which religion for my kid?
By bryanwmc
@bryanwmc (1051)
Malaysia
April 3, 2013 1:52am CST
here is a dilemma .. my wife is a free thinker , no religion not spirituality , as for me , i am on the fence still although leaning more on towards christianity except i still have some issues. but mainly ,my worry is my 12 year old kid who is approaching her teens is what i am thinking about, should i introduce her to the various forms of faiths or religions now at the age she is at or should i just leave it alone till she is old enough to choose for herself?
I have just started to bring her to church with me occasionally to let her see for her self, learning about Christ and God and all that..at the same time, other members of my family , my sis and bro are buddhist, so she also has seen some aspects of that faith.at home we have no altar nor cross nor anything.i am of the thought that a spiritual life started early helps to build or shape character. but just thinking whether if 12 is too young or just the right age to learn about the stuff.
1 person likes this
13 responses
@urbandekay (18278)
•
3 Apr 13
The right age is when she starts asking about such or shows an interest
all the best, urban
1 person likes this
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
she already started that phase of curiousity few years back, and i tried to share to the best of my ability based on what i know about God and religion which isn't much but i am familiar with bible stories, Adam and Eve and King Solomon or David etc.which i somehow managed to spin into short bedtime stories but now she is slightly older and probably wants to know deeper about the stories i spun.
@eileenleyva (27560)
• Philippines
18 Apr 13
bryanwmc, it is parent's duty to rear a child the best way he deems it, including guiding the child spiritually. Christianity, as you might have assessed now, tells us that we are God's children, and though our good God had given us the free will, He wants us to love Him in our lives, and love our neighbors. Tell that to you daughter and she will never go wrong.
1 person likes this
@raynejasper (2322)
• Philippines
3 Apr 13
hi. My dad started to bring me to church when I was 4 so I think that 12 is not really too early. It's fine because your kid is starting to understand things. Maybe, for now, you can just let her tag along with you and you can also let her go with your bro or sis. This way, as your kid grow older, she will be able to analyze and realize which faith does she really want to join. In my opinion, a child does not necessarily follow the parents' religion. It will depend upon which faith can she associate herself and which faith can she feel fulfilled and satisfied. Maybe, there are parents who would disagree with me on this, but anyway, this is just how I perceive things because I'd rather let my child choose the religion where her faith could grow stronger.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
it is what i m trying to do actually, exposing her to the faiths and trying
to explain to her what faith is about whenever she asks.i live in a country where multi faith is the norm . main national religion being 50% muslims and the rest are christians , hindus , taoist and few more.
i m of the view that to believe or not to believe is their own choice but at least know what it is and then decide.ignorance leads to resentment.
@raynejasper (2322)
• Philippines
5 Apr 13
right. We as parents will just guide them but we should not really impose on them. They have the freedom to chose where they want to belong. What's important is their personal relationship to God.
@bostonphil (4459)
• United States
3 Apr 13
Religion is such a complicated, but very interesting, subject. Since you lean towards Christianity, I think it might be best to introduce your daughter to Christianity while allowing her to learn about other faiths. That way, she will, hopefully, grow up tolerant and understanding of those who observe and believe differently. Your siblings could introduce her to Buddhism. You might also take her to various houses of worship. How about a different church every week or two? It sounds like you and her mother will be comfortable if and when she chooses a faith, if she ever does. Nothing says that we have to be one religion or any religion all our lives.
Most parents and grandparents who observe raise their children and grandchildren in their faith since babies. I think 12 might be considered older to begin religious education. But, one can learn about religion or spirituality at any age.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
my confession is that ,personally i have been going around from few churches seeking one i am comfortable with and i seem to have settled on one.which speaks to me and that i can relate to in their appoach to spreading the gospel, not too much imposing but subtle and gentle , so i brought my kid with me to the services for her age group in that particular church and she seem to like it .making new friends and learning about christianity, what it is about before anything, understanding is the key to Faith.
