Want advise for giving gift to a very dear friend...

@vandana7 (100297)
India
March 29, 2013 10:08am CST
She is aunty actually...78 years old. Her birthday is on 4th April, and I know I am late with this discussion. She has ample bags, ample purses, ample perfumes, ample sarees, ample jewelry, ample shoes, just about everything under the sun...she is far far richer than me. :) So...my choices are a. Potted plant b. Chocolate box Would either of them be ok as Birthday gift? Or have you a better suggestion...
3 people like this
19 responses
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
29 Mar 13
Hi Vandana How about a collection of some of the family pics for her in a photo album? I know, I am being lame here but I do feel that in todays world with digital media all around, it is still a wonderful heart-touching feeling to see the photos of good old times specially of friends and family. If not, I would love to opt for the Chocolate Box
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
thesids...Bird has also suggested the same thing...and honestly it is one of the best suggestions out here... Photo Album...digital one...or even some CD with recordings of her kids...nowadays she is using computers.. So that can be good, especially when she does not feel like walking much...
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
16 Apr 13
I bought her three pots of roses, one dark red, one bright red, and one white bunch. She was very happy. I took a small box of chocolate and cake as well. She returned the chocolate box, with a large piece of cake saying she is allergic to chocolates. Actually, we did have problems that day. I mean, I had fixed the program, and dad joked that he would not take us as he was busy, and she took dad's word to be true, so she was late dressing up. In the process when we reached the temple, the granite floor was hot...I felt very sorry because the priest would not listen to us...he said come again in the evening. We have a jagannath temple out here...its exquisite..except that we should reach there before eight in summers if we dont want our feet burnt..lol. Somehow things went a bit awry from there...after cutting a cake, we had a little snack, and she was almost dozing. So we called it a day. Sorry for delay in replying. I have some household chores to clear..:(
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
2 Apr 13
I would love to know how did it all go. I know, finding a bunch of pics and maybe video clips too can be cumbersome but the good thing is that it is possible. Hope I(and maybe others too) would get to know how it all went on the 4th... Good Luck with finding the ones that you want on the CD
@mentalward (14690)
• United States
29 Mar 13
I'm sure she will appreciate whatever you choose to give to her. I'd do something a bit more abstract, though, and maybe write or print up an open invitation to lunch or dinner, maybe accompanied by some fresh flowers then leave it to her as to when to use that invitation, assuming it wouldn't be on a day that you couldn't make it.
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
She cant walk much...she should...but she had to climb stairs a few weeks ago, because lift was not working, and ever since, she has given up on that exercise. The only time she walks is, when she has to go to the kitchen, or bathroom, or answer a door bell. That is not good! She underwent chemo last year...so she does not really relish eating much...though I know she cant resist chocolates. :) All I want to do is to make her feel loved..and make her feel wanted...and make her feel cared for.
@mentalward (14690)
• United States
30 Mar 13
How about offering her a day of pampering, any day she chooses that is also good for you? I wrote a "ticket" for my mother's birthday once; the ticket was good for one entire day of being pampered. She LOVED it! Like your aunt, my mother had everything she needed and almost everything she could want. My stepfather made extremely good money and was quite generous to her so there wasn't much I could offer her in the way of material things. The day of pampering was perfect for her. She didn't need to lift a finger (or walk anywhere) because I did everything for her. Of course, chocolates are ALWAYS appreciated. lol
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
Oh pampering is something we do most of the time..lol
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
29 Mar 13
Either would be fine. At that age, I find most people (at least here) want fewer "things", so the chocolate would be good, because she can consume it. Or how about taking her out to dinner and a show or something?
