Comments are not responses,Responses are not comments!!!!
@Hatley (163776)
Garden Grove, California
November 18, 2012 5:10pm CST
Sometimes I feel when talking here like I am talking in
quicksand as people do not use really correct
terminology.Mylot uses comments to reply to the responses we get on our
discussions. Also comments are used on other's responses too. But
from what I can gather here in mylot land , a comment is different
from a response. why not use mylots terms and by correct so
we all know what page we are on. You comment on a response,
not respond on a response, am I right? Your take mylotters,
14 people like this
43 responses
@inertia4 (27960)
• United States
20 Nov 12
Well all things being equal, a response to a discussion is really a comment of sorts. And a comment to a response is a response of sorts. Its all relative. The terminology used here is you start a discussion, people respond to that discussion, then we respond to those responses. Or if you wish you can replace all the "responses" with the word comment. Either way its the same. I think this is what you're talking about here. If you are referring to what people write and how they write it, well, thats a totally different story.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
20 Nov 12
INERTIA HI you respond to a discussion so mylot sh ows that in a sentence above
your box saying respond to this discussinl and the red tags below will say post response. okay
When you comment on others responses to your discussion or on responses on others discussions the sentence above your post will read add comment to this response
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
24 Nov 12
hi inertia I am glad you respond to discusson you have started
as I have done the same thing., there are discu ssions with
responses and no comments back which looks like a waste'
of time to me. ia always comment back alth ugh sometimes
I may be late doing it.
1 person likes this
@inertia4 (27960)
• United States
23 Nov 12
Like I said, even though it may sound confusing, it is all relative. It all basically means the same thing. I do not pay attention to any of that. I get my email and respond to my friends discussions and to the ones I have started. Its that simple.
1 person likes this
@sishy7 (27167)
• Australia
19 Nov 12
It's ok, don't worry too much how others reacted to this topic...
I have similar feelings when I try to correct those who refer to 'User Rating' as 'Post Counter'...
Oh well, I can only try and it's up to them whether they want to use the correct term or not...
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi thaks it is so silly to get upset about my discussion'as the proof
\of the meaning of the two terms is right below this boc. post comment which is what I am doing now back to those who agree and those who tell me to leave us aloner.
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
19 Nov 12
Iam likely another one that confuses or gets confused with this terminology, but is it such a terrible offense? lots of people make mistakes here and i try not to point them out. like mispellings, not putting a space between words and i know it gets on others nerves but i figure we are not in school here or being graded on our grammer, we are friends discussing things and just hanging out. right? so i hope you will forgive me if im mixing up comments with responses. lol
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
oh dear bunnybon why is everyone out to get me because I pointed out the way my lot uses the two terms and how its easier when a person is talking about responses to know that he or she means what we put down to respond to someone else's discussion., I am sorry I even made this as I guess I am the only one
who has seen the red tag lines below this box that says post comment.
I am not policing anyone or anything like that. There's nothing to forgive
you for.I was just pointing out that m lot uses the terms are not interchangeable
but comment means to comment on a response or another comment and
response means the initial responses we give to each other. I am sick of this discussion as everyone is taking this the wrong way sorry i made it
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
bunnybon I am not criticizing anyone nor scolding just pointing out that m, ulot herself uses comment one way and response a different way.as for my misspelling and the damned space between some letterS I have a keyboard that space bar
malfunctions so I have to go back by hand and tighten up the words and I am human Look I was not scolding anyone and I forgive you but do you forgive me?
I have feelings too and I was just try ng to show how mylot makes a difference between comment and response.I w as not criticizing anyone bu t I am getting flak for being me I guess.I started this because I and and another mylotter were talking about two different things and each one of us thought the other one was talking about the same thing. so I thought maybe we needed to clarify the two terms.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
22 Nov 12
I think that you are exactly right here. I think of those people that respond to my discussion as leaving responses to the discussion and then when I go back through the discussion and leave feedback on the responses that other mylotters have left, I think of those as being comments that I'm leaving. If the discussions within the discussions continue, I think of that as simply being a conversation that really is happening.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
24 Nov 12
hi dorannmwin I think so many people just think they a re all interchangeable but mylot does not do it that wa y.I love it when others come to my discussion and comments on my comments then others comment on the comments so we have a lively discussion going on for ages.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi Ricki I seem to have made people mad and am wishing I had never made
this. those who do not a commentis made on a resopnse or another comment
and a resopnse is what we originally make on friends discussions
so I say to all just look below my box mylot r ed tagline say s
POST COMMENT.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
27 Nov 12
hi I am now sayhing just read mylots large sentence that is always about our
boxex a nd read the red tagts below and you will understand jus twhat I mean bu\coments and reponses too.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi ambie just read abou ve and below your box when you make
a response to somone else's discussion and also below\ot will say
post resoponse or poost comment depoeningin on which it is you
ar doing. I was just trying to show comment and resonse are two different thingsWe resond to a discussion, we comment to a response or another comment.