1 person likes this
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
tecnically the national religion is Islam with 50% of the population being muslims, the rest of us are free to choose our religion or no religion. there is no imposition or curtailment of religious freedom on the rest of us 40% non muslims. so it is quite diverse, you will see Mosques , Hindu temples and Chinese Taoism and Buddhist temples and Christian churches,Catholic and Protestant of all denominations although sometimes there is friction but like sibling quarrels, things very soon go back to normal.recently i settled on a methodist church and been attending weekly sermons, like it because they besides focusing on gospel also do a lot trying to raise awareness of social issues that affect us in the country.
@bostonphil (4459)
• United States
4 Apr 13
So you have been seeking and now you have found yourself a church home. What church have you settled on?
I see that you live in Malaysia. What religion is predominant in your country? Is it Islam?
@spicymary (558)
• Romania
10 Apr 13
Your daughter has the right age to learn about religions, as a subject of general knowledge. I think it's good for her to be introduced to all, as an observer, and have some solid information about.
But regarding the faith matter, it is just... strange for me this process. I hardly believe kids would choose a religion to follow on their own, when they know all options are correct. It's like they would eat carrots because they know this is good for their health. I don't think that somebody that doesn't have a wider perspective of life would choose to follow a system that restricts, at least in the appearence, their freedom.
I am used to the habit that parents who have strong opinions about religion, teach the kid about their beliefs. I don't say this is good or bad, but it works, until a certain age, when the kid considers to respect the religion of their parents or choose something else. I guess that in your case, your solution is the best. But, most probably, her choice would be taken more in the future.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
11 Apr 13
i share your views, i will prefer not to impose my views and beliefs on faith and religion on my kid , but i will be more comfortable in the thought that at least she can understand what it is about,as she gets older and more curious about other faiths that is out there , it is only good that she ought to know and form an own view or belief. not just be lead or in some instances mislead as we all know the potential ugly side of what religious indoctrination can do to very young naive minds. so much of the resentment between religious faiths stem from a total lack of understanding of each other that gives rise to intolerance,hatred in extreme cases.
@dagami (1158)
• Rome, Italy
3 Apr 13
hi, bryanwmc. i grew up with my grandma who was a very devout XXXXXXX. my parents were also practicing the same religion. when i was small, i would always turn to her whenever i had questions about religion. nowadays, communication has become easier. we can turn to the internet if we want information about something. if you allow your son to navigate the internet, i'm sure he must have some ideas about the different existing religions.
it is up to you to guide him, just make sure that he doesn't become lured by some sects that have leaders who use religion for their own purposes.
i converted to another faith when i was 18 although for the family's peace i had my son baptized in my parents' religion when he was born. i made it a point to teach my son about the various religions when he was growing up, just the way my embraced faith tells us to do. he's an adult now and he's chosen his way too.
religion is personal. however much we want to, we can never impose our beliefs in our children because they too have their own minds and the freedom to choose. as parents, we just have the responsibility to guide them.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
i couldnt agree with you more, our relationship with our God is a intensely personal thing.although i have witnessed many who believe but not understand what it is they believe in. blind faith is good and all but when ignorance results in resentment or hatred , there has to be line drawn. My daughter is gradually asking me many questions about god and religion that i felt i need to expose her to the faiths to enable her to get a sense and feel of what it is about, later on to choose on her own volition what she feels to be right.
@dagami (1158)
• Rome, Italy
4 Apr 13
i made a mistake with the gender. i must have been thinking about my son when i replied to your discussion.
we are born into our religion, race, country, etc. we were never given a choice before birth. with regards to religion, it is up to us to investigate and choose which path to tread.
@jonastabuena (2307)
• Philippines
3 Apr 13
Just enough age to learn, i think that age she can already choose what she like and what to follow, its nice that bringing her to the church, your purpose is great. Where you able to talk to your daughter about religion? have you ask about her idea about religion,? I this kind of stuff is hard if a father and my wife is like your wife, and your brother and sister has different religion, there is a possibility that your daughter might be confused about religion, and about you and the people that so-rounds her, she might think why you have different religion? These is really hard.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
actually it is a learning experience for myself also, don't underestimate the minds of 12 year olds and the questions they asked, sometimes it stumps me to answer because i do not know how. but at least i want her to understand faith 1st before she decides or not to commit to believing. now it is just about exposure and she seems to like the experience in church making new friends learning about Christianity.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
it was prompted by her inquisitive mind actually when she started to enquire about God and creation and other questions that , i thought may as well let her find out for herself. so far she seems to like the experience, she attends the childrens service making new friends and learning new stuff, hence saving me a lot of brain racking to explain things i am not too good at.
