Not having a choice to determine who can read what I write! Isn't it odd???
By Gautam1002
@Gautam1002 (730)
India
February 5, 2013 6:12am CST
Hello fellow users, my recent discussion gave birth to something I am now really wanting to bring into your notice. I had a query over if I can decide who can read a discussion started by me. I could not find much regarding this here so I posted it as a discussion. What it came out with a result was that we are not privileged with any such feature here on mylot. Now I want to question this.
Mylot is a wonderful site to spend time on but how far are you satisfied with mylot not having this required facility?
Do you want such a feature? Come up with reasons to support your responses.
3 people like this
7 responses
@allknowing (137823)
• India
5 Feb 13
If you feel you have something to share with specific users then you can add them as friends and send them individual messages.
2 people like this
@hereandthere (45645)
• Philippines
6 Feb 13
yeah, similar to yahoogroups is what came to my mind, with a cc and bcc feature.
i know of one family that has such a group, set to private, yet some stuff still leaked out to the worldwide web.
@Nursefrai06 (2498)
• Penrith, Australia
6 Feb 13
It sounds unfair for the person who wouldn't see your discussion, it would feel as if you were talking about them at their backs. If i were that person, i wouldn't feel very nice knowing that i cannot see all the discussions. The essence of an open forum diminishes if not everyone sees it in the open. Perhaps if you want to ask questions, maybe you can do it privately via private message, i think you can do that.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Feb 13
hi I agree as this sou nds really g rim as if only the elite can reply to so,me people I do not think my lot needs that at all.
@Nursefrai06 (2498)
• Penrith, Australia
6 Feb 13
Also, if there were this feature, not everyone will be treated equally as the earning possibilities are diminished if were not able to see all the discussions. Equality is a good feature in mylot where in everyone has the opportunity to maximize their earnings depending on how much time they are willing to spend on here.
@KrauseHome (36447)
• United States
5 Feb 13
Personally if there are things here you want to post that you do not want others to read, then why are you posting it? If you want to post things like this, there is Facebook. But personally, I could never imagine wanting to hide things from people that are members here. We are allowed to come in here and share and talk about anything we want, so if you don't feel comfortable, don't post it.
1 person likes this
@jonastabuena (2307)
• Philippines
6 Feb 13
I understand your point, i guess for now that the mylot don't have yet that kind of feature, why not try to use the message option, and send your message or post to your friends only. Can i ask why you want this kind of feature? kindly elaborate.
Anyway if you ask me, i'm so much satisfied that mylot users can see my posted discussion, because i need their opinion whether it is bad or good.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Feb 13
yu are missing the above's point private messages means no other mylotter bgut you and the person heer y o contact can see your writing. You sound a bit paranoid to me. but whatever you are hiding from this him you cannot do it here so you need a place like facebgook with all it's many options. there no more contact with
you ever.
@Gautam1002 (730)
• India
6 Feb 13
I agree with you that if I need to post a matter that I want to share with some, I can message them directly. But what if I want to escape from some people seeing what I write or letting them know what views I have on some topic. With what I am telling you still will have option of letting others respond to your discussion or read it, it still will be your choice to allow or not to allow them. But you will have a choice which you do not have now.
1 person likes this
@thinkingoutloud (6127)
• Canada
5 Feb 13
No, it's not odd... and no, I don't want such a feature. Why would I, of my own freedom and choice, come to an open discussion forum... a forum that welcomes members from all over the world... whose thoughts, opinions, knowledge and insights may be enjoyable and enlightening... and then seek to limit with whom I discuss? That can be done elsewhere. Such a feature makes no sense on a website of this type -- where discussions live in perpetuity and members may comment on anything at any time... even years later, if we so choose and have something of interest or value to contribute.
Also, keep in mind that myLot is a website where we can earn by our contributions - again differing from other general forums. If it were possible to decide who could read and participate in a discussion, that would inherently limit the ability to earn to only those "select" people. Entirely unacceptable. We are all equal here and it would be wrong for some to be "more equal" than others.
@Gautam1002 (730)
• India
5 Feb 13
Now I didn't want to take this talk to a racial level where someone wouldn't just allow to see his discussion because he is from some other country or some other religion or whatever. I would question you, haven't you faced a situation in life time when you felt awkward talking about something in front of someone? Did it happen because he was of different country or different race. Even if it happens, do you think this is the only reason for which one would hesitate to talk about something in front of someone. NO. There may be plenty of reasons. And one more thing. why do not you want such a feature? It will not take anything away from you. You are allowed to post your content in whichever manner you want to. And if it does not allow a particular discussion to get seen by you, it is only because that user does not want you to see it. If that feature is not there, you will see that discussion but the mentality of that user will remain same. He didn't want you to see his post earlier, he doesn't want you to see it even now. Having or not having a feature will not bring a change in his attitude. And it is not that you always will remain on the receiving end. This feature gives freedom to you as well.