1 person likes this
@silverfox09 (4708)
• United States
18 Nov 12
Hatley I am one of those people , that dont used the term at all times. What really matter to me is making related respond to any post I am interested in .
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
silverfox I did not make this discussion to fight or fuds just telling all how my lot uses the terms and how is is easier when discussing response or comments if we both are talking about the same thing check the red tagb belows it says Post comment.
1 person likes this
@Cutie18f (9546)
• Philippines
19 Nov 12
Thanks for calling our attention to it Hatley. I have never really made any clear-cut distinction between the two. Responses are supposed to be longer and more detailed while a comment is just a brief reaction to the response. I hope I got that right.
@rosegardens (3032)
• United States
19 Nov 12
so my response is a comment, your comment is a response right? Do I have that right?
reĀ·spond
[ri-spond] Show IPA
verb (used without object)
1.
to reply or answer in words: to respond briefly to a question.
2.
to make a return by some action as if in answer: to respond generously to a charity drive.
3.
to react favorably.
4.
Physiology . to exhibit some action or effect as if in answer; react: Nerves respond to a stimulus.
5.
to correspond (usually followed by to ).
comĀ·ment
[kom-ent] Show IPA
noun
1.
a remark, observation, or criticism: a comment about the weather.
2.
gossip; talk: His frequent absences gave rise to comment.
3.
a criticism or interpretation, often by implication or suggestion: The play is a comment on modern society.
4.
a note in explanation, expansion, or criticism of a passage in a book, article, or the like; annotation.
5.
explanatory or critical matter added to a text.
There you have it, straight from the dictionary.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
rosegarden the use of these terms outside m lot is different.
nmylot admins uses response to a discussion
and comment on responses and other comments
just observe above my box it says add a comment to this response?\
and just below it asks post comment.
follow my lot usage then we all will know what the hell each of us is talking about. myolot simplfies it b y having in huge letter here'
'ADde a comment to this respnse
amd below my box it sa ys post comment.
now if I was responding making my response to a dicussion it wo uld sayu
add your response to this discussion.
look I know the dictionaryh meaning but I am taling my lot use of
two different t erms.
1 person likes this
@surekharathi (14146)
• India
19 Nov 12
Grand ma I always put my comment related to discussions some time if not understand the contents then put my response on the basis of title.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi surekharathi glas t see you as you always make me smile. yes indeed'yu oiu
do and respond as well as you can in the time you hae. todays the sun is
shining brighttly and birds are singing its a lovely day aagin for
November here In c alifornia,
1 person likes this
@vidhyaprakash_2 (7116)
• India
19 Nov 12
Hatley, you are right, there is lot of difference between comments and response, we can add multiple comments in a topic, also we can comment over other persons replies, in short comment is a reply to the response, we can commenting over the comments and have a good interaction with our friends
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi vidhyprakash you are always so good to resopnd to my disucssions
and i am always pleased to see you . you always seem to understandwhere
I am coming from too. so many think here is no difference but mylot
showed us how toi use each ordk by placing a stagement above
our box and beloe it says post comment. so my lot uses them that way and so shoile we.
1 person likes this
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
19 Nov 12
I feel sometimes people try to hard to comment here. If they would just let their feeling go into their responces, I think wed get more out of them.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi maileaperalta so many newbies are so afraid theywill do somethign wron that they get in their own wayl just say what you feel is w hat I always tell
'them as you cannot go wrong that way . we all have feelings and a l ot of timnes we find that we are not alone in our feelings either. thats what makes mylot so great to talk to someone man y miles from me who also loves some of the
sam things I do y et we both have very different cultures and c ustoms. we are all humans too.commentng a lot on others comments has earned me quite w ell but best I have s o m uch fun here with knowing how others feel too.
@stan87 (47)
• Bulgaria
19 Nov 12
Hello Hatley!
You got a point here. It's good to see that thing are in place. Is it really teasing you that much? I'm just asking as I'm usually not bothered much by such things. But I agree, people should make sure they're doing the correct thing.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi stan not until I got into a slight argument over why we should make comments back to all who respond to our discussions a d this mylotter was telling non no'mylot says y ou do not have to leave a response if you cannot think of a good one for that particular discussion I reminded her that I was talking about making comments by the discussion maker on his or her responses she got from fellow my lotters. I was talking comments she was talking responses now had she been usingc omments to refer to the input we should add to the responses we
get she would have known what the devil I was getting at.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
26 Nov 12
I would be thrilled, overjoyed, sublimely happy if EVERYONE, i.e. all the members of myLot (note correct spelling and terminology) were to use the correct terminology.
However, being as not all of us are from the USA, or have English as their first language I think it's wrong to point the finger, even collectively.
I would also be amazingly happy if everyone previewed their post before sending or at the very least, used Spell-check but it will never happen.
Just saying.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
27 Nov 12
Dear Hatley, you asked for "your take" so I gave you mine. I was not targeting you. And you were, collectively, pointing the finger at those users who get things wrong.
