Would you tell your child?
By leateagee
@leateagee (3667)
China
November 7, 2012 9:50am CST
What if you have adopted a baby?
You became a good parent. You got the baby when he/she was newly born. You have provided the baby a good home. The baby grew and you have provided a good education.
Now, the questions are:
When is the best time to tell the child a that he/she was adopted?
Should you tell or not?
What is the importance or reasons for telling the truth or just to keep the truth from the child?
Have a great day!
9 people like this
36 responses
@Youreyes4Today (2356)
• United States
7 Nov 12
I would let the child know once they were grown. Health issue's is one of the reasons that stands out the most. They have a right to know as a person. They also have the right to know that you were kind enough, loved enough to take them in as your own and raise them into who they turned out to be.
2 people like this
@leateagee (3667)
• China
7 Nov 12
That's great. Every one deserves who they really are. When I was young, we made a family tree at school and I got interested in it so I did a family tree for my mother's roots. I didn't like my relatives in my father's side so until now I don't know much about them.
1 person likes this
@Youreyes4Today (2356)
• United States
8 Nov 12
I know sometimes we do not like the family we were born to, yet they are related by blood. If you do the family tree on your fathers side you may find a relative/s that may interest you or did something that will impress you. It is still family regardless..
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Dec 12
Exactly. Whatever they are right now, do not judge instaed look what is something great from them. Maybe at this stage of their life is the down side and their past was the best, why not look deeper. I like that idea.
@maximax8 (31046)
• United Kingdom
7 Nov 12
If I adopted a baby then I would wait until he or she could understand. I think I would wait until my child could understand and use language appropriate for his or her age. At 3 to 4 years old children attend a nursery school. Some of the other moms might be pregnant so I would say to my child that lady is going to have a baby. At the moment the oldest daughter of my 3 year old daughters childminder is pregnant. Her baby is due close to Christmas. My little girl can see her bump is getting bigger. Next month sometime her baby will be born. I think that age 3 to 4 years old would be a suitable time to mention the child had been adopted. I would say to his or her I decided to get you and because you are very special. I would say I had a choice of babies and I decided he or she was the one I wished to get. I would explain getting him or her was a dream come true.
2 people like this
@leateagee (3667)
• China
7 Nov 12
That is so sweet of you. Telling the truth and the timing would really depend on you. The way the child will understand and accept the facts will also depend on how much information you wanted to tell. Kudos to you! Wish you happiness and to your family.
1 person likes this
@KrauseHome (36447)
• United States
23 Nov 12
Personally I think there comes a time when it is best to let them know they have been adopted before they hear it or find out from someone else. I would think by the time they are 16 at the latest, and explain to them that it is OK to be upset. I know I never really got a chance to know my real Dad as he left my Mom when I was 4, and then had my Step Dad adopt me after they got married. But at least I always knew and did get to meet my Real dad once as an adult.
1 person likes this
@serialmommy (639)
• United States
7 Nov 12
I don't understand why you wouldn't tell the child. Everyone searches for who they are, and part of that is knowing where they, and their family came from. I know that in the past it was the norm to not tell a child they were adopted, however that has changed quite drastically, and I think for the better.
When you tell a child really depends on the child. It also depends on how much detail you want to go into. The older the child, the more you can tell them, at least about the details that you know about.
@leateagee (3667)
• China
2 Dec 12
We all have unique family ties. As what you've mentioned it depends on the child. I feel somehow it is necessary to tell. Maybe before adoptive parents hsould tell the child, they should be prepared for possible negative reactions and also prepare te child for emotional changes.
Our emotion affect us so much. Feelings that however we control still lingers even we say "forgiven, forgotten, moved on" ... Only time can tell when do wounds in our hearts will be healed.
@fatlex06 (895)
• Philippines
7 Nov 12
Hi there. I know someone who has this kind of situation. Her answer in here would be no. There is no way that she will tell her child that she was just adopted. Why? Because there is no reason to say it anymore. Saying it will just complicate the child's life. Why complicate one's life when there is an option not to? And, what's the point? To know who are the true parents? No, it's not necessary anymore. As long as they have loved the child as their own, nothing has to be explained anymore. As long as the child didn't feel that he or she was adopted, it's no use to tell the truth. Oh. I sound as my friend. LOL
1 person likes this
@leateagee (3667)
• China
7 Nov 12
Oh really. I searched before I started the discussion and found no tags related. I am so sorry if it quite similar. i am still thankful that you responded.
I understand what you are trying to imply but eventually the child will know the truth. Why hide or not tell it when the truth will set them free. I don't think it will complicate a person's life. If the upbringing was well then the adopted person will be very greatful that some good couple took care of him and provided him a family.
But, well, we are all intitled to our own opinions. And we have our own reasons for doing such actions or decisions.
1 person likes this
@damanpreetsingh (192)
• India
7 Nov 12
hi i honestly feel that its really really sad to let any child/person know that he/she is adopted. If there is no other source from where the child might come to know about his/her adoption apart from parents, then I would suggest not to reveal the truth.
2 people like this
@leateagee (3667)
• China
7 Nov 12
I understand what you mean. People are different. Others would like to know their roots and others would not mind at all or will have a hurt feelings.
1 person likes this
@marguicha (223776)
• Chile
22 Nov 12
I would certainly tell my children if they were adopted, because that would not make them less my children. The only difference is that we don`t have the same blood. THat could be important if they got some genetic illness. I am for giving the adopted family all the resourses and data for that reason. When and how would depend on the child. I do not love my two daughters identically, but I love both of them dearly and could not measure which one I love best.
