Should I or should I not quit the home phone

@suspenseful (40192)
Canada
March 22, 2013 10:00am CST
So here is the problem. I got my home phone on basic and also my cell phone, and both have caller id. I get long distance calls on both and because I do not answer them unless it is my cousin in Ontario, I do not know whether the one called me was important or just a telemarketer and it costs money to find the name of the caller. They just give the city. And I do not want to purchase a reverse directory for the whole of North America. I could go back to the advanced on my home phone but that would cost an extra $20 - $40 and yet since some of those calls come from the State, even the 1-800 have roaming fees. I usually get one a day plus the wrong numbers, so I was wondering whether giving up my home phone and just keeping the cell phone would work. I live in Canada, by the way. And the home phone costs about $20 a month now but will go up.
6 people like this
16 responses
• Philippines
23 Mar 13
It is minimal to maintain home phone is very important in case of emergency it is one way of knowing where you are and cellphone is also beneficial for you can bring it anywhere you are, but the disadvantage is in case you are low bat. If you can afford maintain both. If i will visit Canada then I will contact you to your home phone for sure and if your not around I will just leave a message. Okay.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
I have caller id on my home phone and what bothers me is that those on the other hand who do not, and I have to go on the reverse pages to find out who is calling. So I believe if even if it costs a bit more, to always have caller id. I have an iphone so I can plug it in and it is also good for emergencies or when the power is off. The trouble with just having a cellphone is that the long distance and roaming charges are so high here in Canada. Oh I have voice mail on my home phone. Have not checked it yet for a while.
@peavey (16936)
• United States
22 Mar 13
Is there a reason you have two phones? I dropped my land line phone several years ago because it was just an extra cost. The cell phone does everything the land line did and more. Unless a person has their name blocked, you will see who is calling on a cell phone and you have voice mail. I don't know how it is there, but here we can get long distance within the country for no extra charge (it just uses the normal minutes).
1 person likes this
@peavey (16936)
• United States
25 Mar 13
I don't know how much difference there is in plans there, but here we can get long distance without having roaming charges. It's not expensive.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
I have an alarm system where the 1-800 number is in the States and I live in Canada. Now in winter, the power often goes out and the alarm system that is on battery and if the battery starts to run down, it beeps and I have to call that number to get it stopped and to recharge the battery. I also want to see a standard fee on my phone and not see the fees go up and down.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
I have a cousin in another province and also in-laws in other provinces, plus a brother in another province who does not like computers. I also have an alarm system with a toll=free number in the States. And apparently you get charged roaming fees. I really want to put my home phone back on the free long distance plan, but cannot afford it now. And also I have to replace it as well as the reception is bad especially long distance. I would not mind paying extra on the cell if I get someone who talks a lot, but do not want to pay roaming fees.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
23 Mar 13
If one is good enough, then there is no need to have both unless it is cheap for the service. I have a land phone in my school apartment and it is one that I can answer phones for free without paying any monthly fee for it, but if I need to make a phone call by using it, I need to get a phone card for outgoing calls. I use it mainly for the Internet connection. I use my mobile phone for calling and answering in most cases for its convenience. Thanks for the discussion. Have a good day, friend.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
1 Apr 13
I have relatives and in-laws all over Canada and some in Europe and if I had my home phone on the free long distant plan, it would work better for me and use my cell just for local calls. The trouble is that I have to have one phone for the long distant plAN and right now I only have both on basic. It is not about the money, it is about when I make a long distant call I want to know if I have enough minutes left on my home phone basic plan so I will not get a higher fee that I have not budgeted for. And now I got an unexpected expense that had not figured on (nothing to do with the phones, something else.)
