who can call you by your name?
By pomwango
@pomwango (1353)
Kenya
March 26, 2013 1:59am CST
i find it abit weird that some parents dont mind being called by their names by their kids,i think this is wrong and disrespectful,its good to have your kids address you as dad or mom,as for relations its also good to address them by tittles,aunt,uncle,grandma etc.i feel nice about being referred to as such and not have a four year old child screaming out my name,whats your view on this?
6 people like this
40 responses
@extremefun4fun (2908)
• India
26 Mar 13
well, it is good to call name but if we use address of relations too... like aunt anna , uncle david.... i do not mind like that even i like somebody call me like that...
@alpha9180 (301)
• Malaysia
27 Mar 13
I would feel weird and disrespectful if my kid would called me by names. I would not allow them to call other people by names too especially those who are elder than them. At least they need to address them as aunty and uncle so and so...Even with elderly neighbours' man and woman, we would address them as grandma ...or grandpa... I think this is basic manners one should have.
1 person likes this
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
30 Mar 13
I'm referring to parents of before during the time of my childhood. I could definitely say it's "general" because my friends and I talked about it once or several times in our gatherings and we would share what we went through during childhood.
Being drunk and driving is not the same with being a parent and being firm. We're not talking about being beaten with whips here. We're talking about being slapped (without pure anger).
This is not the same with parents these days who are too soft. Requesting their kids instead of leading them. Waiting for their kids opinions instead of knowing what's good for them.
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
31 Mar 13
Perhaps the difference there is the fact that you see it as violence, while the parents of my generation see it as discipline. If you could compare the outcome of the children now and before, you'd see that there are more children who are displaced now compared to before. But heck, there are too many factors to consider.
Anyhow, a slap isn't something that adults too instantly (you need to distinguish the violent act from the 'disciplining' act), children don't get slapped the instant they commit a mistake, they're told to not do it again, if they still continue doing so, they get slapped.
Remember in management there is a positive and a negative reinforcement or motivation. You can't always rely on one form in order to get the desired effect. You need to know how to mix and match things. Positive motivation doesn't always work in the same way that negative motivation doesn't always work either.
All I'm saying that in my generation, parents would slap mouths of kids who call their parents by name repeatedly even if they're told not to do so because it's disrespectful. It is the middle, it is acceptable and legal because you're disciplining your child ~ you are being a parent who isn't controlled by your child. Further, we are talking about the parent here, not some stranger who is disciplining the child for you. Try talking to your child when they're being a brat, let's see if there's point talking to them that time.
@jazel_juan (15746)
• Philippines
26 Mar 13
In our society, we are not called by our names, it is VERY rare for kids to call their parents by name as that is deemed disrespectful. Kids should always address their parents as mom, dad, mommy or daddy,mama or papa or in our native tongue, as nanay or tatay or tata.. Even with our older siblings, we address them by adding Kuya (for brother) before their names or Ate ( for older sister) before their names.. Like with my brother Nick, i call him Kuya Nick.. and that is the same with older cousins, these are applied. And the same for Aunts and Uncles.
@jazel_juan (15746)
• Philippines
26 Mar 13
yes that is one thing nice about here, plus it feels awkward to call someone by their names, well for me that is. i am so used to addressign someone older than me by those names.
@JamesKYTan (1605)
• Malaysia
26 Mar 13
In our Asian society we still appreciate relationship of elders and juniors. This is called reverence for the elders. Children should respect their parents by calling them father or mother. They however, may disagree with their parents but still have reverence for their parents. Even the west they still call dad or mum. We address our uncles or aunts or grandpas or grandmas according to their hierarchy. Even when we meet strangers we address them as uncles or aunties according their age. Do you?
@alpha9180 (301)
• Malaysia
27 Mar 13
I am absolutely agree with you. This has been the way Asian society practising and I think it is respectful in this manner. It will be rude if our kids were to called us by names...this is awful and disrespect. Besides, even if the children would want to call people be name they should address them aunty or uncle so and so...these are basic manners.
1 person likes this
@Professor2010 (20162)
• India
26 Mar 13
Thanks for this discussion, in my family i am the head, besides me my wife; son, daughter in law, grand kids are there..
none call me by name, my son and daughter in laws call as papa, and grand kids as dadaji, my wife calls me as 'ji' only; wives here will not utter name of hubby.
Yes my elder sisters, my parent in laws, my uncles who are older than me call me by name
And all my class mates call me by name as Bhuwan
@pomwango (1353)
• Kenya
2 Apr 13
Proffesor i like that style,it sounds very well and maintains respect.here we also do the same,i can call my husband by his name or pet names but when i am talking about him to the kids i will call him dad or your father or when i am talking about him to my parents or his i call him as father of our first born.
