Would you support having meditation and yoga taught in schools?
By Pose123
@Pose123 (21635)
Canada
March 1, 2013 7:20am CST
Some have suggested that having meditation and yoga taught in schools, starting in preschool, who help end both obesity among children and bring an end to bullying. Children would be taught to meditate on such things as compassion, love, respect for others etc. The earlier we start the better it would be for the child. This would have nothing to do with religion but with the development of the whole person.
5 people like this
15 responses
@averygirl72 (37845)
• Philippines
1 Mar 13
I've heard a lot about yoga and meditation but is it safe? Are we not inviting bad spirits because they say it can be pagan practice? I heard yoga uses poses and slow movements. What if we just invent our own yoga exercises?
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
5 Mar 13
Hi averygirl, Thank you for responding and I can assure you that nothing is more safe than meditation and yoga. Many Christians practice meditation and yoga is simply exercises. If people wanted to call it by another name, that would be fine too. There is absolutely no chance of inviting bad spirits. This could only do good. Blessings.
@Kashmeresmycat (6369)
• United States
1 Mar 13
I think that's an excellent suggestion and would do good for all children. Just the thought of having even a minority of children learn to control anger issues, health issues, and bring on some inner peace and calm would be worth it to me.
If my kids were little I would for sure let them do this. I wish they had it years ago.
1 person likes this
@Kashmeresmycat (6369)
• United States
6 Mar 13
Aw, Thank you Pose for BR! I had no idea you did this as I did not receive any notification. Thanks again and I do think this is an excellent idea and I hope the schools will incorporate it into their agenda.
@wolfie34 (26771)
• United Kingdom
1 Mar 13
Personally, looking back on my school days I would have welcomed meditation and yoga classes, although I guess they weren't so 'open' to those type of classes back in the late 70s/early 80s. As an adult I tried meditation and wasn't able to get on with it, I guess it takes a lot of practice, trouble is would children be able to sit for any length of time and meditate without getting fidgety, be disruptive, it only takes one child to upset the 'mood' and the 'meditation' class. Basically I don't think they'd be disciplined enough.
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
5 Mar 13
Hi wolfie, Thank you for your response. The thing would be getting good teachers and starting at a very young age. I am certain that it could be done and would work wonders for the next generation. I suspect that it will eventually happen no matter how much resistance there is at first. It may be our only hope. Blessings.
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
1 Mar 13
Yes, of course! But its," Pie in the Sky!"
The problem here is religion! Religion is desperately scared of anything that could be deemed 'spiritual,'which is why Yoga is misrepresented by the church. The Yoga Group that I manage at Alamo Palms has as many as 40 members at peak season, and it's not unusual for would-be members to tell me that advise from their priest is, "Stay away from Yoga, because it can play games with your head."
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
5 Mar 13
Hi barehugs, Thank you for responding and of course you and I know that both meditation and yoga are very helpful and this would indeed be best for children and adults as well. I think that things are changing, as I told another here I know of at least one Catholic priest who teaches his congregation to meditate, and there is such a thing as Christian meditation. I don't think that it need have anything at all to do with any religion. Don't you agree? People today are becoming better informed. Blessings.
@veganbliss (3895)
• Adelaide, Australia
1 Mar 13
A conditional "yes". It would need to be voluntary - for both the students & parents consent. It would also need to be managed by a competent instructor who also does not charge any fees to anyone whatsoever. The benefits to students & families would be so much more than what you have briefly listed, but they will depend upon both the competence of the instructor & the dedication & sincerity of the students. Should either one, or both be lacking, others will see it as a complete waste of time. Yoga could also be incorporated into a child's daily fitness program.
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
5 Mar 13
Hi veganbliss, Thank you for responding and I agree. It could be voluntary because once people saw the advantages, very few would object. Old wives tales usually accompany anything new, but that too would soon disappear. Of course competent instructors would be a must but I think such instructors could also teach other subjects just as any other teacher. There would have to be a lot of planning and time put into this and I'm not suggesting that it could start right away but I think the advantages are tremendous.Blessings.
