I think catholic priests should be allowed to marry
@allknowing (137771)
India
March 3, 2013 9:50pm CST
Looking at what is going on in the world today with so many priests accused of not keeping to their vows of chastity and celibacy, I feel all this will not be there if they are allowed to marry. Unlike in the good old days when this was made a rule today's priests are exposed to a lot of temptations what with the Internet, and having free access to women, et al. Your views please.
4 people like this
11 responses
@ARIES1973 (11426)
• Legaspi, Philippines
4 Mar 13
Hi allknowing! I am a Roman Catholic and here is my opinion.
They should not be allowed to get married in a sense that we cannot serve two masters. In the first place, why do they have to enter into that profession if they want to get married?
As the technology improves, temptations also become stronger, that is why they should strengthen their faith in order to maintain their vows of chastity and celibacy.
Have a great day!
2 people like this
@Angelpink (4034)
• Philippines
4 Mar 13
Aries i agree with you ! They should not be allowed , before they get into priesthood , they were taught and conditioned that they can't marry for life and that was taught to them the very first day of their schooling in priesthood and because they are just like us human being have passion also then they can still be allowed to marry provided they will get out from the vocation. They can served best if no responsibility of their own.
2 people like this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
If the unmarried status lets them perform their duties in the manner they should all is well. But sadly that is not the case. So many priests are undergoing psychiatric treatment. And so many are breaking the rule of celibacy. I think most break the rule of celibacy but not all are exposed. Priests with a clean conscience could perform far better then those who are guilty.
@Angelpink (4034)
• Philippines
4 Mar 13
Yes true many priest are breaking because just like us they are into so much pressure , vocations demands a lot ! Just like us sometimes we break down because can no longer bear life's demand how much more to priest ,where in many are dependent on him spiritually ,emotionally , financially . ..the game is like 1 versus all!
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
4 Mar 13
The reason for this, I think that the priests were not allowed to marry in the Catholic religion is that, they should be able to focus on serving God. It is their duty to be serving one person alone, which is God himself / or the church.
If he has a family, then they would probably have divided attention, or that they would have been the same issues as before when the cardinals and pop rose to power controlling the church funds to "feed" their family members like a typical political dynasty set up. (this was part of the Borgias series, if you want more of how corrupted the catholic church was, then and that they had families before).
The vow of celibacy, I agree is not anymore followed by many priests (perhaps, they are really unable to due to many factors, and their environment included too) We see that a lot of these priests ways were corrupted nowadays and they are involved in a lot of controversies that we know has basis. Some priests were even accused of rape, of impregnating a woman in their town, and so on.
2 people like this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
4 Mar 13
I agree with what you say.In our MUTTS also the head of the ashram is allowed to marry and after a considerable time lapse, he renounces the family and becomes the head of the ashram.This has been the practice for years together.
They go through their young age and taste the pleasures of the flesh before they take up this state of renunciation.
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
4 Mar 13
In the one which I was talking about the heads are particularly old.On the other hand there are some where we have young people also and there I think they are not allowed to get married at all.Kanchi kamakodi etc..,This is a good ashram ; of course we hear of so many scandals associated with the flybynight operator sannyasis.They are , a big scam.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
I think even those in charge of the ashram should continue to remain married as we hear of so many scandals among them too.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
That is why it is time religion takes a look at what is and what is not.
@offlimits (596)
• Philippines
4 Mar 13
I think I'd have to agree with you. Aside from what was said here that they are only human beings like us, it would be helpful for them to have an option if they're going to marry and at the same time serve as priests. Even though they'll have their own family to attend to, they could also be a good example to the clergy as married men who are faithful to their wives and are loving fathers to their own children. It would be wonderful to see priests not as someone who are hypocritical to what they preach but as humans who can empower people through the word of God.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
When this rule was made, I wonder what was it that they felt that only unmarried men can serve mankind better. As you have pointed out a man with a family can set a good example and he is bound to keep his marriage intact which in itself is an effort.
@allknowing (137771)
• India
5 Mar 13
When they join the priesthood they are very young and are not exposed as much as they do in later years specially nowadays. The fact that so many are going astray could be an indication that some radical change is called for.
It is easy to quote the gospel but difficult to practice.
@gabzreal (136)
• Philippines
5 Mar 13
Following Jesus means giving up EVERYTHING..
Luke 5 records Jesus calling his first disciples.In both instances, in the calling of Simon Peter and Levi the tax collector, Luke notes they “left everything and followed him.” Luke’s gospel that others wanted to take care of their affairs before they followed Jesus and Jesus basically told them they could take care of those things or follow him. But they couldn’t do both.them leaving their boats, their nets, their tax collector booth, and their other possessions. And that’s all true. But they also left their families, their houses,and their careers... I suggest if one wants to be a priest and follow jesus..center your self to God..not to your own self..give up your needs our earthly needs... dont take a vow of a priest if you cannot do it.. dont worry if catholic priest go astray..even the disciples of jesus like Judas, even do the worst thing..and even simon peter denied jesus 3 times...what did jesus do? did you tolerate? it? no.. what happens to priest today alreay happens in biblical times.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
4 Mar 13
The number of incidents are increasing indeed. But still, I would rather that Catholic priests should remain chaste and should only focus his time in serving the Lord. I think that this is the ultimate test for a man in order to know who really deserves to be called a descendant of God.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
It is time those teaching theology should look at the reasons why so many priests go astray. If they want their priests to remain celibate then there has to be a radical change whatever that is. Otherwise we will only be reading scandals by the dozen every single day.