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
22 Mar 13
I think it all depends upon your needs. I have a home phone and I pay just the basic. I very rarely use it. I have a tracfone that costs me 20.00 every 3 months or more. I carry it mainly for emergencies. For me this is cheaper than getting a regular cell phone. As for answering unwanted phone calls, I have a caller ID and a message machine. If I don't recognize a number, I just don't pick up. If they want to talk to me bad enough then they will leave a message.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
I do have a caller id, and an answering machine, but some of those long distance numbers only give the numbers and not the person who calls. I never heard of a tracfone but feel that might be what someone in business needs, but not a homeowner. I get most of my home phones on my home phone, but make most of my calls on my cell phone. And I have relatives and in-laws out of the province. I also am debating on whether since I have a in-laws out of province, what would be cheaper to use the long distance program on my home phone or do everything on my cell. My home phone is bundled with my internet and cable.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
31 Mar 13
Here we call them 'Pay as you go,' and you purchase like you have, so many minutes. With me, I want to pay the same amount each month on my cell phone and on my home phone. In fact, even if I have an extra twenty cents which is what I had before I got the message plan, I got very nervous. I will never answer a private caller and I think that if someone has the number on caller id, they should at least have the name. And do not like wrong numbers either. My cell phone plan is rather reasonable, but then I have an iphone and it is used for other thing.. I have the cheapest talk, message, and data plan on it.
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
30 Mar 13
Hi Suspenseful, A tracfone is the last thing that any business would want. It is like a cell phone but you buy minutes for it. I buy 120 mins. for 20.00 and it lasts me for quite a while because I hardly ever use it. I carry it mainly for emergencies. On my land line, I do NOT pick up the phone if I don't recognize the number or if it says 'Private Caller'. I figure if the person wants to talk to me bad enough then they will leave a message and I will either pick it up or call them back when I am able to. Walmart has those go-phones for 40.00 per month with unlimited texting and calling plus internet. Tha might be financially better for you depending on your needs. My home phone is only like 23.00 per month bundled in with my internet and cable. This works for me but it may not for you. I will say that I would not pay for both a home phone and a costly cell phone plan.
1 person likes this
@dainy1313 (2370)
• Leon, Mexico
22 Mar 13
Hello Suspenseful, I hope that you are fine. My mother quitted her home phone five years ago, and she just has her cell phone and it works quite perfect for her. I cannĀ“t quit the home phone since I work from home, and my teens also receive and make calls. Blessings Suspenseful... dainy
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
With me, I have a cousin who lives in another province and also I have an alarm system where the 1-800 number is based in the United States and I live in Canada. I have no idea whether if I use my cell to contact them in case of an emergency, if I will be charged Roaming fees or not. The thing is the last time, I contacted them on my cell because the digital phone was off as well as all the electricity, I was going to be put on hold so I hung up.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
That's the trouble because the reason I downgraded my home phone was to save money over the Christmas holidays and then my friend who has since moved assumed that I was saving the money to donate more to the church. Well our deacons know that I am a pensioner and do not have that much so they never approached me on the subject. So now I am stuck, because it has taken up to this last month to catch up. Now I am not talking about credit card charges but how much money I have to put away for after Christmas payments, and not to mention restocking the pantry, buying new clothes, etc.
1 person likes this
@dainy1313 (2370)
• Leon, Mexico
24 Mar 13
I see, I understand quite well how important is to have quick access to those emergency numbers. We also have one of them.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
23 Mar 13
Unless your internet is bundled with it, why don't you just quit the home phone and use viber or skype etc on your smartphone? It's cheaper. For me the home phone is still necessary because of the internet bundle and my parents still use landline.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
My internet is bundled with it and there are three choices, basic, light long distance and regular long distance. I am considering going back to regular long distance because of all my in-laws and relatives. I do like my cellophones because it is easier when I am out and also if two people call me at the same time.
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
22 Mar 13
We got rid of ours, because all in the house have their own cell phone. We haven't missed the land line at all.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
there's just me, but I have relatives and in-laws all over Canada. So need the landline. Trouble is because of finances I had to give up the free long distance plan as well as the extended tv viewing plan. I am on a tv-internet-phone. And if I go to Vnnux do not know if they will upgrade the phone wiring, like put in new jacks. I know that our phone plan will do that install them for free if I buy the jacks. So am rather stuck at what I am. If everyone lived in Winnipeg, then it would be no problem but they don't.
