someone must go home tonight...who is it? do you agree with america? save used?

I would really like to hear her performance...I am sure I will online. this year there really as good of talent as I thought there would have been from auditions... yes better to have a few god ones that none at all tho... who do you think will or should go home? I know you cant watch until later tonight tho

honestly I was rooting for phillip Phillips to win...not that Jessica wasn't good because she was and she really has a lot of talent and I am sure we will hear more from her in the future. I do agree that the choice for her single wasn't that great tho...not a good choice at all. im not sure what she is doing now a days but it would be nice to know...I never really likes scotty that is for sure!!

I wished that it was really Jessica who won last year. She was great during the entire show. Her performances were consistently great. I just think Philip Philips won because of that song Home. It was a great song compared to the winning song given to Jessica. At least Philips is famous nowadays but Jessica is really great. So I hope this year, a girl will win. Just imagine for the past four years, all the girls on the finale were better than the guy but it still end up that guys won. Haley, Crystal, Jessica? Those were great singers compared to Scotty, Lee, and Philip.

I should add that I have no idea who will be going home but, thus far, two males are in the bottom three.

it is a lot weaker this season than last. that includes the talent, the judges, the new changes.... that is devin and paul right?

I completely disagree. This season is far way better than last year. Last year I can only recall Jessica and Colton who were so good at that season. Now, all the girls are great. And guys like Burnell and Curtis are amazing. This is the only season who have great girls for the past 3 years or 4 years. During the season when Scotty won, it was only haley reinhart who was a good singer that season. During the season when Lee Dweyze (I don't know if I got his last name correct), it was only Didi Benami and Andrew Garcia who were great that season. The best season for me when everyone seems to be great in singing is during the season of Kris Allen. Who can forget Adam Lambert? or Alison Iraheta? it's just strange that Kris won over those great talents.

oh you are talking about Lazaro and yes i agree with you. the night before me and a friend had decided that it needed to be Lazaro or Paul to go home and he wasnt even in the bottom 3. his performance was not up to par for me and i didnt enjoy it. i kind of knew he wouldnt go home because of him being in 4th with the voting the week before but he did deserve to be down there....some seem to think he is getting sympaty votes...what do you think?

prior to last night I never thouugt about sympathy votes but after he started crying from the judges comments, it did seek into my mind when he at least wasn't in the bottom three/I mean he sings OK but he was really bad on wednesday..

i did watch the recaps and i do not remember what the judges had said and i missed it if he was crying...agreed he has a great voice i jsut feel that this past week wasnt his week. this isnt the same guy i saw at auditions. well he is still on the show another week and i really hope that this coming up week he is able to step it up because if not it will not be long before he goes home...as long as it isnt all about sympaty votes.

so you were voting for Curtis to win?? are you still going to be watching or have you stopped because he went home?

I will still watch as I love a few of them. I like that kid that sings in english and spanish. Devon?

Devon, hes about 20-21. he sang 3-4 songs so far this season. he starts in english, then switches to spanish. hes good. :)

i agree with you 100%. jessica sanchez was amazing on the show she had a new energy about her. she came out there having a good time. her performance was great. she deserves this and it is great to see her shooting for her dreams!! i hope to see more from her in the future.

I don't like American idol I LOVE it and cant live without it lol. I go crazzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzy without it!!!!!

Its been my favorite show for about 10-11 years now.

it good :P

do you watch the American idol show? I know it shows in the Philippines because people were watching it last year when she was on the show. I hear she was absolutely amazing tonight on the show! well watching her on youtube is better than nothing at all! :)