I read new study shows extra pounds prevent early death risk

@stary1 (6612)
United States
January 2, 2013 12:41pm CST
LOL so now I read on MSN and USA Today that being overweight by 30 pounds can actually help reduce the risk of early death. I am notsure what early death means..but what a story to come out when so many have weight loss New Years resolutions I think as one gets older they need a few extra pounds to keep from showing a lot of face wrinkles and looking anorexic..still if you think about it..someone who is 110 as a teen and eary 20's weight would probalby be ok at 140 in their 60's... Exercise is important all your life, but a few pounds are better than the stick thin figures..imo anayway...
4 people like this
9 responses
@celticeagle (166761)
• Boise, Idaho
2 Jan 13
You don't want to be too over weight nor too skinny. Neither is healhy. A happy and healthy medium is the way to go. Afew extra pounds won't hurt anyone. And make your organs happy. No sluck or gluck.
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
3 Jan 13
celticeagle I agree and it isn't always weight that determines..those who exercise a lot will have more muscle and more weight than their appearance indicates ...
2 people like this
@celticeagle (166761)
• Boise, Idaho
4 Jan 13
And muscle is important. Have you read the Blue Zone?
1 person likes this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
4 Jan 13
celticeagle I have never even heard of the blue zone..is it some type of new way to evaluate weight?
2 people like this
@GardenGerty (160626)
• United States
2 Jan 13
I look at the pictures of me in my late teens and early twenties and it is like a different person. On the other hand, I way almost 100 pounds more now, and that is too much. I still do not look like it. I would like to way about fifty pounds less than I do now, and by the charts I would still be overweight. As you age you need some weight to fall back on in case you become ill. The question becomes whether or not your weight interferes with your health and your activities of daily living. I know we keep aiming for too thin a profile.
2 people like this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
3 Jan 13
GardenGerty It's true as we age we should weigh a bit more..and it depends on bone structure and height etc... I am happy to see some of the fashions rejecting stick thin models, but I feel they are still a bit too thin. Health is of course everything...
1 person likes this
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
3 Jan 13
I don't believe that one standard setting for weight determines what is best for all. And in my 49 years of life I've not yet met a man whom actually likes a stick figure. I'm not referring to a healthy individual whom is thin, I'm talking about those whom are so thin it hurts to look at them. When I was 17 I weighed about 110 but I was certainly more active. A few years ago I was at 199lbs. Most people didn't believe that because I could hide it with how I dressed. And there was a time in my early 20's that I weighed about 100 lbs because I was doing things I should not have been. When I was under weight I would cry when I bathed. I looked terrible. At the other extreme I was diagnosed borderline diabetic. I mean .1% away from diabetes. I know weigh 171 and while still over weight by about 10 lbs in my opinion, I certainly feel better, my sugar is better also. What I am getting at is while one should be physically at a healthy weight, I also believe that it's how one feels about themselves that factors in for overall health. I'm more excited about life so I'm apt to be more active and eat better because I'm happier. I do look at other women's bodies. Not because I'm in to women but because seeing that my husband and I agree on whom looks great helps me see myself better because he is with me. Is that any more important than magazines and television showing models whom are excessively thin as what men want? No. It does boil down to what I think of myself, how I feel, and my health. Everyone is different and has different needs. I have an aunt that can barely take an aspirin without it knocking her out. I generally have the opposite reaction to medications. If it's supposed to knock you out it hypes me up. What is healthy for you may not be for me and that includes weight. Just my thoughts.
1 person likes this
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
4 Jan 13
Aboslutely, my emotional state can lead to over eating. Or if I'm bored. However, I try to keep some healthy snacks about the house. That fresh green apple dipped in all natural peanut butter sure was good last night. And it was filling.
1 person likes this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
5 Jan 13
Carolyn63 I try to keep healthy snacks too..but my hubby keeps thinking he is being good to me by bringing home stuffd I crave that are not good for me..like chocholate cake and brownies I keep telling him he wants to fatten me up so no other man will look at me I always have peanut butter and apples and bananas..my problem with peanut butter is I can eat it right out of the jar and keep repeating that..and I do if stressed I buy only creamy because the crunchy is way too tempting...and I keep it to smaller jars... just in case...I once read one was not suppose to eat it straight from the jar because it causes chocking..but that never happened to me so I sort of ignore that warning now...
