Separation of Church and State

@MaylaJay (349)
January 11, 2013 9:34am CST
There's a lot that supposedly goes into this phrase. This is supposed to stop the government from identifying with a particular religion. However dollar bills say "In God We Trust" The Pledge of Allegiance says "One nation, under God" Do these things not identify the government with Christianity? The phrase is supposed to also distance religion and school, but most graduations have a prayer in the beginning of the ceremony and at the end. So again, church is not separated. Is this fair? Should things be changed? What are your opinions?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@iuliuxd (4453)
• Romania
11 Jan 13
Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man & his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, & not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should "make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof," thus building a wall of separation between Church & State. Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore to man all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties. [b] I reciprocate your kind prayers for the protection & blessing of the common father and creator of man[/b], and tender you for yourselves & your religious association, assurances of my high respect & esteem. Th Jefferson Jan. 1. 1802. So you see, back then they didn`t think that separation of church and state means creating an atheist state, but a state where all religions are allowed and threated the same way because in the end we all have a common father and creator of man.
@iuliuxd (4453)
• Romania
11 Jan 13
It is not my belief, it is a fragment from the letter where the "separation between church and state" thing appeared. As you see in the same letter Jefferson still talks about the common father and creator of man so maybe that`s why you have written on your money "in God we trust". Maybe "in God we trust " meant "in the common father and creator of man we trust "
@MaylaJay (349)
11 Jan 13
It is still a religious belief.
@MaylaJay (349)
11 Jan 13
That is your belief and irrelevant. The discussion is about whether we have achieved separation of church and state. I'm not talking about atheism, I'm talking about government not identifying with any religion or religious belief.
• United States
11 Jan 13
Take a look at the dollar bills a bit.On the left, it is the all seeing eye and on the right, it is horus. These two elements are not part of churches. They actually belong in temples. Also the term God can mean any God and not just the Christian one. So in a way, the church is still separate from the state. It feels nice to say one nation under God. I don't see any problem with it. In fact it is rather broad. So when saying that line a Freemason can feel he is getting close to his Horus. A Christian would think of his God and a Muslim would mediate on his own God. As for atheists, they perhaps, do not believe in Christianity, but majority of them do feel that there is a super national power out there who is running the world. So the line would simply keep most people happy.
@MaylaJay (349)
11 Jan 13
The point here is that there is no solid proof that any god exists so putting "In God We Trust" or saying "one nation under God" is identifying a religious belief which means there is no separation of church and state.
• United States
12 Jan 13
Well, God is super natural. Mainly because of this, he is known as God. Religion is consists of an organized belief system. But what I was trying to say is that the term of God is not completely defined by the line. Only if the line included in Jesus we trust then it would have been linked church with the state. Muslims, Jewish and many others do not go to church. They have their mosque and temples. One nation under God has nothing to do with church at all. The line simply takes God in broader sense.
@MaylaJay (349)
12 Jan 13
Yes, I see your point. I still think that connects to religion however, because saying you trust in God, no matter which one you relate to, it is still a belief, not a fact and therefore part part of religion.
@dainy1313 (2370)
• Leon, Mexico
11 Jan 13
Hi MaylaJay, philosophy states that human beings need to be attached to a superior being. Finally they mention God, sadly they donĀ“t mention Jesuschrist. Just a vague figure "God". But in fact, they are attached to a superior being to justify efforts. Blessings Maylajay... dainy
@matersfish (6306)
• United States
11 Jan 13
It is impossible to separate the church from the state when the vast majority of those in charge of the state are members of the church. It's as simple as that. Loopholes and grey areas will always be found, and that little thing called "tradition" will always be there to fall back on. To want separation causes many religious people (as seen around here already) to claim that atheists want to take over and to impose on everyone. Yeah. Oh, the persecution. My take on this has always been simple. Change "God" to "Allah" and watch the widespread panic. Then we'll see more people actually wanting a more defined separation.
@MaylaJay (349)
12 Jan 13
I agree. It is unfair for the minority that gets only negative light. The ones represented are the religious ones and more specifically, the ones that believe in God, the God of the Bible.
@MaylaJay (349)
17 Jan 13
I just want to see that!
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
11 Jan 13
There is not a separation of church and state though there should be for many laws. However, I agree with one poster in the sense that God is such a broad term as people tend to interpret things differently. I never said the pledge of allegiance because I didn't agree with it and for my high school at least there was no prayer before and after. I do think things should change a bit though. As for the money, I don't think people pay much more attention to money than the numbers printed on it to make sure they can buy something or pay for something. As for the pledge of allegiance they should just get rid of it and people of any faith should agree. Seriously, you want your child to believe in God and then pledge their allegiance to a flag or country of man. Another thing you missed if the need to get married either by a legal justice OR established religious official who is ordained. However, atheist may not want just a legal justice but another atheist to marry them or for a wiccan a handfasting. I think they should either recognize every single deity and religion (or lack thereof) or none at all.
6 Apr 17
Not really. The government wants to take prayer and God out of school. The government has nothing to do with religion accept for the Catholic Hierarchy, which is a system that is similar to the state legislature.