@echoforever (5180)
• United States
19 Mar 13
I honestly can think of no reason "why not" and since that is the case, yes I would support this. I have recently been trying out meditation for myself and it has helped me feel pretty good. I think this would be a great thing for children in schools. Its hard to be around a lot of children all of a sudden and the case of bullying, something needs to be done. This would be something consistent and I think it would help.
1 person likes this
@KrauseHome (36448)
• United States
5 Mar 13
Some interesting thoughts here, and it might actually help in some ways. Give kids something else to want to do and concentrate on. Personally I feel a lot of times some of the bullying happens when kids are always trying to compare themselves with one another. Then they tend to think because they are better dressed, get better grades, are sports jocks, etc. they are better than you.
Personally the issue is the way you are raised. Too many times if they parents are always thinking they are better than some others, their kids will too and it will make it hard for them to ever really be able to get along and succeed in today's society.
@echoforever (5180)
• United States
19 Mar 13
Pose just out of curiousity what makes you th ink it will be happening?
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
3 Mar 13
Hello Pose. There are too many kids that are failing in reading and writing. I have two granddaughters inn high school that can't spell let alone read at grade level. Kid are not being taught the basics as they should be. They can be taught about bulling love through reading and improve reading at the same time. California is taking algebra out of the schools. There is also talk about taking civics and American government out of the schools. I have nothing against meditation or yoga but the schools need to use their time with the students better. There is not enough expectation of our kids as it is now.
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
5 Mar 13
Hi deebomb, Thank you for your response but I think teaching meditation and yoga would help children with all other subjects as well. It would work wonders with obesity and greatly reduce bullying. This may be the answer to a lot of our problems but I know it would take planning and could not be introduced right away. Blessings.
@jambi462 (4576)
• United States
1 Mar 13
I think that it would be an incredible thing to teach meditation and yoga in schools. I think it would be faced with a lot of opposition from different religions, especially Catholics and Christians, that claim that it isn't fair for meditation and yoga to be taught in schools and not have the bible be taught in school as well.
Yoga would be great for students because it would help relieve hypertension. A lot of our sores and aches of daily life are from not strectching and not working all of the different tendons and parts of our body. Meditation would help as well because it would help children to find their true identity. Overall I don't see how teaching this wouldn't be a positive thing for school systems.
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
4 Mar 13
Hi jambi462, Thank you for responding but remember even Christians meditate, in fact I have a book on Christian Meditation. I also know of one Catholic priest who teaches meditation to members of his church. In any case meditation and yoga need have nothing to do with any religion and is very helpful. I just wish I had been taught it when I was a child. No doubt there are some Christians who would associate it with other religions but it doesn't need to have any connection with any religion. Even the Bible says "be still and know that I am God". People should put what's best for their children first. Blessings.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
16 Mar 13
If I had seen this question some years ago I would have said that it was nonsense and wouldn't make any kind of difference at all. However when I was in college I had the opportunity to take a personality class where our teacher did several activities to help us get in touch with our whole selves and yoga was one of those activities. I think that this would be something that would be very beneficial in the classroom because it would help to release stress while the students also had the opportunity to tune into their body in ways that they'd never before done.
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
16 Mar 13
Hi dorannmwin, Thank you for your comment. I too would not have considered it just a few years ago, but today I think it is the answer for many things that is wrong in our society. Like everything it would take planning, the right teachers etc. but I think it would all be worth it. Blessings
@starsailover (7829)
• Mexico
19 Mar 13
Hi Pose: I used to practice yoga myself and I think this ancien practice can give people peace in their minds which is necessary. It's healthy, it's good because they make people active and can help with the student's attention and can be an strategy against bullying. So if it's present in a non religious context it could be taught in schools.
ALVARO
@echoforever (5180)
• United States
19 Mar 13
I have just tried meditation for myself a little bit recently. My mind seems calmer afterward, that's for sure.
1 person likes this
@prashu228 (37524)
• India
1 Mar 13
Hi friend
yes now a days meditation and yoga has become the necessity because of all the junk foods we eat especially children are facing this problem at a very young age which is really bad.
1 person likes this
@Hopefull90 (921)
• United States
1 Mar 13
I got through school without that. All the things you mentioned can be taught without meditation. I always had to much to teach to include yoga. I don't even do those things but still have compassion, love, and respect for others even when they don't show me those attributes.