I really don't understand you becoming so defensive here when you are usually one of the first ones to come to the rescue of those who do not normally write or even converse n English.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
17 Dec 12
oh myh gosh I am not usually like that Mstickle I was ill that day and really shojuld have waited til I felt well.Yes I was out of line as I was working with abdomional cramps and my reasoning was not very good. sorry bout that too
'as I do realize that a lot of people here have English as their second languages and some do improve so much over a few weeks which I know i would not do in learning another language, I do apologize really. Today I am myself again
for better or worsel. lol l
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
27 Nov 12
mstickle the only thing I was trying to get at is if two people are trying to discuss something and both are using different terms it can get really confusing. I was talking about I felt it rude to not comment back to us who
respond to the posters discussion and she was telling me it said in the guidelines that if we do not have anything really good for a response we can move on to another discussion. so I was trying to explain that I meant comments back on a response not responses. to a discussion.
And no I did not think I was pointing fingers at anyone here. my gosh others make discussions like this and nobody accuses them of being mean and pointing fingers so why me? Actually mylot shows us the terms they use if we look above our box and see an Add a comment to this response or post a response to this discussion. I know I am having a time with typos and yes I do use spelling checker and I do preview and edit but still miss a few in spite of all the precautions I take,Okay if anyone is feeling I am mean I apologize as I do not intend to be rude at all.
So comments are made on the responses we get and on others comments. Responses are to our discussions and other di and others resoponses too. This is not my doing it is how mylot uses comments and responses."So if anyone does not like those meanings go jump on my lot too.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
green moow mylot helps us if we pay attentionl above nmy oc is sayhs
add a comment to this response. s ure;y you trust mylot to mean
what it prints also below my box it says pot comment?
that is all I was try ing to show. people get upset over
mny telling the truth that is not my fa ult.
@sishy7 (27167)
• Australia
19 Nov 12
'responses to my comments' - there is no such thing
'responses to my topic of discussions' - the only response thing exist
'comments to my responses' - is what I'm doing to your response
'comments to my comments' - is what you or others will put under this comment; and those are the ones we don't get notified of.
1 person likes this
@changjiangzhibin89 (16784)
• China
19 Nov 12
Good topic! You corrected it in time.I am the very person who can't tell comment from response.In my previous respones,I alway confused comment with response.Thank you!
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
hi chang thanks as I thou ght maybe I would clarify theste two terms y ou resopnd to a discussion you comment on a response or another c omment thats
the si mple way of knowing which is which.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
24 Nov 12
hi chang I see I again managed to make some typos but you have the distinction now. responses a re what w e make to the posters discussion and c omments are what he or she makd back on our responses.[
@changjiangzhibin89 (16784)
• China
24 Nov 12
I notice that they did call the response which the discussion starter made" New comment" and call the response which the reader made to discussion "new response" in my yahoo inbox notification.Thank you!
1 person likes this
@mythociate (21432)
• Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
18 Nov 12
Do we get paid more for responses? if not, what's the big diff?
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
19 Nov 12
the big deal is that a response is what you make to another person's discussion and a comment back is what the discussion maker makes to those responses he or she gets. myulot uses these terms look below my vbox it says post comment.I am commenting back to your snippy response. no we not have rates here so who kno ws which pa ys more thats not the point at all. a comment is NOT A RESPONSE.LOOK AT HE POST SIGNS THAT WILL L SHOW YOU THE DIFFERENCE. TO YOU IT MIGHT NOT BE A BIG DEAL BUT IF Id am talking about we should comment back to all our responses and you sa y we should respond to all our responses that really does not make much sense.
1 person likes this
@hereandthere (45645)
• Philippines
20 Nov 12
maybe because when you open your email notifications from mylot, it always says "respond to this discussion" regardless if what you posted in your own or other people's discussions was a response or a comment. either way, i agree with others that what matters is i'm "replying" or "interacting" as we're supposed to.
what concerns me is some people seem to think a comment should be shorter than a response. i don't understand that. there have been times my response is short, like 2 sentences, but when someone commented, my additional comment is actually longer. why limit yourself if there's more to discuss or there's a need to clarify something? it will actually mean more earnings for you.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
20 Nov 12
hi hereandthere yes I agree we should always write as mu ch as we need to
to convey our input in comments too as well as in responses. I just tried'to pur out like this box right now mylot has a large s entence above add a comment to
this response and below the red tag line says post comment. that is the way I use comment and response. so nobody else cares fine. blame it on my lot not my idea but for me i like to use the correct terms my self.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
18 Nov 12
hi jdalaqui did I say anywhere in my discusson its a n offense? no but if two people mean two different things then its a little hard for them to
understand each other. because mylot u ses the tern response to mean
a response to a discussion,either mine or anyone elses
and a comment to mean a comment on those responses. so why not all of us
us use the same terminology? Mylot even uses it like right hereb elow my box it sa ys post comment. this is my comment to your
response.It might not be an offense but to someone who does post
a comment that is what she is going to say, I am not posting a response.
1 person likes this