I'm Surprised No One Remembered...

Valdosta, Georgia
January 16, 2013 10:19am CST
I am not mad, I am just surprised no one remembered... My daughter's 4th birthday is today and no one in my family remembered. I am just really surprised by this. I always remember my immediate family's birthdays. I understand life gets busy but my daughter doesn't understand that concept. She asked me earlier why no one called her for her birthday yet, when my family calls it is always early that they call. My sister came over earlier and I had to tell her to wish her a happy birthday because she must have forgot! I remember her children's birthdays, just really shocked right now. Oh well we will make her day special today so I guess that is all that matters.
10 people like this
35 responses
@mauie0918 (337)
• Philippines
18 Jan 13
Birthday is really special for children. Even it's not a big party or just lunch or dinner with the family make them very happy! Well as for me, I know the birthdays of my family member by heart. Even I'm busy or out of town then still I give greeting to them. But what matters most is that to wish the celebrant a good health!
2 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
4 Feb 13
Yes especially to kids birthdays are a really big deal. I cannot believe so many people forgot about hers! It made me feel terrible. But she had an awesome day anyway. =)
• United States
18 Jan 13
Like you said life happens. I was pretty good about remembering the kids in our families birthdays. However, when money got tight I hated to call and disappoint the kids that I couldn't send them anything but well wishes over the phone. It's hard to explain to kids that you have your own kids to take care of and they come first over the rest of the family.... or atleast that's the way it is in my world.
• Valdosta, Georgia
19 Jan 13
Yes life happens but at least a few minute phone call would be nice... I always remember the kids birthdays, even if I cannot send anything. The kids in this family appreciate the fact that they were thought about even if they don't get a gift which is nice. It is the way we raised them to be.
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Jan 13
this disappointment is always likely to be there when we tend to remember and others forget ours.Everyone is equally busy and all it takes is a little time and care.Many people do not care as we ourselves do and slowly, she will realise it and know that only parents will remember all this.
2 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Your absolutely right, if I can take the time to care and make effort so should they. That is the way I feel about it. I'm not really mad about it just a little annoyed I guess... It only takes a few minutes to call and say Happy Birthday!
• United States
16 Jan 13
Well, please tell your little princess Happy Birthday! from one of mommy's friends on myLot. I know she won't really understand that, but it's the thought that counts. I hope that your family is going to call her tonight, or surprise her this weekend with a family get together.
2 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Thank you scorpio, I will definitely tell her! It is the thought that counts. I hope they do something to let her know she is loved and cared about on her special day. It's not like she is older and understands that people get busy, she doesn't and its not like she doesn't care about the day-for little ones a birthday is a big deal!
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (166911)
• Boise, Idaho
17 Jan 13
That is weird. If I were her I would be upset. People sure can be uncaring and unfamily oriented at times. I guess unless you have a big family get together no one remembers anything.
@AmbiePam (92711)
• United States
18 Jan 13
For some reason I'm fanatical about birthdays. I even remind my dad about the birthdays of HIS friends.
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (166911)
• Boise, Idaho
17 Jan 13
@AmbiePam-Yes, my grandmother was 89 when she passed. She was always remembering. Their generation I guess. @LovingMyBabies-- Poor little gal!
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
17 Jan 13
Yeah she was very upset and I cannot blame her. She is a smart little girl and realized that her family did not remember. That is so sweet that your grandmother did that!
2 people like this
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
18 Jan 13
At four years old, I have to say that I'm shocked that your family has all forgotten your daughter's birthday. I mean I will admit that there are times that I will forget my sister-in-law's birthday and my brother-in-laws' birthdays, but when it comes to the kids, I will never forget any of their birthdays. I mean I not only remember my children and my niece's birthdays, I also remember the birthdays of my best friend's three children. With my other really close friend, I not only remember the birthdays of his three children that I have been lucky enough to meet, I also remember when his two deceased children (that I never had the opportunity to meet) were born.
2 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
19 Jan 13
Yeah I know me too. Then on top of that my mother had the nerve to ask why I am having her party at my house, as its too small for everyone to be here! Not happy with my family right now at all... I don't forget the kids birthdays either, that is a big deal to them!
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160663)
• United States
16 Jan 13
I have had some that did remember birthdays, others that did not in the family. My brother and his wife are great about birthdays, but they pastor a church. Busiest people I know. My sister, on the other hand, does not remember birthdays and she does nothing but sit in front of the TV. I used to remember all of the kids when they were little. Now I am to the point of having grandkids to remember. Yes, you make your daughter's day special, cause she is special.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
See to me just like your saying here being busy is not really a good excuse. Its about what's important to the person. I just feel bad for my little one because she just feels left out... How unfair for her to have to feel bad...