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
29 Mar 13
Dawny she has problems with her legs...she can barely walk on road...:( She is also very fragile. We are taking her out to the temple, but that is it...its too hot. If she drinks outside water or eats out, I cant guarantee that everything will be fine with her. So no...we are going to have a gambling session at her place, a small sponge cake because she does not like cream. My maid is going to cook some fish for her. That is all that I had planned. But now that you say it is ok to offer chocolates, I am going to add that. :) I thought it was childish..lol.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
29 Mar 13
hi vandy and dawn speaking as an elderly lady oh my goodness you cannot go wrong with a box of chocolates. I gifted myself last night with a small box of Whitmans sampler. It had 8 pieces of the most divine chocolates,. I could only eat one piece as I have to watch my blood sugar but it was really so very delicious too. No special occasion but just felt like it. not childish at all. So I will have one each evening for 7 more evenings lol,.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
Thank you Hatley for confirming that it is not childish. :) Now I am more sure about what I want to give her. :)
@bhanusb (5709)
• India
29 Mar 13
hi vandana, your aunt is 78 years old. She may be a diabetic patient. So chocolate box would not be suitable for her. No I can't think potted plant as birthday gift. Give her a idol of Ganesha. She is a wealthy woman. I think she will like god of wealth.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
She is not diabetic...she's been very active person, and she does monitor what she eats. So chocolate will not hurt her. :) Ganesha.? Why...I have a nice one..:) Why didnt i think of it...:)
@Mavic123456 (21893)
• Thailand
29 Mar 13
I always go for potted plant... flower plant for birthday. It is renewing.. since it is birthday. I often gift this if I am invited to opening of gallery ( I gave my friend cactus) beauty salon.. I gave an indoor plant. It is different among other gifts that they will receive I know and it is symbolizes LIFE... nurture it, take care of it.. for it will flourish and it will grow and be abundant.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
Mavic - one of the reasons I like giving potted plants for most occassions is, it keeps the person cool and leaves them with pleasant thoughts. Another factor that influences such a decision is, there is no differentiation between friends and relatives. I do have a lot of friends and relatives who compare the gifts, especially its cost. So if I give one person a gift of 1000 bucks, another person would hold a grudge if I gave her a gift of 700 or so. :) So with plants, that comparison does not arise. :)
@Mavic123456 (21893)
• Thailand
31 Mar 13
okidoki vandy
@dagami (1158)
• Rome, Italy
29 Mar 13
hi, vandana. why don't you cook or bake something special for her? you can cook her favorite dish or bake her a special cake and let her blow the candles. when we turn into adults, we usually do not bother blowing the candles anymore during our birthday celebrations. maybe she hasn't done so in many years and this could be a wonderful surprise for her.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
Oh cake is on cards. But other things...I am not sure...now that you are suggesting, perhaps I will ...:) Her favorite dish? She is a very poor eater...cooking in small quantities is not something that I specialize in. :) We will buy instead. :) Yeah...it will make her feel young again. I am going to try that. :)
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
30 Mar 13
I read the first two lines of your discussion and even before I could proceed to the page , I just concluded that a few plants and some rare seeds may be ideal ;I saw it being listed as the first option too. I feel the first option is a good choice.If she loves chocolates, then you can give her on bar of special chocolate along with these plants. If you get along very well with her and she would like going out with you,then you can go out and treat her to some nice exotic icecream. You can ask her what music she likes or what books are her favourites and get some rare find .
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
Kala...going out...yes, I am taking her out to temple...on that day. :) Its very hot out here...so chances of her getting sun stroke increase considerably if she is taken out around this time of the year, especially since, she rarely goes out. Given that, a brief visit to temple followed by a visit to KFC, and then to her place with a small cake...and a cards session was what I planned. :)
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
29 Mar 13
hi vandy oh I am 86 and if I got a box of chocolates for my birthday I know I would love it too so I think thats a great gift or a potted plant both good choices., I feel Also perhaps a gift card to her favorite restaurant but I think you have named two really great gift options..
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
16 Apr 13
I gave her three rose plants. She was so touched with the gesture. I also gave her a chocolate box, which she promptly returned along with a large piece of cake..lol She says she is allergic to some of the chocolates so she avoids them. :)
@bird123 (10643)
• United States
30 Mar 13
It might be too late this year but how about making a photo album of all the oldest pictures dating back to the beginning of time. You can have them scanned and digitized so they last forever. I did this at Christmas one year. Everyone huddled around to see. How would it be for all aunt's people huddled around with her to see pictures and share stories? Indeed, memories in the making.
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
Bird...what a beautiful suggestion!!! Yeah...it is a nice thing to look at, especially when you are bed ridden...well almost bedridden...
@allknowing (136541)
• India
30 Mar 13
You have not said how much you are willing to spend. It depends on that.
