Fake profiles on online forums
By Porcospino
@Porcospino (31366)
Denmark
January 13, 2013 6:09pm CST
On another discussion site I read a discussion about a fake profile. One of the members from that site had started a lot of discussions about her life. According to her discussions she had a very happy life with her husband. She was pregnant and started a lot of discussions about her pregnancy.
One day her "husband" posted a discussion where he told people that their twins had been born, and many people congratulated him. He wrote in the discussion that he had posted a picture of the twins in his profile. One of other users recognized the photo (it was taken from the internet) and wrote in the discussion that the photo was fake. The admin later confirmed that her entire profile was fake and that the person behind the profile had made up all the details about her happy life.
The story is not so unusual. Many people lie online and make up stories, but the strange thing was that the person behind this profile wrote from their fake profile for 3 years! She shared all sorts of details from her life and often asked for advice. The people who tried their best to give her advice and help her with the problems that never existed are disappointed and angry. She had many friends on the site and many users had exchanged private messages with her.
The person behind the fake profile was very active. She wrote about her life almost daily and it must have been an awful lot of work to remember all the details about the life that she made up. What makes people keep a fake profile for 3 years? Have you met fake profile on discussion forums?
7 people like this
26 responses
@McCreeper (777)
• United States
14 Jan 13
Some people have these fake profiles as a way to be a social climber. While it may not affect MyLot that much, it's probably easier to develop a certain persona to make more discussions than to type about your own life. Sometimes things in life are too mundane, so there could be times where discussions can be more "gilded" and more exaggerated to where it sounds like people could contribute in the discussion.
I have previous experience of finding these type of people. It's quite unfortunate why they do this, but they have their separate reasons.
3 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
14 Jan 13
I think that some people think that their own lives are boring and make up things instead of writing about their own lives, but I don't really understand the idea behind that. I mean it must be a lot of work to remember all the details and avoid contradicting themselves It must be especially difficult if you are very active and share lots of details about your "life".
The girl that I mentioned when I started the discussion was able to keep her fake profile for 3 years and she shared a lot of details about her fictive life. The people who tried to help her give her advice about the problems that never existed are hurt and angry now, because they feel that they have wasted their time, and I understand that.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
14 Jan 13
I don't understand the thoughts behind that. I mean adding you to a different account instead of using the real friends list. On discussion sites I have seen people who create more than one profile or create a fake profile where they describe a fictive life. I think that same things happen social networking sites, but I haven't experienced it myself, or if it happened I didn't notice it.
1 person likes this
@Arieles (2473)
• United States
14 Jan 13
You know what? I didn't (don't) understand it either. I never will and I think it's childish. It's a form of bullying really, they have to hide behind fake profiles and they don't have the guts to confront you themselves, well...it is childish.
2 people like this
@jcj_111776 (3216)
• Philippines
14 Jan 13
Actually I've encountered such profile in a Love Forum at Postloop. In her first post, she was asking for any advice regarding her brother's behavior towards his ex-wife.
Some members gave their advice and she responded back. Those members were totally clueless until another senior member of that said forum announced that she found a similar thread started by this woman. With the exact situation. But this time, the woman was talking about her and her husband.
It turned out that this woman was posting bogus situations. The senior member have directly told her to not mess with the forum for there are people who are truly in need of help and advice.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Jan 13
When I read your description I first thought that the woman pretended talk about her brother because she didn't want to admit that it was her own problems like some people write about their "friend" when they are embarrassed to admit their own problems, but it sounds like that wasn't the case here and she simply made up stories.
Maybe she thought that she had found an easy way to earn money at Postloop. Some people make up things in order to earn, and the people who did their best to help them with the problems that never existed get angry and disappointed when they discover the truth.
@silverfox09 (4708)
• United States
14 Jan 13
How did the admin know she was fake if only the picture was !? How did she remember all those lie , sound kinda crazy because 3 years out of lying for no reason . Its not like we are breaking world record online are becoming famous I dont know why people just lie about silly things like those unless they are crazy.
I remembered sometime ago I made up fake age to join over 18 chatroom lol and they booted me and my friend out a week later. Those were good time because we wanted to be in an adult room .
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Jan 13
I am not sure how the admin discovered the truth about her. As an admin he has access to IP addresses and other kinds of information, but he never revealed how he discovered the truth. I never really understood why she kept her fake profile for 3 years. I think that most people would get tired of a fake profile after a while, but she continued and she became friends with many of the other users and exchanged private messages with them. Some of her friends feel bad now because they think that they were too naive, but she must have been quite convincing.
