"You Won't Always Win" - What age should this be taught?

United States
March 15, 2013 10:48am CST
I have another incentive based event that brought on another issue that I see... We have coin races to fund raise - basically, the kids bring in loose coins and try to fill up classroom buckets... the classroom with the most gets a pizza party, the PTA gets the funds... very popular event. However, again this years PTA 'powers that be' decided that instead of the winning CLASS getting a pizza party, the entire winning GRADE would get one... brought on by younsters not understanding that they can't always be the winner. This issue raised alot of concern with a number of parents because it's not teaching the concept of healthy competition... it's teaching the kids "why even TRY, we're going to be rewarded anyway"... Both this issue and my other posted issue were raised in PTA meetings, but there were more parents who wanted to see their kids rewarded for ANYTHING other than excelling... so... I try to teach my child that certain things are expected, you don't get rewards. In a contest, SOME ONE is going to loose. If you want to be rewarded, you need to excel... it's just getting so hard to teach this when he's surrounded by kids who are constantly SO obviously being held to lower standards... Thoughts? Perspective?
2 responses
• Valdosta, Georgia
15 Mar 13
My kids have been taught this concept since they could play any game! I also have a Childcare Business so they are around a bunch of other kids so I knew they would need this lesson in life early. I taught my kids this since they were about 2 years old! Too me, it's the way life is. Not all of us get ahead in life, not everyone wins every time we do something. That is life and it is normal. I personally think it is ridiculous that there are no winners and losers now a days. Competition is healthy! And it's a way of life! I will keep teaching my children this concept because they need to know they will not always do well in life... I think it is stupid letting everyone win all the time!
• United States
18 Mar 13
Thank you for the response, and I appreciate knowing I'm not the only one who sees the issue here. For my own sanity, I will have to try to not let the pettiness of other parents get to me and concentrate on teaching my son the important things. Thanks for the support!
@nanayangel (7879)
• Philippines
15 Mar 13
Hi there Raven7317! I think that I would suggest that there would be two kinds of prizes. First one would be for the winners and the other as consolation prize. In that way, both opinions or requests will be satisfied. Everyone will be rewarded for their effort, only, the winning team will get better prize than the other team. Events such as this is a good opportunity for character formation. Aside from learning about not winning all the time, kids can also learn about sportsmanship, camaraderie and also sharing, in case the winner decides to share their prizes with the other team.
• United States
18 Mar 13
Hi Nana, thanks for the response. I guess I don't see how the kids are learning about being a good loser when they are being given a prize... Just for participating? I don't agree with this, they don't HAVE to participate... plus, the final outcome of the contest is to raise money for PTA sponsored events - like field trips, after school drama, movie nights... The entire student body benefits from this... THAT is the consolation prize. I guess it wouldn't have bothered me except we ran it this way for years and it was changed ONLY because there were parents who couldn't/wouldn't teach their kids that they can't always win. Thanks for the response... this is one I will have to get over.