Dhoni taking wrong decisions!!!

Howrah, India
December 16, 2012 6:31am CST
I don't what happen to Dhoni,is he become mad or what? He was known as the most coolest and cleaver captain, taking some decision that putting India in deep trouble.Just think about today's decision of declaring when India was 326/9 still 4 runs behind of England's score of 330/10.If India was still behind the score of England and there was a chance to give some lead to England why Dhoni choose to declare I don't understand.I know India was 9 down but why I would declare each and every run is important,and Ashwin was playing really well 29 not out. Share your views about today's decision of declaring...
2 people like this
8 responses
@prash133 (12)
• India
17 Dec 12
Yes,Captain Cool is tensed.This match is do or die situation for dhoni .If he lose this match this is going to be his last match
@ajithlal (14716)
• India
27 Dec 12
I also think that Dhoni right now is little tensed and when people get tensed they tend to make more mistakes and I think most probably team India should rotate the players.
• Ahmednagar, India
17 Dec 12
Last match - Oh yes!? How do you know that? But how will he be playing his last match? Is he going to retire? Now when you read this there might be some other thoughts in your mind and let me clear them - the selectors are not going to dump Dhoni. He is a great captain and an even greater player. India needs him. A couple of failures here or there doesn't mean the end of the world for anyone. Look, he will be there for many years to come.
2 people like this
@dollar3235 (2062)
• India
16 Dec 12
Dhoni has gone crazy, I don't get the point why couldn't he wait for some more time? He could waited for a few more overs. Nothing will change in 3-4 overs in a test match, at least we would have got some lead and a different pressure on the England team. Now that they've two set batsmen on crease all we can do is to hope for the best, however, that seems more unlikely. God only knows what's in Dhoni's mind !!!
1 person likes this
• Howrah, India
17 Dec 12
Not even Ashwin every Indian batsman was not so aggressive in this test why he could't wait for 10-15 min when India was still 4 runs behind???
• India
17 Dec 12
To be very frank, at this time, we don't have a single bowler, spinner or fast bowler. If you see, in other countries even the part timers are better than Indian bowlers. E.g. look at Zaheer Khan and Ashwin. If you can't take 7 wickets in one day, then you don't deserve to be Indian team. They should look for some fresh talent, batting will be improved with time but this bowling department needs new players, none of the existing bowlers has got any talent. Now I know why Dhoni declared so early, he knew the strength of his bowlers.
@ajithlal (14716)
• India
27 Dec 12
I think Dhoni is not in good form and most probably is burned and is making more and more wrong decisions. I think most probably Dhoni should rest in two to three matches and then come back and play for team India.
@sweety_81 (2124)
• India
18 Dec 12
I think that if Dhoni was thinking of trying to make a match, he should have asked Ashwin to play a bit faster. Even if we had got out, lead would not have been much bigger. Or else, let him scored a bit more. However, the way Indian bowlers performed in the second innings, bowling England out looked difficult. They were clearly the better team.
1 person likes this
@abhi_bangal (5518)
• Ahmednagar, India
17 Dec 12
Please stop blaming that man, first. Did you blame him when he came out to bat at no. 4 - not his usual position, in the finals against Sri Lanka and guided Team India to the WC win? Well, if he had failed in that match, we all would be asking for his head, isn't it? And stop praising Ashwin for his 29 runs. Remember, the Indian team took 62 looooooooooong minutes just to score 29 runs on the fourth morning. What was the point in wasting those precious 62 minutes when we know we don't have bowlers who can quickly bowl out the English team. Well, bowl out we can't even take wickets reasonably fast in this series. And the condition is this on home pitches. Ashwin and Ojha should have thrown their bat at everything on that day. And remember, a message coming out only after 16 minutes of play yesterday morning. Not even a county team would have sent out a message in only 16 minutes to their team mates batting there. This shows our unpreparedness. I would say that India should have declared overnight itself and given their bowlers more time to take the wickets. And yes, once again, it is not right to blame only one man. The decisions are taken by the team management and not by one person alone. When Dhoni came out at no. 4 against Lanka, it was the team decision and not his alone. Please grow up, man!
• Ahmednagar, India
17 Dec 12
I think you are able enough to differentiate between the two scenarios - Dhoni scoring 99 runs and Ashiwn scoring 29 runs. Why 246 balls, I will say even if he had taken another 100 balls to score those 99 runs, it would have been fine. India was 71/4 when the big partnership started. Just calculate for yourself, and you will find that the match that was declared drawn at about 3 PM today, might have ended in England's favor yesterday itself. When Ashwin scored those 29 runs, India was already safe and had played for time and not for a win and a 1-3 drubbing. And one thing, you said 'now' I am supporting Dhoni. My friend, it is not now, but it is for ever and ever that I have been backing him. I have many articles written on this topic at various websites and even discussions here where I have never admired a player either too much or never had brickbats against him at the same intensity. We Indians either have flowers for our cricketers or thorns. There's no between here. And yes, some decisions will never be taken by a captain as an individual. It is always a team decision. Remember Ian Bell being called back. What do you think, when Dhoni was asked three times by the umpires to give him out or not, he got enlightened in the dressing room and decided to recall him? It was a team meeting that he should be called back - not Dhoni's alone. And when should a bowler be given the ball to bowl is entirely the captain's call. Don't think a captain never has a say in any matter. But even a captain has to remain under the management's rules. He is not a dictator all the while and not even a servant.
1 person likes this
• Ahmednagar, India
17 Dec 12
I had so much to say, I forgot to mention one thing - I didn't say Ashwin took 62 minutes to score 29 runs. It was the end of the third day when India was on 296 and declared on 326. I was talking of those 29 runs. Incidentally, both Ashwin's and India's additional runs were 29. Ashwin's actual stay was of 91 minutes while facing 65 balls.
1 person likes this
• Howrah, India
17 Dec 12
Now you are supporting Dhoni just by saying that it was not his decision total team decision oh!!! well that means every match that Dhoni wins as a captain of India has no contribution to India as captain right cause it was total team decision.So, we are wasting time on saying Dhoni is a great captain cause it's the team who take decision right??? We all know captain has a great role in every decision take in the match so if he wanted to bat India till the end he can do it.And you are saying Ashwin take looooong 62 minutes for his 29 runs,then just think about Dhoni he took loooooooooooooooooooong 246 balls to make 99. Each an every Indian batsman straggling to make runs its not about Dhoni, Kholi or Ashwin so that was not a big factor...
1 person likes this
• India
16 Dec 12
I think he sportingly declared the innings so that he could get ample time in getting 10 english wickets in the 2nd innings and then head for a win, he was loosing precious time, so he thought of declaring...I understand every run is valuable, but one has to think positively and hope for the best...which I think at the end of 4th days play doesn't seem so..
• Howrah, India
16 Dec 12
I understand your opinion but tell me one thing even if India will able to take 10 wickets of England then also India will have to bat 2nd Innings to win the match.So, to win the match you have to score runs,so why not in first innings??
@ram_cv (16513)
• India
17 Dec 12
I actually think it was right to declare at that moment. The only way India is going to win is by bowling out England and chasing whatever they put on the board. On this pitch you need at least 3-4 sessions to bowl an opposition. As it is after 2 and half sessions, India has managed to pick only 3 wickets. If anything the fact that India scored only 7 runs in the first half hour of today's play was what was disappointing to me. Also yesterday, throwing it away with run-out was poor cricket from Dhoni. Cheers! Ram
@natliegleb (5175)
• India
16 Dec 12
i would say yes because he is counting on luck and i believe they must have fired for the last wicket and then got out rather than being declared for such a miser total at the last moment,it hurts india now badly