My country your solution
By vanny
@vandana7 (100240)
India
February 18, 2013 11:12am CST
So...there can be issues in India...and
somebody from our arch rival Pakistan offers a solution...
Should I accept it or not?
Lets change the nations...North Korea and South Korea...would either of them accept the solution offered by the other..
Or if it were Japan and China
or if it were the US and Iran?
I would be open to suchggestions from outsiders...
Since quite often when we are too close to the picture ...we cant actually see its overall effect...that outsider's perspective is offered by people from other country.
At times it may not be country specific either...yet...it is a solution to the problem in the country.
I just received a best response from a Pakistani, and that prompted me to start this discussion.
So...my question is are you also accepting suggestions based on logics or are you letting national pride intervene...in the progressive path for humanity as a whole.
3 people like this
9 responses
@DoctorDidi (7018)
• India
18 Feb 13
India and Pakistan may be at daggers drawn to each other. But people of both the two neighbouring countries are peace-loving, they do not want any war between the two countries.But it is the political leaders who are responsible for this bitter relation between the two countries and they do so to axe their own grind. So if anybody from Pakistan offers a solution for any problem I encounter in life, I would analyze it by logic and if I find it justified, I will take it without any hesitation; in no case I will reject it on the wrong ground that it has been advised by somebody from our arch rival Pakistan.
2 people like this
@mani118 (146)
• Pakistan
19 Feb 13
I really like your opinion.I am a pakistani i never thought negative thing about India.It's our leader's who encouge us against eachother for thier own benefit. They used illegal money from outsources to engourge us. I think we people loves eachother a lot.
@stringer321 (5644)
• Kiryat Ata, Israel
19 Feb 13
The logic solution has to offer the best solution for both sides.
If they have to sacrifice something to get to the solution, they may reject the offer
or maybe accept the offer.
Israel (my country) and some other countries around are not good friends and still no solution is found yet. When one side is not going to compromise for the other, only time will tell what was the best solution. The conflict stays the same, some times people riot here and there, some go to prison, some give up...
Maybe some sacrifice cannot be afforded since it may open an situation that is cannot be reversed.
And, what is the best thing to do if both sides suspect and don't trust each other ?
Each side is afraid the other will take advantage of the offer and use it.
@DoctorDidi (7018)
• India
19 Feb 13
I think and firmly believe that India and Pakistan may be enemies but Indians and Pakistanis are respectful to one another and have feelings for one another; they are friends and never enemies but the political leaders try their utmost to make them enemies to one another in order to achieve their own political gains.
@jeanneyvonne (5501)
• Philippines
19 Feb 13
true, and sense depends on who you ask.
2 people like this
@pergammano (7682)
• Canada
19 Feb 13
I guess, dear VAndy, my first question would be are they offering a viable solution...or are they "flexing" their muscles? And what is the basis of "their good solution?" and the long-term results! The mighty powerful U.S., is just across the border, and we are treated like errant little children by Big Brother!
I am fiercely Canadian, and wonder where Big Brother will lead us, especially when involved in another war, in the EAst!
@pergammano (7682)
• Canada
30 May 13
Whomever this [person "khizargujjer" IS....if I were on the old "myLot" I would have NO problems reporting you...as you seem to take pride in breaking every rule!
@topffer (42156)
• France
18 Feb 13
India and Pakistan are not in war ? Then there is nothing forbidding to their citizen, even if they are fiercely patriotic, to be more reasonable and wise than their politicians by giving a BR to the member deserving it, whatever the country. Congratulations.
1 person likes this
@jeanneyvonne (5501)
• Philippines
19 Feb 13
It depends on how much each party will gain. Of course, any party or people would wish to have the advantage over the other in any situation. The technique is to make everybody happy (or as many as happy) over the solution. In an ideal view, I guess it worth considering the proposal of your ‘enemy’ since it will somehow affect you too whether you like or not. The question is whether you can influence it to make it also advantageous to you. The problem is the politics in the process and whether if the people negotiating is really looking out for most of the people and not for themselves.
In addition, the tow parties concerned should also welcome third party advice with constraint. Only the two parties know the details (they are the ones who shared history, blood and people over this) and they are the only ones who should benefiting form this proposal.
As person, logic is the bets solution for any conflict. Pride and other strong feelings can help propel a cause but when it comes to relations with others, it might just not work. It divides rather than combine good things that can be possible.
@extremefun4fun (2908)
• India
19 Feb 13
as I know people of india and their nature, I really would like to say I do not know when the matter of pakitan and india want to finish. I have seen many Indians to make diffrence to people of another national and used to call themsleves as the best. Anyway I wish that knowlege and humanity grow in each part of our life and people understand that we are all Adam's children and permitted to live on the earth for somewhile and this earth is not belong to anybody so I wish to the world to understand having a border can not make you diffrent from another one, this is land of God for all of us so wish ignorance will disappear from our world then I do not think we should have any reason to fight or discuss.
@Archie0 (5652)
•
19 Feb 13
Well i think i would take suggestions, i will be open to all. But decisions will be mine. Also it is important who you hear to. I would not entertain suggestions from my rival. No one would think of getting a suggestion from their enemies. Doesn't matter how good we are we cannot expect the same goodness from our enemies. They are enemies after all. Suggestions and advice's are better listened to but are not always something where we can abide to.
@else22 (4317)
• India
19 Feb 13
If a Pakistani or a Chinese provides a practical and logical solution to my problems,I would love to accept it although not at the cost of my national pride.I would love to help them if they are in distress in my country.Recently I had come across the findings of a survey conducted in China.It was found that only 25% of Chinese like India.I don't know whether any such survey has ever been conducted in Pakistan.So don't know what Pakistanis think about us.
@anubrataroy (444)
• India
21 Feb 13
If I was in a position where I had authorities to accept or reject a suggestion from Pakistan. I would have thought ten times before accepting it. Citizens of both countries may be friendly. But the politicians back there don't have a good intention. Many fact in the recent past had made this point very clear.