@veejay19 (3589)
• India
3 Apr 13
Your 12 year old is still in the developing stage of mind and needs careful nurturing. It is good that you and your family members are exposing her to all faiths.Don't force her to follow one particular faith. She is still immature and kids her age keep changing as they grow up.Leave her to herself and she will automatically follow that faith which she is naturally drawn to or which suits her the most. She may, God forbid, even turn out to be an atheist, after seeing all the crimes that are being committed in the name of religion nowadays.
@wilsongoddard (7291)
• United States
3 Apr 13
You didn't think about all of this earlier?
She's almost a teen. She'll figure out stuff on her own and find her own path. At this point, she doesn't need for you to drag her to church. If she wants to do something or learn something, she can ask you or her mother to take her to a service of whatever stripe, make an appointment for her to talk to a religious leader, buy books, etc.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
come on..!thats not gonna work! teens r usually very rash as we know since we been there before when it comes to stuff like this, just felt that , you wanna know , go to where it is at and see for yourself.then make up your own mind basd on understanding and not just hearsay.
@jazel_juan (15746)
• Philippines
3 Apr 13
When i was a kid, i guess my parents never had this dilemma probably because both are solid Catholics, though my dad was never a church goer, my mom was really a Catholic..till now. She did enroll me in a Catholic school so iw as introduced to christianity at an early age.. went through Masses, knows all the prayers and stuff of being a Catholic.
But now i am an adult, i knew different views of Faith and Christianity, thoguh i have a baptismal certificate as a Catholic, i choose now a more simpler religion, I am joining this Christian Church that is simple yet i am at peace there...
Here comes the dilemma (sort of)for me now too, i am joining that Church and i am happy there but my husband is still Catholic.. as for the kids we do bring them to both Churches, they know about God, Jesus and the likes, They read the bible with us. Though they were baptized as Catholics as well, i want them to also realize it on their own. I found a solution to that and that is to teach them simple things about Faith, none of those hullabaloos.. lol just simple thing of Loving God, believing in Jesus.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
so true, it is not the denomination nor the religion but our very own personl relationship with God..it is all from the heart of followers, neither demanded nor infringed on us.which many supossedly learned religious scholars seem to insist upon.that their way is the right way and anything else is not
@extremefun4fun (2908)
• India
3 Apr 13
well, in my idea children can understand a lot more in their childhood, like when they are 5-9 about religion and God they can understand. it is good to let them study and think about such things and to have right of choice , it is good to teach them the base of all religion which is just humanity and being good and loving another human and helping others...
@HumanRites1 (18)
• United States
3 Apr 13
Grounding your child in the basic "golden rule" to me is the best spiritual education for when they are young. Just teach them how to treat people and teach them right from wrong. This is the basis of EVERY religion or spiritual belief.
If a child has a spiritual leaning, they will choose for themselves when they get older, regardless. But the basics of human kindness and what's right vs. wrong are found in every religion, and also among atheists and agnostics for that matter.
@bryanwmc (1051)
• Malaysia
4 Apr 13
i subscribe to your point of view although my confidence in that is not a 100%. Kids from this generation grow up much wiser than my gen.so much exposure on the TV and social media, we have to move with the time.by the time they are in their teens their own personality will show and it is the same with their mindsets , there is only so much us parents can guide them, when they start mixing around with friends from school and other places,their world view adapts as they socialize. so may as well expose her to whats available and let her make up her own mind as she gradually matures in mind and body. now i still tell her what i think is right and wrong but eventually, it will be just my opinion for her to formulate by herself and have final say.