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
14 Jan 13
I have also seen that, at another site I belong to. Once we had a guy who said he was 22 years old. After a year of chatting and posting. He posted one day he was really only 14. i would have banned him for that. But they didnt.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
14 Jan 13
One year that is long time to lie about something like that. On the Danish forum where I am a member we also meet 14-year-old teenagers who sign up and pretend to be adults, but they never last long. After a while they usually exaggerate too much and write things that reveal their true age and then they are banned. The guy at your site must have been better at hiding his true identity since he was able to keep his false identity as a 22-year-old for one year. I would also banned him if I had been the admin of that site.
1 person likes this
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
14 Jan 13
this guy was even a site mod. Thats why I would have banned him after finding out. But they didnt. Hes a good kid, just made a mistake.
2 people like this
@deiusz (193)
• Indonesia
14 Jan 13
that's people really stable with her commitment about this case, in fact that you dont know for all that time, that's very long time.
And i wonder how did you know that it's fake profile/live about her and her husband?
I assume that you knew her from mylot too not in real life. applaus to you that you can detect the fake profile in here...great..
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Jan 13
It didn't happen here on Mylot, it was a different discussion site. It was the thing about the fake picture that started the whole thing. One of the other users from that site recognized the photo that she had posted in her profile. The person behind the fake profile had written that it was a picture of her newborn twins, but it was actually a photo of some twins that she had found on the internet. The other user had seen the original picture on the internet and she knew that something was wrong. The admin read the discussion and started investigating and after some time we told us that it was a fake profile, but I am not sure how he discovered the truth.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
17 Jan 13
Yes, she must have been smart. It must have been so much work to remember the details about her stories and she was very active and participated almost daily. She must have had a fantastic memory or a detailed notebook next to the computer. Most people would probably have made a mistake after some time and then the truth would have been discovered. Her first mistake was that photo that she posted, and some people think that it wasn't a mistake and she did it on purpose because she wanted get caught since she wasn't able to stop on her own, but I don't know about that.
@elitess (5070)
• Ipswich, England
22 Feb 13
In just one word the answer must be: money ! Especially if the said person had a fake profile here at mylot. If the case happened on another site, where there are no payments, another reason might be the age restriction - some forums have a 13years old minimum age for joining.
If there was no money or age restriction, I can't really see why a person would do this, except maybe if he plans on writing novels ? Creating a lot online can help developing a virtual life that he can afterwards write about.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
23 Feb 13
If the someone has a fake profile on Mylot my first thought would also be money. If a person created a fake profile on Mylot and started writing about a fictive life I would imagine that he or she simply wanted to earn money. The thing that you mentioned about the age restriction could be another reason why some people create fake profile. I have sometimes seen that kind of profiles where a teenager pretends to be an adult. In the beginning they are able to hide the truth, but after a while they usually write things that reveal their true age.
@wilsongoddard (7291)
• United States
14 Jan 13
Everyone lies. That is true whether you are online or off. Generally, though, most people tell small, socially-acceptable "white lies." We do that to avoid hurting people's feelings or to try to secure our positions within the community (i.e., making it seem that the hubby is bringing in a bit more income than he really is). We want for things to look a bit better than they really are.
However, when someone creates such an extensive, long-running lie, that is an indication that the person is mentally unbalanced.
I am who I am, regardless of what user name I use or what site I'm on. I have enough going on in my life that I have neither the inclination nor the energy to be anyone else. I sort of pity those who feel inclined to create such extensive webs of lies. How very empty their lives must be that they must resort to being someone else.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
18 Jan 13
Yes, I think that white lies are very common especially in situations where we don't want to hurt the other person, but it is a different situation when a person creates a fake life and writes about their fake life almost daily. I never understood why a person would spend so much time describing their fake life. It much be a lot of work to keep track of all the details. I couldn't imagine doing the same thing as she did. I definately prefer to write about own life. That way I am able to get advice or opinions that I can use in my daily life, I wouldn't get that if I spent my time describing problems that didn't exist.
@nessabean (11)
• United States
14 Jan 13
I agree, I would be totally exhuasted making up all that stuff. With a new baby I have enough to worry about!
1 person likes this
@LovingMyBabies (85288)
• Valdosta, Georgia
14 Jan 13
I have no idea how people keep up with so many lies when they do these kind of things. To me it is pointless to lie so much like that. Why not tell the truth about who you really are?
I guess their life is so boring and so uninteresting that they feel the need to do this. I don't think its possible to have that boring of a life to do that. My life is not at all glamourous or anything but I don't feel the need to make things up that way.
And the sad part is you do end up hurting many people by making things up like that. People help you and give advice from their hearts. When they find out it was all lies of course it hurts them too! Sad.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Jan 13
I also think that it would be pointless to create a fake profile and write about things that never happened. I definately prefer to write about my own life, that way I get real comments and advice that I can use. I would also feel bad about making up things and asking for advice about things that don't exist like that girl did. People try their best to help and they would be hurt if they found out that everything was a lie. I wonder why a person would invent a fake life and describe the details almost daily I guess that they feel that there own life so boring that nobody would be interested in hearing about it, but I still find it hard to understand it.
