My dad who just died was related to a well-known family, should we have told em?

Philippines
October 16, 2012 9:01am CST
Only a few years ago we found an old picture of our father during the wake of his own father. It was a very old black and white pic in which he was with his sister among others. When asked, he said they were his siblings as well on his father's side. They had a different mother. One of the men who were in it looked like someone who is a prominent figure in the Philippines. Some of our relatives started digging around and when my father heard about it he got mad and were told to stop meddling. Even so speculations were abound that it was indeed him. When he got hospitalized and was in semi conscious state, one relative asked him point-blank if ______ was his brother. My father nodded but when asked if we should contact them he said no, his brother will just get mad. His sister also claims the same thing. Let me tell you as well that our family tree on our father's side is unclear because they've gone through several changes with tbe surname. Our grandfather was from a different country who migrated here and changed his name after becoming a citizen. Our father also changed his surname and did not use his father's surname. So tracing our lineage is difficult. And other than the old pictures there were no proofs to setlle it once and for all. I believe they have not been in any contact since then as we which would be over 3 decades now. Do you think we should have told his "brother" about our father's death to give him a chanceto pay his last respects in case he wants to or was it right to honor what our dad wanted and let bygones be bygones?
5 people like this
3 responses
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
I think you'll just open up wounds of the past. These types of things are better left unsaid. If it were up to my great grandmother, she would have wanted it that way too. There are things that need to be set in the past and perhaps they have a good reason for doing so. As you said, they changed surnames and such (that is actually my grandfather's story as well) if they lost "in touch" it wasn't because they didn't want to. There are things they did in the past that would cause them and their "relatives" out of the country and if you dig that up these days, you'd only find problems in the end. So, respect your father's decision and keep his past with him. If you're just doing that for curiosity's sake, then there are things that you don't really need to know. Have a great mylot experience ahead!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
17 Oct 12
I agree with what you said. There are some things better left unsaid and some secrets better left unknown. And perhaps this is one of those things. Tthank you.
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
23 Oct 12
If this is a long issue and you think no one seems to care maybe it is better to let the past gone with the people behind it. It's just my opinion. If your father's brother or other siblings are interested to know about your father's well-being they should have tried to communicate or search for him. But since no one comes to know about your father's condition and as per your father's wish to forget his roots, maybe it is better to respect your father's wish. But I understand your curiosity and it is your right to know your real ancestors and meet your other relatives as well. If you think you have all the means and proofs- then go on and I wish you all the luck.
• Philippines
23 Oct 12
Were your ancestors from a different country? Chinese perhaps? My grandfather was and I understand that during those times to become a Filipino citizen, they needed to change their surnames.
• Philippines
23 Oct 12
I say respect your dad's wishes and just continue with life. They never made any move to be together themselves so why should you not just keep it that way?
• Philippines
23 Oct 12
Yeah he's gone and has been buried and I too feel now that there is no more point in bringing it up and introducing ourselves to our relatives