1 person likes this
@ElicBxn (63643)
• United States
23 Mar 13
I think that giving up the landline is the way to go. I can't give up mine, because the roomie has to have a dedicated landline for her job. I've also had the number since 1984, so it would be hard to give it up.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
With that is that I have relatives and in-laws all over Canada. It was all right when I had the long distance plan, but now I do not have the long distance plan so the cell phone and the home phone plan is about the same. Also with the cell phone, I can go on the street and talk or be at a store and call someone. So now I want to go back to the long distance on my home phone, but if I put the same on my cellphone, with the roaming charges, it would cost more.
1 person likes this
@MoonGypsy (4606)
• United States
22 Mar 13
many people only have their cell phones and not a home phone. i would say to keep the home line for if you want a fax machine. other than that, it is quite useless if you have a cell phone.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
With me, I have relatives all over Canada and need the home phone for that. Also if I call a toll free number by cell to the States, I will have to pay roaming fees and have no idea whether it is time related. The whole trouble is that I went temporarily on basic home phone to put back the money I spent on other things, and was wondering whether to continue this. It would be different if all my relatives lived here in Winnipeg, but they don't.
@sk66rc (4250)
• United States
22 Mar 13
I kept my landline phone for my daughter & Internet... I had DSL & back when I got it, phone company made me get a landline, or rather keep my landline... Now I have fios, I don't really need to keep the landline open... My daughter has grown up & I'm thinking about getting her a cell phone as well... If that's the case, I don't have any needs for the home landline phone... Weather it's $20 a month or $200 a month, why spend anything if you don't need to...
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
I have relatives and in-laws all over Canada, but now temporarily I have just put my home phone on basic which is rather ridiculous because is that is what I have my cellphone on, a basic with limited data. The thing is that I have been getting long distance calls every night and when I go on the net to look at the who called list, they will give you the city and street but not the person, so you have to pay extra to get it. I wonder if that is their purpose. And if I do go back on the long distance program will those long distance telemarketers stop phoning me?
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
23 Mar 13
i was just thinking of that today. if it would be better if i got a cell phone. but then i would have to pay more then i currently use and son is in on the home phone bill because it is bundled with our cable. yet he has a cell that his job pays for. id like having a cell but i guess im better off without the extra bill. so maybe you should just give up your home phone and only have one, then you could afford the extra expense. if that makes any sense.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
I find that a cell phone alone would be a disadvantage if I have to call someone on a -800 number in the states and be put on hold. My son also has a cell phone for his job and if I use that phone number, I cannot talk for long because it is for his job, so with your son, that cell is mainly for his job so his employer wants to be sure he can get on it and if he cannot, assume that your son is talking to someone related to his occupation. I can afford both, it is just that I wish that people would use caller id. And that roaming fees do not apply to toll free long distance on cell phones.
@rosekiss (30414)
• Eugene, Oregon
23 Mar 13
Whether you have a home phone or not, is totally up to you, as you are the only one who knows whether you can afford both your cellphone, and home phone. In my situation, I couldn't see paying for both, so I got rid of my home phone, and just use my cellphone. I would always get a lot of telemarketers on my home phone, and it got so annoying, so I just decided I didn't need all the hassle. I really don't miss my home phone at al. I use my cellphone everyday, and I would be lost without it. Take care, and have a good day.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
29 Mar 13
Trouble is that I have in-laws and relatives all over the place and they all do not like here in Winnipeg. In my cellphone, I have certain rings for those who are related or friends that live out of the city, and rings for the bad guys -telemarketers. I do have caller id so that helps except when I am tired, and reach for the nearest phone. Will have to think about it.