@MissPiggy (1748)
• Indonesia
14 Jan 13
Well, I can understand it if it's the social networking where people can make more than one accounts (some of them make it to support the games they play.) But in discussion forums? Wow...that was something else. Moreover this person has made up a story for three years! I must say it's amazing. But still I can't believe it, why would she/he do that?
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
18 Jan 13
I think that she would be a great author. She is great at creating a fictive universe and she could use that talent in a better way...
@MissPiggy (1748)
• Indonesia
17 Jan 13
Well, I think you're right. That's why she made up the story. I don't think it's impossible to manage the story for three years. However, I think she better writes a book rather than hanging around on a site creating a life. Seriously, she could benefit herself in this way and also gets famous.
1 person likes this
@besweet (9859)
• Ireland
14 Jan 13
Wow, 3 years is very long! It's very easy to tell lies but harder to keep up with them and remember everything! I am guessing that without that picture that person would still be there! She probably had a notebook to remember everything! Lol
I imagine that this is very possible to happen online, you can never know if what you read is true. If there can be a positive aspect in this, I would say that maybe her discussions were not a complete waste of time because all those answers and the members advice might have been useful for other people who actually had those problems in real life and got some help from those posts!
I was wondering, what did she answer about the fake baby pics when the lie was discovered?
1 person likes this
@silverfox09 (4708)
• United States
14 Jan 13
Yeah that could be it , she want to live in an imaginary world and if so she might really have psychological problems. I agree 3 years is long time to be keeping up with lies .
2 people like this
@NailTech (6874)
• United States
14 Jan 13
She probably had some kind of mental disorder. Her life might have been so empty that she made up things like that in order for people to like her. In real life she was living a lie. It is really sad. In one group on MSN a few years back when it was not closed, we had a girl there that made up the fact she had cancer and even had a friend go along with her to "back it up". Then on another MSN site I saw where she was caught. I didn't mention it cause I didn't wanna be the one to say I saw it first. Plus there were other things to consider...But it turns out she did it so people would make her more "gifts" of the kind we made there.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
14 Jan 13
I also think that she could be mentally ill. Many people lie online, but I think that it is unusual keep a fake profile for several years and actually write about her fake life almost daily. It makes me wonder what he own life is like. It is probably very different from the happy and perfect life that she has created online. I think that it is a strange thing to lie about having cancer, but I have heard about other people who have done the same thing in order to gain attention. The girl that you mentioned also did it to gain something, but I still don't understand why some people would lie about a serious illness, I would feel bad about deceiving people that way.
1 person likes this
@inopiratum_a_medio12 (877)
•
14 Jan 13
too bad! I never thought someone you've shared will do something like that just to win the crowd and get attention. I haven't encounter such people yet but that's true you can be what you want to be when online since dominant participants are strangers but that will be so annoying and waste of time to entertain someone fake.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
15 Jan 13
Yes, when you write about you life on the internet you don't meet people in real life and it is easy to pretend that you are someone else. Some people create a whole new identity on the internet and start discussions about experiences and problems that they have made up.
When people discover that they spent their time helping someone and giving advice to someone who made it all up they get angry and disappointed of course, because it feels like a waste of time. The advice might help other people with similar problems so in that sense it isn't a complete waste of time, but it is still not nice to discover that the things from the discusions never actually happened.
@cupkitties (7421)
• United States
14 Jan 13
I remember people talking about something like this years ago in the MySpace forums
Apparently this man had shared detailed events and things that were going on in his life, made friends with people and became really close with them.
Then it all came to light that he was an author writing a new book and supposedly he was acting out as one of his characters for the sake of research.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
18 Jan 13
I remember the MySpace forums, but I wasn't that active there, and I haven't met the man that you mentioned. How did people react when they discovered that he had been lying about those things as part of his research for a book?
Your response reminded me about a girl who once did the same thing. She told a story about her mother who had read her diary and asked for advice. Many people tried to help and it seemed like a genuine problem at first, but the girl later revealed that it didn't happen to her, it was simply something that she wanted to use in the story that she was writing...
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
14 Jan 13
I guess I know this person and I also posted a comment on that "cute twin photo".
I also saw the photo (of those twins) on the net and uhmn- now my doubts is cleared. (lols)
Well, that is why I do not trust most people who doesn't use their own profile.
Thu, people can use other people's photo too.
But still posting real photo can tell who is fake and who are real.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
25 Jan 13
It is my impression that quite a lot of people use fake photos on the internet. Some time ago I read an article about some of the romance scammers. They contact someone from a dating site and pretend to be interested in a relationship, but they lie about everything and use fake photos of beautiful because it is simply a scam designed to convince the victims to send them money. Sometimes they steal the pictures from social networking sites and the person who owns the photo doesn't know that the scammers have stolen the photos.
