Should believers play the lottery?

United States
November 29, 2012 6:51am CST
Where do you stand on playing the lottery? Is it gambling, harmless entertainment, or a vehicle for G-d's blessing? Actually the scripture says that the lot belongs to the L-rd. Does this mean that games of chance are divinely directed by G-d?
2 people like this
9 responses
@JohnRok1 (2051)
30 Nov 12
A preacher I heard (I think it was Jonathan Fletcher, now of Wimbledon) called John 19:24 an emotional argument against gambling. Most evangelical preachers have been against gambling and lotteries. Hywel Harris was an exception, but there was at least one other personal deficiency at one period in his life that hardly any other evangelical leader ever had. I do have Premium Bonds, but the reason I have them is the fact that the principal (as opposed to the interest, from which the "prizes" come) is as safe as the UK Constitution itself. Some investments and activities involve a mixture of skill and chance (e.g., investing in the stock market, starting a business). They are a different issue. But whatever we do needs to be to the glory of God, and "Keep thee far from a false matter".
1 person likes this
@JohnRok1 (2051)
1 Dec 12
Is your boss taking risks to keep himself in business and you in a job?
• United States
1 Dec 12
Ah...great thought. Certainly don't want to think that I would be someone who would deal falsely with another or lead another into sin because of my actions. I don't invest in the stock market because I've no skill and I don't have my own business because I really don't wanna work as hard as some of the folks do who have invested in one. I prefer to obtain my money the old fashioned way...I work for a boss and I work as unto the L-rd. I show up every day and I try to focus and do the best job that I can so I'm not defrauding my boss by poor performance.
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
29 Nov 12
I guess since mathematics is God's doing, so is probability. I think trouble occurs when one cannot stick to the wise verse "moderation in all things"! So if one gets addicted and gambles away the house from beneath their children's feet, that would be sinful/imperfect/not good. So if one cannot be moderate, than they should run far from it!
• United States
1 Dec 12
Ooohh...good point. I certainly agree. Most things are considered sin because it is acting upon a lust or an impure motive. I think if a person has entertainment money and they view it as spending discretionary income for entertainment purposes, then I don't see the harm. I do worry though about those people who put so much hope into winning and they play their last dollar...sad.
@chrystalia (1208)
• Tucson, Arizona
29 Nov 12
"casting lots" was the equivalent of flipping a coin or drawing straws-- quite common in the Old testament, not so much in the New. As I interpret it--the lots belong to G-d--this practice of drawing straws or tossing the proverbial dice was placing the given decision in G-d's hands-- it was used by Joshua, at G-d's direction, to divide up land in one instance I remember (though I can't quote the chapter and verse offhand). Casting lots, then would be leaving a decision up to G-d, and taking the result as the "answer", in a way. That being said--if G-d is omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent, then He already knows 1.who's buying the tickets 2.who's going to win. Of course it would be free will to buy a ticket. On the other hand, if He knows all that is going to happen, then some would argue that there IS no "free will" because the outcome is already known..and a case could be made on either side of that little conundrum. As I see it, foreknowledge of an outcome doesn't mean the outcome wasn't reached through free choices-- just that it is known. I don't think that G-d stacks the deck, so to speak--he just knows the winning hands. He leaves stacking the deck to us "The love of money is the root of all evil". NOTE-- the actual scripture says the LOVE of money (greed) not money itself. (1 Timothy 6:10). You can make a case that people play the lottery, or gamble, due to greed, or because they covet the lifestyle others enjoy-- therefore, such games would be sinful. I would assume that the vast majority of people who play lotteries, go to casinos, bet on the ponies, aren't motivated by the idea of using the money to help others. Christians seem to be going with gambling is a sin based on the greed aspect, as well as the fact casting lots was an Old Testament way of solving things, so with the coming of the Messiah, it isn't needed anymore--though the apostles cast lots to see who would replace Judas (probably drew straws, I would think). Any way you slice this particular pie, playing games of chance is usually connected to greed, or being covetous--so I would say it's probably a no-no. That being said--I didn't win the Powerball . OK, I bought 1 ticket. I'll go drag out the sack cloth and ashes now...and the hair shirt...and the scourge...
• United States
1 Dec 12
Alas, I cannot toss the first stone...I, too, bought a ticket. Not just one for myself but I insisted on taking my friend into 'sin' with me by purchasing one for her as well. I guess we did entertain ourselves with a couple of what ifs...but it was all in fun. We both work hard for our money and we neither one really desire the lives of the rich and famous. We just want a couple more things to make our life a bit more comfortable. But then we also realize that we are very, very, very comfortable when compared to those of other nations...and our own nation, as well.