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160663)
• United States
17 Jan 13
I am sure that it does not really mean anything to her that a bunch of us strangers want her to have a special day. My middle grand child will be four on May 17. Her big deal is asking which things are really hers. She has a big sister and gets lots of hand me downs. I send stuff and sometimes it is for the family and sometimes for the individual. Since I cannot be there often I try to send them special things a lot. Not expensive things, often they are thrift shop things, but they know I think of them all the time.
1 person likes this
@BarBaraPrz (47308)
• St. Catharines, Ontario
16 Jan 13
I've never thought of my birthday as being a big deal. Maybe because mine came two days before my father's, so we always just had one cake on the Sunday nearest to one of the days. (My father wasn't big on sweets.) Anyway, I'm sure everyone here will wish your daughter a happy today.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Yeah but to most children their birthdays are a big deal. That is the one day that is special to them. That is how they are being raised also, birthdays are a big deal. Everyone has the right to feel special one day of the year! =)
• United States
16 Jan 13
If I don't write birthdays down, I generally don't remember them. I remember my late dogs' birthdays, my boyfriend's birthday (and only after we'd been together for two years) and my own. That's it. I know the birth months for my mother and my two closest friends, but the actual dates never stick in my mind. We aren't all good with dates, and being busy makes it easy to forget such things.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Yeah some people are bad with dates but for a kids sake, I think people should be a little more careful to remember...Kids birthdays are a big deal to them.
• Philippines
16 Jan 13
Happy Birthday to your daughter!!! :D This happened to me last year too though my family didn't forget my birthday, my friends did. I mean my closest friends. I was kind of hurt but the feeling didn't last. Maybe they were just too busy to remember my birthday. Hahaha! My closest friends normally do not forget each others birthday. We always make sure that we don't let the day pass without making it special for the birthday celebrant. Last year, I thought it was going to be the same but I was wrong. My officemates and new friends didn't forget. I ended up celebrating my birthday with them and my family. None of my closest friends even texted just to greet me a happy birthday. Oh well, I'm over and done with that part already. I'm not angry with my friends. I was able to tell them last time we went out and they all just laughed at me and said they were sorry for forgetting my day. :)
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Thank you! Yeah I think its more important for family to remember their birthday. Friends, from my experience are not very good with these type of things. But family should rememeber their family's birthday. Like I said I'm not mad, just a little hurt for her.
• Philippines
16 Jan 13
I think if it was my family who forgot about my birthday it would hurt more. I understand how you felt. Anyway, just have fun and enjoy your daughter's birthday! :)
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
22 Jan 13
I remember only half of the birthdays of my nieces and nephews; one is easy because it's the same as mine. With the other half I know the month, but not the date. It gets tough keeping track of all of that information after a while with everything there is to keep track of and all of life's distractions and preoccupations. Some people have good memories and some don't. I'm surprised that you had't been talking about it leading up to her birthday. how often do you talk to your family members? Maybe if you made more of a big deal about celebrating her birthday ahead of time it would help them remember.
1 person likes this
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
7 Feb 13
I have an excellent idea of what I am talking about, which is why I asked questions. Not everyone has the same priorities, it's unfortunate that sometimes children get hurt feelings as a result. I find it hard to believe that with all of those reminders everyone simply forgot. It seems like there is more going on. Suggesting that someone should be slapped for forgetting your child's birthday is ridiculous and sets a terrible example as a parent. If I were your relative and that was your attitude toward me, I wouldn't have attended either.
• Valdosta, Georgia
4 Feb 13
I reminded everyone constantly that her birthday was coming up since we were having a party for her too! I even reminded my entire family 2 days before her party so you have no idea what your talking about here... They were apparently too worried about themselves to think about my daughter! Sad but true... That is why they make calendars to mark things down on and to help us remember. No one should ever forget a childs birthday, it is their special day. And if someone does forget they should be slapped because that is just awful!!
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
16 Jan 13
It matters as a child...I remember that used to be the day I had to join the school, and it used to be so sad because dad used to leave me at the hostel right on my birthday, and dressing well and having all those gifts ..ah well..as kids we want it all...nice pink dress, and a nice cake...and to look the best in the room, and plenty of gifts. It matters. Years later..at 53...I have asked my relatives ...you all expect something from you, where were you all when I had no mom, and I was at the hostel, not a letter, not a birthday greeting, not even a new year greeting ...from 6 to 18. So..yes..it matters, it shows who cares and who doesnt. By the way, there was a nice neighbor, she used to pack some nice things as surprise for me. Nice dress usually, and some sweets. One neighbor celebrated my birthday exactly one month before..:) So good people are there..:)
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
16 Jan 13
And wish the kiddo many Happy Returns of the Day on our behalf...
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Yes as a child it is a very important day. Most people when they were kids wanted to be remembered on their special day. It's the only day that is really special to kids! I just think it's terrible that her own aunts and uncles don't remember her birthday but I remember all of their kids days! It doesn't seem right to me... Thank you I will!
