hit your child so that they will learn but not to the point of hurting them, there are many psychological matters that will rise if you hit them wrongly. There are advices from expert on how to treat a child especially when they commit mistake. Expert says:You can punish them by cleaning their rooms, or do things that can develop their sense of responsibility. Also if they are really, really naughty, there's a way of hitting them that should like example: He hit someone ....you get a poster/paper, then roll it and hit his hands only not the body. Remember, train up a child the way he/she would go and when he/she old she/he never departs from it.....we should discipline them in a nicely manner....okay...parents!!!!
1 person likes this
@angelkarah050182 (4980)
• Philippines
18 Oct 12
Yes, I believe in that saying. I want to apply that in our lives. I guess it's not yet late to correct our mistakes. Thanks a lot. Happy mylotting.