@trisha27 (3494)
• United States
3 Dec 12
I would tell my child when they are older and able to understand. Maybe when they are in their teenage years. I learned that my father was not my real father that he adopted us when I was a baby and my brother was only 2 years old. That is when my mother told us about we had another father who wanted nothing to do with us and gave up his parental rights and that is when my step father adopted us. I grew up thinking that he was my real father. I didn't learn that he wasn't my father until I was 13 years old. I think I maybe should have been like 16 years old or they should have waited until I was 18. But I think that age 16 or 18 is a good age to tell someone they were adopted.
@lovinangelsinstead21 (36850)
• Pamplona, Spain
22 Jan 13
Hiya leateagee,
For me I would tell them when they had enough notion to understand things. Some might not understand the reason why they are adopted and others will understand it right away.
Not all of them are going to like the idea at first but it is vital for them to know in case of any kind of issues.
Maybe the Mother the natural Mother might want to meet them and also their possible Father whoever he is or was.
In all its very important for them at least to know even if they never want to find out nothing at all.
Before here a lot of adoptions were not legal and now there are a lot of problems going on because of it.
Child has a right to know every Child I know someone who´s Father told her that she was not his Daughter very late in life and more out of spite than anything else this is not the way to do it.
Last but not least they could easily find out the child I mean that they have various Brothers and Sisters and other loads of relatives especially if they were an only adopted child as well.xxx
@Professor2010 (20162)
• India
23 Dec 12
Ok suppose i adopted a baby when he/she was just few days or say one year young, i gave good food,good dress and good education etc always considered as my kid.
First of all why should she/he will ask?
Suppose he/she asks, then i must tell the truth the very day itself, no hiding lol.
Thanks for sharing.
MERRY S'MAS
Cheers
@fantabulus (4000)
• India
16 Nov 12
Yes I think parent should pay attention on child in proper manner even the child is adopted. No matter child is own or adopted we should treat same otherwise dont take the child of others.
@jureathome (5361)
• Philippines
14 Nov 12
I would tell her the truth when she's old enough to understand. Perhaps, when she's 13ish. Or, as soon as she'll start asking, if that comes prior. The kid deserves to know the truth, and re assuring her of my love should not change anything. If the kid is brought up well, she'll be grateful of what I've done for her.
@hlfbldmom (743)
• Philippines
15 Nov 12
I have an adopted daughter. She is 8 year old now and from the start she knows that I am not her real mother. She called her real mother mama as well. But most of the time she in confused when people told her that I am her real mother since we have resemblance and not with her real mother.I am thankful that she is so bright to understand it at her young age. Her confusion don't affect her. She is open to me and told me everything people asked about her and she's the one telling me don't mind her mum they are just insecure and envy much of you haha! So I guess it's better that they will know it from the beginning so it is not hard for them to accept while they grow up.
@heleighna (102)
• Philippines
14 Feb 13
Telling the child the truth is the parents responsibility, though it'll make the child very sad, and the parents as well. But the hidden truth will never make the child a complete person as long as it'll be keep hidden from him forever. The right time? Maybe when he's old enough to understand everything. A 5 year old is just too young.. Maybe when he's in college, or after college, as long as he's old enough. =)
@youless (112586)
• Guangzhou, China
9 Nov 12
Perhaps I will not tell my child that she/he is adopted. I think she/he will be hurtful to hear that. And she/he would think about why her/his own parents abandoned she/he. It will be a big burden for her/him. Whereas she/he may not find her/his own parents to get the answer. Since I treat her/him as well as my own child, I don't have to tell that actually she/he is adopted. It is good enough that we are a family.
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
9 Nov 12
An adopted child should be told about the adoption early, just as soon as they begin to understand what it means. They won't understand at first, but they can be fed bits and pieces of information. The best adjusted adoptees have just always known that they were adopted.
@aabuda (1722)
• Philippines
11 Nov 12
Well, I think the child deserves to know his past and that it is his rights to be informed.
@jonnagirl (322)
• Philippines
11 Nov 12
i would rather keep it sealed until the child will reach at the right age where he/she can understand things like that . Just putting up my shoes in her/ him. It would be harsh if at the young age he can be informed of that. he can be emotionally bothered and would develop bad thoughts . good if you as a standing parent of the child is a full time mom so you could explain right away the abrupt thoughts and you are there in the process of letting him/her feel not bad about the situation.but if you both are working parents and your time with the child were so limited and at times that he/ she needed some explanations even how little it is considering her/his emotions on the process would require immediate respond to cope up his/ her bad emotions on that.
@olivetree27 (495)
• Greece
14 Nov 12
You should actually tell her/him that she is adopted. You are loving enough to adopt her and give her a life that she would have never experience if she was with her real parents as she was given away, right? I'm sure by being a good parent you left a spot in her heart and I'm sure she will have second thought in leaving you even if she will try to find her real birth mother, for her you're still her real parent. I have a lot of friends who are adopted and upon finding out who their real parents are, they said that they don't feel the same affection for them as much as they do with the parents who raised them. It is better to learn that you're adopted from the parents who love you than from someone else. And telling them at an early age or at an old age will not make a difference especially if they know that you love them so much as they don't really care finding who their real parents are.
@vmartre (31)
•
11 Nov 12
For me, the real parents are the ones who take care of the baby. The ones who share their love and life with them.
Yes, you must tell them the truth, but in an age that he/she undestand life, this can be in the 15s or 17s, and they will love you more.
What a difficult moment!!!