@garson (884)
• United States
18 Feb 13
As I am responding your interesting post, let's first focus on mylot as a social discussion forum. I receive daily digest in my e-mail in box. From each one, I chose one that would appeal to me. Sometimes I chose not to respond to any if I think there is nothing interesting. The discussion that I tend to avoid or not interesting to me is the same old discussion like how do u make money online (never cease to exist and will continue to exist), do you make friends around here, and what kind of music do you listen to.
Other discussions that I tend to avoid is variable posts concerning life issues. I would sometime respond to someone experiencing health issue (I would not somehow think that a post like this as a fake post if it sounds sincere, although I may never know.) or experiencing a crisis situation.
I may not be sensitive to some people's personal issues, but I prefer to look at posts that are though provoking, like significance of bible verses, a medical term, or something scientific. Somehow, it's understandable that many of us don't have scientific mind, adventurous or out of the box thoughts, but the quality of mylot and many social forums suffer to certain degree.
Going back to fake profiles, it's just happen that part of lives are sad. Some people act childishly like they need some attention. Online forum, no matter how supportive people, still do not solve people's problems. Tips, advice, suggestions may have significant contribution. I could be wrong about negative attention seeking or merely attention seeking.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
23 Feb 13
Yes, some of the discussions like the ones about online money making will continue to exist. Sometimes I read some of them, but most of the time I prefer to focus on other topics like travelling or relationships. I like discussions where people share experiences from their own lives. I am not very interested in discussions about material things like the best laptop or cell phone. I prefer to read about people, friendship, love, work etc. Like you I enjoy posts that are thought provoking, but sometimes it is hard to find that kind of discussions.
I think that attention seeking could be the reason behind the fake profiles like the one that I mentioned when I started the discussion. If it had been a discussion site where you got paid for your participation money could have been the motove behind the fake profile, but that was not the case because it was a site where you don't get paid for your activity.
@WildHorses (718)
• United States
16 Jan 13
It does take a lot of time and effort to come up with a life that doesn't exist but when you get people into believing it and becoming long time friends with something that isn't there it sure changes a lot when it gets discovered. The least they could have done was use a picture of other family members lol
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
19 Feb 13
Yes, it takes a lot of time and effort to create that kind of fake life, and that is one of the things that I find it hard to understand. I mean why did she invest so much time and energy in a fake profile? I would feel that I was wasting my time if I did the same thing and I wouldn't have the patience to write about my fake life almost daily I prefer to write about my own life, because that gives me the chance to get comments and advice that I can actually use, I wouldn't get that if I wrote about things that never happened.
@sunshinesophie (794)
• China
14 Jan 13
I have seen this case for many times and I find it really boring.They just want to earn the concerns and the CTR.But honestly,they do the most meaningless things.Can describing a fake story really make them joyful or amused?I don't think so.I just realize that the more a person parades something,the more he/she wants it.Flaunt is just a display which enlarges something boundlessly to gloss over the void in his/her heart.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
18 Jan 13
I don't understand that either and I don't know why they find it so amusing to create a fake story. The woman that I mentioned didn't just create a fake story she kept writing the details from that story for so long People believed the fake story that she had created and gave her advice and developed a friendship with her over time and of course they were disappointed and angry when they discovered that everything had been lie. I think that I would feel that way, too if I had become one of her friends.
@nessabean (11)
• United States
14 Jan 13
I frequent a pregnancy forum where people would start fake posts regarding their pregnancy or baby. Many times it would be a tragic loss and a lot of the women would devote emotions and offer help to the person. On the forum I frequent many people would shut the posts down as fakes almost immediately.
I think some people are disappointed with their lives and decide to make up a new one. They seem to have plenty of time to do such things and probably track all the detail. I'm sure if you went back and read her posts, compare them closely, there would be some differences. She probably put some of her life in it, no one is that good at making everything up and keeping it straight.
I have heard about people posting fake lives and asking for help, people would give them money or items out of the goodness of thir own heart just to find out that they were duped! No wonder our society has become hard and cynical.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
18 Jan 13
I think that you are right about that. Some of the people who create a fake life probably do it because they are disappointed in their own lives and think that their lives aren't interesting. Maybe they describe the lives that they are dreaming about instead of their actual lives.
When people describe something tragic like a loss that they have experienced other people tend to offer help and compassion, but sometimes the person has simply made everything up, and they take advantage of other people's kindness or willingness to help. When people even offer money or items it is even worse. That also happened on one of the discussion forums where I was a member and the person managed to trick other members into keeping them money when they posted their fake story about their terrible financial situation.