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
22 Mar 13
I did years ago. Fact was I did move frequently and I had to pay for the movement of my phonenumber as well. Also I needed to pay each month for the connection (even if I was not calling at all). Since I seldom call and just have a Phone in case of need I decided to give up on it. The money I had to pay just for the connection I am not even spending in 4 or 5 months time by calling. So it was a big waste of good money. Only bad thing about the cellphone is calling does cost way more plus if you do need to call an organisation they make you pay more (extra costs because you call with a cellphone). Still I save way more money this way and I Always try to contact everybody by the internet/e-mail. If I use my cellphone I tekst. I even have a different (way cheaper) number to tekst abroad. For $20 a month you can make a lot of Phone calls or?
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
For me, I get a lot of telemarketing calls, and also I have relatives and in-laws who live out of province. I tried to get the Rogers 1 number on my computer but apparently it does not work on Macs. I was thinking of switching to Vonex for my home phone, but do not know if that would if there are repairs. I know with my home phone even with the basic, repairs are free and I think that includes getting wiring done. Also my friends seem to contact me with the home phone even though they know my cell phone and I need the later when I go out of the house. So it seems to be either I am screwed it I give up the cell or give up the home. I was thinking of putting the home phone back on the free long distant plan, but right now cannot do that.
@internaty (257)
• Chile
22 Mar 13
Well, it is easier for people to contact us by the honme phone, but if it is getting complecated and expensive, maybe you could quit. My advice is that you wite a list with the pros and the cons, and make your decision. good luck
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
25 Mar 13
I think that is a good idea even though I am not a list maker. The thing is that when I got my cell phone it was first for emergencies and when the landline does not work, which happens here when the power goes out since my homephone is digital, and also if I am out somewhere. And the homephone well we had a good plan included with internet and tv where the long distant calls were free. Then because of Christmas I decided to downgrade the homephone temporarily. Then one of my friends suggested I put some money for the school since our church has a private school. She does not have that good timing as to suggestions. If it would have been when I first joined the church, it would have been all right, but to do it when I already had the after holidays on my mind, did not like it. Now had I kept the home phone for long distance and not duplicate services, then I would not have had this discussion, because with cell phones, you have to pay for the minutes, and there are roaming fees even for the toll-free since I iive in Canada. I also have in-laws and relatives all over Canada. So therein is the problem, if I quit the home phone, I lose out and if I keep it I lose out. So it seems I need both.
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
22 Mar 13
whitepages.com is a free reverse lookup that you can use to find out who called you. Don't you have a voice mail on your home phone? Here, most phone plans have free voice mail where if you don't answer they can leave a message. You can either look into that or buy a phone that has voice mail. But I'm seriously considering giving up my land line at home and just using my cell--maybe that would be best for you, too, as you can see who is calling and also save money. Everything is going up!
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
23 Mar 13
Thanks for the information. There is this one who keeps calling me every night and whoever it is is not related to me. And I do not know who that is because whoever it is did not give his name or the company he works for, just the number and apparently he is doing it to other people. (Yes, maybe he works for the phone company and is calling from his home so they get long distance charges -that is how my mind works.) I do have voice mail but now I have the cheap one. I am also worried because I heard of those who had just the cell phone and someone calls or they answer the phone, they get dinged.
@Fatcat44 (1141)
• United States
22 Mar 13
If both phones do the same, why do you have both? To me it sounds that simple in your case. Also, you cellphone should have voice-mail, so if it is important, they should leave a message. I have a home phone because my internet is bundled with it. To get rid of the home phone, my internet would be almost as much. Also, I have a young daughter who I keep the phone for. I can get her a cell phone, but the cost would be equal. So it doesn't matter yet. I will get her a cellphone in a couple of years and the land line will go then and save myself 20 a month.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
24 Mar 13
My home phone is bundled with my internet and the reason I downgraded it to just basic was because of Christmas and a friend of mine who thought I was made of money "Why don't you?" But I also have a cousin who lives in the next province and also those toll free calls down to the states, I do not know if I would be charged roaming fees for that. It is very complicated to ask my provider. If I could go back to the free long distance calls, it would be easier but it would cost a bit more. And also the reception is not as good on my home phone as it would be on my cell. Yet it would cost a bit more in the long run depending on whether the one on the other end, like a telemarketer, is also a motor mouth.