1 person likes this
@thinkingoutloud (6127)
• Canada
5 Feb 13
I never brought up anything racial in my response to you and I certainly wasn't intending it to be taken to "a racial level." I said that myLot welcomes people from all over the world and that is the truth. Discussions can become much more interesting, informed and enlightened when impacted by open conversation across varying cultures, beliefs, customs, etc. In reply to your question, if I hesitate to discuss something for ANY reason, I don't post. It's really that simple.
What you didn't address is my point that myLot is NOT just "any other website." There must be equality in people's access and ability to participate here because we can earn for what we type. So, when you ask me "why do not you want such a feature? It will not take anything away from you.", I am telling you that yes it WOULD take something away from me... it would take away my access to earn which is accorded to everyone here equally. myLot does not give us the right to any activities or actions that may impact others potential to earn -- i.e., we cannot delete posted content, we cannot edit posted content, etc. -- because all of these things would give us an aspect of control over the earnings of others and we are not entitled to that.
@Gautam1002 (730)
• India
6 Feb 13
I am not making a point of not letting any random person read my post. I just want not to let some, yes some known people, who definitely are not my enemies, and are certainly not "blocked by me, as you all are terming it, forever. It is only for a particular topic that I feel a bit hesitant in bringing up in front of them. There may be several reasons for the same and it does not mean that this will hurt them every time. If I want to discuss something which, say my friend does not want me to discuss about and for my betterment(keep a note of that! for my betterment!), what should I do? How will I bring up in front of you people and seek your views on that? Am I wrong in wanting to post it? Are we being guesses as enemies for this action? He is doing it for my betterment, and my attempt of hiding is just not to let him know that I am discussing a particular topic with others. It does not takes any one's freedom.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
5 Feb 13
gautam why would you want to block your discussion:?
you want to diss us users here like the last person who got banned for that? WE do not need a block as this is not face book and it is an open forum and also this is not the place to air your grievances with fellow mylotters.for one thing openly attacking anyone here is called flaming and it is not allowed. This will get your discussion banned. do read the guidelines and the frequently asked questions as it helps to understand why mylot does as it does. I woul hate blocking feature as it would led to just that hate discussions and flaming wars.I am very satisfied with mylot as it is regarding this idea . I dislike that very much. What have you to hide? If you do not want family or friends to read your discussions leave any upsetting stuff out of the discussion. also mylot farms out a lot of our discussions so any thing you say will be out on the net so take care.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Feb 13
I have read and reread your posts here. my problem is that this is a friendly c ommunity and nobody is wanting to stop anyonne from reading our posts here.we do not want nor need your blocking option. for one thing our earnings would dimmish a lot if all but a few people decide not to block out half of the population here because of any number of reasons. maybe you dislike Indians or Negroes or something else so you block all who appear to be in those categories.
sorry I just do not agree with you and I think that if you really must have that option you need to go to a different type of site.I am responding since you responded but from now on you are not on my friends list nor dolI w ant you there so goodbye adios adieu.
@Gautam1002 (730)
• India
5 Feb 13
Why is my advice compared to "block" on facebook? I hope you are reading all my above posts. My point only emphasizes the uncomfortability of the user. If he is not wanting some people on this globe to read what his views are on a certain topic, will you directly claim him his enemy? NO. Its may be just a result of his hesitation. It may be a result of his fear. Or could be anything for that matter. According to responses on this discussion, he is advised bot to write such a thing on myLot. Now is he not denied his freedom? Also his content, by default, is taken to be abusive as he only wishes his content not to get disclosed in front of some people. Now if he doesn't want his content to be displayed that way, certainly, from any sense of imagination , turns abusive. There may be several thousand reasons for the same.
Also one more thing I would like to know form you, what is the issue, what is the problem if something like that is introduced?
1 person likes this
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
8 Feb 13
I have to say that an idea like this is not something that is at all appealing to me. Yes, I do realize that there are times that we write something that we do not want the whole world to read but we really want to get it out in the open. I really do not feel like mylot is the right way to deal with these kinds of things. Instead I feel like if there are things that you want to write but you do not want it to be available for the entire world to read, then the thing that you should do is to start a private blog where your readers are by invitation only.
In posting some pretty private stuff here on mylot, I have found rhat I have been able to get some great advice from complete strangers.