1 person likes this
@ShivenderRajput1 (110)
• India
26 Mar 13
in our part of society its considered disrespectful if youngsters call elders by their name. Its not acceptable and its correct. Its moral values that make a human. So we shud b upto it
@Buchi_bulla (8298)
• India
27 Mar 13
Even I feel that children should not call elders by names and it is disrespect. Calling aunts
and uncles by name is too disrespectful. If kids call elders in singular, that is ok, but not
by names.In the beginning itself, this habit should be stopped.
@ptrikha_2 (46916)
• India
26 Mar 13
I too think that it is disrespectful to call someone very elder to us and in our relation by names. Even talking about those folks by names in our close family meetings is not something that I favor. There could be cases where someone or their family(s) are not behaving well enough with us and making a situation where good respect is not something that they are reciprocating with. It is better to teach kids with respect for elders unless the elders are of a dubious character.
@taiwanlife (745)
• Philippines
26 Mar 13
I am Asian and this just doesn't work for me too. What I like working with the Westerners though is that we call each other by our first names including the boss. Everybody gives their best effort for the company. We all work for the same cause thus calling by first name means equality, having this freedom in suggesting new ideas on the table no matter who you are as long as it is for the benefit of the company.
@lil_toni (206)
•
26 Mar 13
I also agree with you. Some parents wouldn't mind it. We should always respect and be polite to other people specially older ones. And parents should also teach their children the correct manner. But we should also respect other people' s opinion or perspective and also their choice regarding this matter.
@giggles721 (275)
• Philippines
26 Mar 13
I would definitely want younger generations address me accordingly like auntie or "ate" (addressed to older women hear in the Philippines). It's somewhat confusing though when the age difference gets in the way of the hierarchy. For example in our family I have a cousin who is as old as my mother and her kids are all older than me. Instead of calling me auntie her children just call me by my name and then I call them "ate" or "kuya" (the names when addressing elders who are at most 15 years older). My mother said that it is still appropriate to respect them by age rather than the relation in the family but some of my cousins who are also younger just call those older nieces and nephews by name. I would still follow what our mother taught me and I too will teach the same to my kids someday. The respect in calling someone's name is just the first because what makes someone respectable is proving that he/she is worth the respect.
@missjahn (4574)
• Philippines
27 Mar 13
ah, this one - sometimes i am calling my mom her name whenever her friends seeking her presence. well, for me calling the elder's name by their names is not showing disrespect at all times. it depends on how you call it for a reason. like i am calling my mom's name softly because sometimes i want her to feel that i care for her. sort of reason like that. but i will not call my mom's name whenever she is angry or in a high temper. that is not a suitable time for calling her uttering her name. we must fit every action we make to every situation or yet we will be disrespecting them for any reason. :)
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
27 Mar 13
Does your Mom feel comfortable when you call her by her name?
@rocketking (189)
• Singapore
26 Mar 13
I think it is not ok and we should address our elders by their titles, it cultivates respect for your elders and authority. This is a very strong practice in Asia and in Chinese there are even many different titles for each of the various relations instead of simply "uncles" and "aunties", which shows how strongly entrenched the belief is.
@silverfox09 (4708)
• United States
27 Mar 13
There are so many different cultures and none is better than the other , just different . Our culture tell a story about where we are from .
@chiyosan (30184)
• Philippines
26 Mar 13
I do not think that calling our parents by their names are okay. in our family we know we cannot do this and we are not comfortable to do it too. I do not even know why or how it has started in the US that kids or children call their parents by their names. it is only with them that i have heard a parent called by his/her name. its a sign of being disrespectful if we call our parents by their names.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
1 Apr 13
My elder daughter began calling me by name a while ago and I told her to stop. If I'm being introduced to their friends my kids can use my first name or Mrs .... when they were young.
My nieces and nephews all called us aunty or uncle but when they became older teens I asked to be call just by my name. They take no notice.
I also asked my family to call me by the short form of my name...they don't. My two sisters have short forms and are called by that and one sister prefers the long form but for me, it's always the long version which I detest.
My very elderly Dad was the only one to accede to my request.(he's gone now).
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
26 Mar 13
Here in our country people do call their elders with respect. No matter how bad a person maybe, they do make us of Mom, Dad, Aunt and Uncle. That is how we were taught by my parents. And even if there are friends of my parents, we call then either Aunt or Uncle as well.
@Pegasus72 (1898)
•
8 Apr 13
I think some kids go through that phase. Mine didn't seem to thankfully. I didn't call my parents by their names either. I guess it just depends on the child and how they hear you called more often.
@FireflyN (22)
• United States
26 Mar 13
I was raised to show respect. I call people by their titles, be it mom, dad, aunt, uncle, mister, miss. It doesn't matter. I feel it is disrespectful to call someone by just their first name, unless they have asked you to or stated that it is ok for you to do so. When I see kids calling their parents by their first name, I feel that it shows not only disrespect, but also distance between them, as if they don't have a good relationship. Personally, if I ever have kids, I will be "mom" or some variation. I would feel too disconnected from my kids and worry they might see me as more of an equal and less of an authority figure at that point if they used my name.