1 person likes this
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
16 Jan 13
Happy birthday to your daughter! Not that this will make you feel better, but sometimes family just forgets like even immediate family. My husband just asked me what my birthday, my son's birthday and our son's birthday was this morning. Maybe you can get her to play with something and call up family members secretly to remind them or ask them to call right back. The only one that really remembers my kid's birthdays is my dad. I just try to keep their mind off of it and buy them a cake and a new toy that keeps them busy or dance around to kid tunes with them.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
Thank you Aida. I know family forgets and I guess it wouldn't bother me so much if I ever forgot any of their children's birthdays but I haven't. I know to a child that is a very special day for them! Adults understand and its not such a big deal to them, but a kid?!? I would just never forget their birthdays. We are taking her to the McDonalds with the playplace in it today, just to do something special with her that doesn't cost us a ton of money. Lol. It makes her very happy to go there!
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
17 Jan 13
Mcdonalds works well! We eat before we go and then they play their hearts out. Tonight we got them an ice cream there because it was her birthday so it cost us $4 for hours of fun! Definitely worth it. They had a blast and it was nice. Your welcome for the idea, most kids love it there!
1 person likes this
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
16 Jan 13
There is nothing wrong with McDonald's. I made a pizza last year and we danced around singing Dora songs. I was so tired afterwards. Maybe I will take them to McDonald's this year. I can rest a bit while they play since I can just sit in there and watch them. Yes, that sounds like a wonderful plan. Thank you so much for the plan. XD At least she is very happy to go there. :) Four is a fun birthday. My kids are turning 5 and 6 this year. But I am serious, I am going take those little energizer bunnies to McDonald's. Keeping up with them is hard even if I am not that old. lol.
1 person likes this
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
16 Jan 13
Is the day over yet there? maybe they will still. Funny family usually forgets adults birthdays... not kids. Sorry for that.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
16 Jan 13
No its not over yet but if they were going to call they would have done it already. My family is the type to call people when they get up, which was hours ago... Yeah forgetting a child's birthday is much worse to me because to a child their birthday is a big deal!
1 person likes this
• Mexico
16 Jan 13
sure is.. very sad. Sorry for that. Try and make it a special birthday any ways..
• Canada
26 Jan 13
That is absolutely nuts! I'm going to be 31 in five days, and I'm getting all kinds of birthday cards from my family. It totally amazes me how some people can be so completely scatter-brained.
• Valdosta, Georgia
4 Feb 13
I completely agree with you! I think it is terrible especially to forget a child's birthday. Too them it is a big deal and their special day!
@sylvia13 (1850)
• Nelson Bay, Australia
17 Jan 13
I have two children and many nephews and I know what birthdays mean to them! Please wish your daughter a belated Happy Birthday and tell her Sylvia sent her those wishes from Australia!
• Valdosta, Georgia
18 Jan 13
Yes they are so important to little ones! Every parent knows that. I will thank you.
• United States
3 Feb 13
Since they can't remember your child's birthday, then it is time to forget their children's birthdays! I hope Princess had a good day anyway.
• United States
4 Feb 13
It is the adults I Want to hurt. Let them see how it feels. As for the kids, I would get them a little something but not on their birthdays.
• Valdosta, Georgia
4 Feb 13
If that would only hurt the adults I would do it but I don't want the kids to be hurt either, I love them to pieces! But she did have a great birthday. She went to McDonald's playplace and we got her an ice cream, she had a blast! =)
1 person likes this
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
18 Jan 13
Birthdays are especially important to children at that age. I commend you for remembering the birthdays of your nieces and nephews.
• Valdosta, Georgia
18 Jan 13
Yes I know how important birthdays are to kids, that's why I make sure to remember them all.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
17 Jan 13
I'd feel upset myself if it happened to any of my kid on his birthday. But, what can we do about it? We can't just call everyone and remind them, right? Instead, as a parent, we would make everything possible to make their day a very special one.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
17 Jan 13
That's all that matters. I am sure your little angel had a blast. She would be probably throwing tantrums if mommy was the one who forgot her birthday.
• Valdosta, Georgia
17 Jan 13
Yeah I was upset but I know theres nothing I can do about it. We did make her day very special. She had a blast!
@911Ricki (13588)
• Canada
16 Jan 13
That is just sad, just plain saad. My 82 year old grandmother who seems to forget everything remembers our birthdays. You are never too busy, I have woke up and then a few hours later look at the daate, then called the person. I feel so bad for your daughter, because she will remember this.
• Valdosta, Georgia
17 Jan 13
Yeah it is sad... Especially when it comes to a kids birthday! Adults understand more but kids don't. Yeah but we made it a very special day for her.
@911Ricki (13588)
• Canada
26 Jan 13
Good, so she caan forget about those who forgot about her. Especially her own family, and grandparents ridiculous.