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
4 Jan 13
Carolyn63 You have some interesting points. I will agree everyone is different..and being happy very much influences health and so perhaps weight too. Some are more concerned with body image and try harder. Certainly I relate to feelings and food...being overly down or up can lead to overeating for me...
@trisha27 (3494)
• United States
13 Jan 13
If I was 30 pounds overweight, I know that I would not like it at all. I'm right now trying to lose like 20 pounds before I become 30 pounds or even 40 pounds over weight. I'm happy at 110 being 140 or 150 is not healthy for me I know it for a fact and I couldn't deal with it. I'd be very depressed. I remember my husband told me when I was bigger, I was depressed, but when I lost the weight I had been more happier. I think too at 150 I had a lot of health issues going on and the doctors advised me to lose the weight and I was just overweight by 40 pounds. So I don't agree with that article at all. If I was under 110 I wouldn't be happy with it either, because I'd look like a skeleton. I've seen myself under 110 and it isn't pretty. 110 and maybe 115 are good enough for me.
1 person likes this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
9 Feb 13
trisha27 I think too it depends on your age...I was slimmer when I was in my 20's and 30's..if I weighed the same now I would look anorexic... Of course bottom line with all these stuides is use yor own common sense..which [s just what you appear to be doingi
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
3 Jan 13
I'm getting to the point where I hardly believe any of these studies, since they often contradict each other. I try to use common sense -- eating healthy foods with lots of fruits and vegetables and almost no sugar or white flour. I feel better that way, and it seems to keep me from getting fatter when I stick to it. I also try to spend some time in physical activity of some kind every day, some days more than others. My health measures aren't ideal, and neither is my weight. I'd still like to lose about 30 pounds to get back to my 30-year-old weight. It was easier when I was young because I could walk everywhere in town I needed to go and I did. In college I had to walk long distances to classes and back to the dorm each day, sometimes going back and forth three times a day. UCLA was a large campus, and I'm sure I walked at least a mile a day and probably more. Now I'm lucky if I can get a half hour walk in a day.
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
3 Jan 13
bagarad Provided one is a normal weight at 30, wouldn't that same weight be too thin in their 50's and 60's?? I think it would be for me. Walking it the best exercise I remember one place my Mom lived she didn't have a place to walk so she would take her wind up clock and go to her backyard and walk round and round in a big circle for half an hour....I certainly gave her a lot of credit!!!.
2 people like this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
9 Feb 13
Sometimes I'm tempted to do the same thing, but I usually say I'll just walk in the neighborhood for ten minutes. Once I get started, I forget to stop and often walk up to an hour.
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
2 Jan 13
oh no, Im in trouble. Im a small thing and at 119 lbs. If I add 30 Id look so bad. A little tank or something. Take care dear. See ya here soon..
2 people like this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
3 Jan 13
mariaperalta I think age is the biggest factor here...when you are 60 perhaps 149 would be ok?? Unless you are very short...
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
20 Jan 13
hi stary if one is already overweight and gain another thirty pounds would really screw up my controlling my blood sugar. So I go by what my primary care doctor says and do not get on the various new sudies kick. I have starting losing was 210 now 1sdays lose if slowly so it will stay off and make a life style change not a diet at all.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
4 Jan 13
Who decided just what IS a healthy weight anyway? lol Hey, as a person who had to buy all new jeans cause I'd 'outgrown' the others, I would have to agree with the article!! lol Seriously, it is what you eat not how much. If you're eating healthy, EAT ALL YOU WANT and up the exercise a bit.
1 person likes this
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
4 Jan 13
debrakcarey It's true..we keep hearing different theories of what is jhealthy. While it's true what you eat is extremely imprortant, I also think moderation in all things is a good rule...
• India
16 Jan 13
As we age gracefully, if we are happy, it is very likely we gain weight, more so after 40, i was keeping at 90 kg most of the time, but after retirement, i was less active, my weight became 110 kg, not good lol. With yoga i brought it down to 85, am happy lol.
1 person likes this