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
2 Dec 12
We, too, were promised that the money raised by the lottery would go for education of the state's children. That is the reason my husband said he voted for it. It has not happened in Texas, or any other state that I know of.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Dec 12
I wonder if there is full disclosure somewhere to find out where the money is allocated? I don't think I've ever heard though.
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
1 Dec 12
The scripture you referenced was made during the time of miracles. I consider the lottery gambling and have nothing to do with it.
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Dec 12
My disappointment is that when we were asked to vote on the lottery it was billed as the answer to educational funding. But no, it didn't turn out to be that. We are still having teacher appeals for greater funding for schools and for their salaries. I think that if you do not have the money for your family that you will just have less money when you engage in lottery chances. I must agree that it falls into the category of gambling and that is why it was not permitted in our country in the early years of our country formation.
@narnia007 (1050)
• India
1 Dec 12
Surely lottery cannot be connected with Gods work.As it is similar to getting money without doing any work.Thus it can not be expected that God will help in getting such benefits.Also people wont stop and is usually associated with greediness
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Dec 12
Yes, we have had to add gambler's anonymous to a list of self help groups that deal with people who just can't say no. I recall a scripture because of your response. It says that if you don't work, you don't eat. Of course, it is advice to a church food sharing program and it means that as a general rule, all should contribute in some way. There are to be no free loaders. My concern is that as the media stated that most people who play the lottery are the poor....are they using the only money they have to feed their families, then going to the food pantry or the food stamp program and getting help? That would be wrong, in my opinion.
@livewyre (2450)
29 Nov 12
No, that is not what it means - I think on occasion it has been used to work out God's purpose in specific circumstances, but in a game of chance, I am pretty sure there is no divine intervention. In the UK, a national lottery was introduced, and the funds diverted to various 'good' causes, however, I believe that this is largely a tax on the poor - it is the poor who contribute disproportionally to the 'pot', and the proceeds are used to fund things that arguably, the Government should be funding (if they are indeed good). I don't want to sound mean, but a game of chance that raises far more money that it will ever pay out, is not the type of 'investment' an intelligent person makes. On spiritual, moral and political grounds, I strongly object to the fact that we have a national lottery in the UK and that gambling laws generally have been loosened so that gambling can appeal to a wider audience.
@livewyre (2450)
29 Nov 12
I meant to say that I would not say that believers shouldn't play the lottery, I believe it's a personal choice, but one that I would never do myself. There is a growing tradition at weddings, for the bride and groom to buy tickets for all the guests as a gift, if I was to win in those circumstances. I would be a bit embarrassed, but maybe then you COULD all that divine intervention
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Dec 12
Yes, ethical or not I have received them as door prizes from work meetings, etc. I don't know whether I think it is scripturally right or wrong, but I believe that one's motive for playing should be the guide for whether to them it is a sin. I would think it truly a blessing from G-d if someone gave me a winning ticket, as well. Because my Bible says that good and perfect gifts come from H-m.
@livewyre (2450)
2 Dec 12
I think our philosophies match - I wouldn't actively participate, but I wouldn't condemn others for doing so - there are more important issues. We had a motto in our church some years ago, which I think is still relevant today "Let's keep the main thing, the main thing". Which means, let's not worry about whether a brother is smoking, playing the lottery or mixing with people we don't like - Let's worry about where his heart is at, whether Jesus is important to him. It's primarily saying 'Let's worry about the big stuff, not get caught up with minor doctrinal issues' - I think that's a spiritually healthy outlook.
@srganesh (6340)
• India
9 Dec 12
I don't see it as gambling or entertainment but a hope for the desperate to see a beautiful tomorrow. I don't know what the scriptures speak about lottery but personally I feel that lottery is good unless it becomes addiction. So play it safely without greed.
• United States
29 Nov 12
I do not think that gambling is condemned in the scriptures. I can't think of a scripture that prohibits it in the believer's life. I would say that it might not be the wisest use of our money (unless we win of course!) But they used "casting lots" which is a form of gambling to me --
• United States
1 Dec 12
Yeah...it may fall into that category of things we are admonished to avoid if we think it will be offensive to a weaker brother? I realize it was talking about food offered to idols, but perhaps the principle could be applied to this case?