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
Flexible budget..:) I liked Bird's suggestion below...and even Vegan's...though of course...I dont think its a viable thing in her case...she has been through chemo, and just last Jan...she had severe urinary infection that almost sniffed life out of her. She is very very delicate...she is a poor eater...and she has about 100 sarees...which she does not use as she hardly goes out, if at all. I wanted to give her Salwar Kameez ...but I know she wont wear it...another time, another place...may be.
@veganbliss (3895)
• Adelaide, Australia
30 Mar 13
http://www.adrenalin.com.au http://www.livingsocial.com/australia/cities/1055-australia-nationwide Give her the gift of an experience! No-one else would even think of it! Even if she can't use her legs much, she would be great at sky diving & bungee-jumping! Or maybe flying a fighter jet or driving a race car or a jetboat? There are also more ideas for the less adventurous on those sites - like a gift certificate for an educational course to do something specific that she has always wanted to do.
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
vegan...I would have loved to take her out ....to a hill station...and get her on a boat...but her son is ...you know not confident that his mother can withstand...overprotective...I hate sons...they dont have brains.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
30 Mar 13
I do think that anything that you think of for as long as it comes from your heart will be greatly appreciated.
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
1 Apr 13
Yeah, and the heart wants to give her sooooooooooooooo much that I get confused :)...she is a real darling...:)
@jkct02 (2874)
• Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia
30 Mar 13
Generally any gift is good as it is the intention that counts if the gift is presented with good wishes. She is your friend so you know her quite well. I am sure that your choice of gift is appropriate for her.
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
After reading through responses, I am now going to offer her a small chocolate box, and a small potted plant with an exotic plant in it. :)
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
16 Apr 13
sky diving...she can barely walk..lol
• Adelaide, Australia
30 Mar 13
No... wait! How's about sky diving & bungee-jumping??? It'll add years to her life & she'll love you forever!
@Keynote (399)
• India
29 Mar 13
Hello vandanaji! Plant seems better choice. If you think giving one plant is not sufficent than more than one can also work.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
Oh yes..plants are definitely a better choice. :) But instead of giving only one plant, I could give her a small box of chocolates as well. :)
@ElicBxn (63594)
• United States
22 Apr 13
If she's not diabetic, then chocolate! We've started giving the roomie's folks food for presents since they don't want more "things"
@BarBaraPrz (47332)
• St. Catharines, Ontario
29 Mar 13
A bouquet of cut flowers would be nice, too, but we know how you feel about that. Maybe a book of poetry?
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
16 Apr 13
Out here, we are not that poetic..lol I mean, she is already in that ...god and goodness mode...we call it "krishna rama" mode..lol. Most of the elderly folks become devout...by the time they reach seventy. She is seventy eight..right? :) Sorry for delaying the response...I took three different color rose plants for her. She liked them. :)
1 person likes this
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
30 Mar 13
Either a plant or chocolate sound good to me. You probably know which she'd prefer. Personally, I'd prefer the plant because my husband would probably eat the candy. I like to eat a piece or two a day, thus enjoying it longer. However, when he sees the box still nearly full, my husband has to "help" me eat it "before it gets stale".
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
at "help" for eating "before it gets stale". We could give both actually. Papa could give her chocolates, and I could give the potted plant. She likes chocolates. And basically, being a poor eater, she wont each all that much and yes, in her case it may "get stale"..lol. Potted plant would prompt her to walk and be there for a while in the sunshine. That is what I want. Right now, she does have a problem with her leg, but she also needs to keep herself mobile. :(
@doroffee (4222)
• Hungary
29 Mar 13
Oh, a potted plant would be a wonderful gift! It's pretty, and lives for quite long... it's something she could care for. You could also give her theatre tickets, for example, because an experience gift is always good for those "who have everything".
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
30 Mar 13
Yeah...and it would prompt her to get up to water that plant, and tend to it...right now, she is not walking much...even though she needs to.
• India
29 Mar 13
Actually its my brother birthday on the same day! all right.. she is 78 years old, come on , she now doesn't bother about money anyway! A hug and a potted plant would do it!
@vandana7 (100297)
• India
16 Apr 13
Thats what I did...and the hug must have felt good for the lonely lady. I could see she was touched. :)