@Angelpink (4034)
• Philippines
4 Mar 13
Hi Knowing ! Priesthood is a calling , a vocation and not a profession. It needs your 100% giving of yourself and that includes not marrying . Unlike in a profession that its alright not to give your 100% in your work. They can never be allowed to marry because of their huge responsibility to all people that is 24 /7 . If they really wanted to marry then they are still given that freedom , but to do that they must leave the priesthood and be an ordinary man in the community. No one was ever forced to stay in celibacy , all are given freedom to do what their heart's desire .
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
Giving of one's 100% is possible even after one is married. When priests today spend most of their time building churches, collecting funds and what not which is far from being holy, taking care of a couple of children and having a wife is a mere drop.
Just yesterday the parish priest dropped in asking for donations. He never asked us how spiritually strong we were but whether we were financially strong to give him money.
Most priests today do not have a clean conscience and rightly so as they are exposed much too much. You must be reading about it every single day. Marriage will give them a clean conscience and they will perform better. These are my views Angelpink based on what I see around me. One priest impregnated a nun here recently.
@pergammano (7682)
• Canada
4 Mar 13
Don't pass out..for once I fully concur with you! Many, many years ago I fell out of love with the Catholic religion and it's tenets. I was fully exposed to it's economic side, ONE of the richest businesses in the world. Often, the worship had the almighty dollar attached to it! I think because of the cyber world, we are being made more aware, of the indescretions and also because the populace of this belief being one of the largest in the world. Will allowing marraige solve this problem..possibly, but if it just reduces the "scandals" by a small percentage, it has served a purpose for the good!
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
Marriage is one of the things. The commercial aspect of religion which is almost 90% should be taken away from them and lay people should handle it. Today religion is nothing but money.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
4 Mar 13
I think it would improve a great many things in the church. Not to say that would automatically cure all ills or get rid of all bad priests, but it would remove one huge problem
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
Priests can perform better if they are not shackled by guilt and most are. As you say it sure will remove a huge problem. Marriage will give them a guilt free conscience and to some extent the boys around them will be safe!
@jalucia (1431)
• United States
4 Mar 13
I don't no a whole lot about the foundation that the Catholic religion was built on, but it is in the most trying times that you are to show the strength of your faith. God's word is not to be bent and shaped according to secular happenings. I guess what I'm saying is "times are tough" is not an excuse to compromise, especially, someone's religion. And I am not one that is quick to mess with tradition. All that being said, I am not too too knowledgeable about the Catholic religion. I just know that with any religion it is not right to bend it and mold it to suit our personal tastes.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
That by remaining celibate alone one can render service to mankind needs to be given a thought. These rules were made during the time when there were hardly any situations that these priests were exposed to. Looking at the number of priests that go astray these days that itself is proof enough that this rule needs to be given a second look.
@mods196621 (3652)
• Philippines
5 Mar 13
You are right there are lots of things priests are expose to outside world. There are many reasons for them to look and see what is happening around like internet, cellphones and a lot more that are easy to connect with others. I feel if they will be marry how they will concentrate and offer themselves to God? I think, it is up to them 'priests' to think first and feel first if their life is for priesthood or for outside world. It is hard for them to be a family man and at the same time is a priest celebrating their mass while they see their kids running around or see them crying because kid wanted to be at his father side like an ordinary scenario of a father/son relationship. This is just my opinion... have a nice day friend!
@allknowing (137771)
• India
5 Mar 13
If they give up what they are doing today, such as building churches and other money oriented projects which is a layman's job they will have plenty of time for spiritual pursuits even after getting married. A guiltless conscience can do wonders spiritually.
When they made their vows they were not exposed as much as they get to later on.
@doroffee (4222)
• Hungary
4 Mar 13
I think if there are some rules in a certain group, you should keep them if you want to belong in them. If you really wanna be a Catholic priest, bear with the celibacy. If you can't resist the temptations, step out. That's all. But if you vow celibacy, and you don't keep your vowws, you're a hypocrite and you shouldn't preach about what others should do to be good Christians.
@allknowing (137771)
• India
4 Mar 13
When an individual joins the priesthood he is just around his teens and the 14 years that he gets trained are free from all exposure and so deciding whether an individual can stick to celibacy becomes easy at that time. In later years if he finds that he cannot keep to the vows the right thing would be to get out but that is not easy just as it is not easy to get out of a bad marriage.