Benefits to Parenthood
By AidaLily
@AidaLily (1450)
United States
April 17, 2013 1:17pm CST
Warning: Long post!
I was asked a strange question today from a woman at the family center who is considering having children.
The question probably isn't that strange but she asked me "What exactly are the benefits to parenthood?" and she clarified by saying 'actual benefits' as opposed to random moments of joy, frustration, etc.
I couldn't answer her after her clarification and I feel upset about it. She was looking for the benefits to being a mother, raising children in this day and age, and so on and I couldn't give her at least one true benefit in what she was asking.
Before anyone thinks I don't enjoy having my children, I really do, but she did make me think about it.
I experienced joy when I was able to hold my children for the first time but...
Due to pregnancy, I was in and out of the hospital and had really high hospital bills because of it. I could barely carry my first child and nearly lost my life and more with the second one. I can no longer have any kids. I went from healthy to unhealthy no matter how much I eat right or exercise or do mind-calming things like meditation or yoga. Stress adds to declining health and having children adds to stress because as a parent you are constantly worried about them. I couldn't tell her that the random moments of fun and joy were great benefits because my health is still affected by the stress and problems I still have after having children. I couldn't tell her to save up money or be more financially secure and things will be easier because they wont. My first savings (not the current one I've been able to work on) was completely gone because since I couldn't hold my children as much I had many many doctor's appointments to pay co-pays for on their insurance on top of that both my kids have a minor but potentially bad genetic disorder from me that takes away their ability to turn sugar into energy or process it at all. No one plans on having a premature baby, having a complicated pregnancy, etc. I could've had a great job as well as my husband having one but it wouldn't have mattered when medical bills came up like uncovered medications, hospital stays, etc. Most insurances don't cover multiple events in a year or multiple medical procedures.
I couldn't tell her that they give anything back to her because they don't and they might not ever. Every parent can hope that when their children are grown, they will be appreciative of everything they did and so on but they will also develop their own thoughts about things. Even though we raise them with values and more, they will still develop their own opinions and whether or not they apply what they are taught is up to them. With all the craziness in the world - overpopulation, murder, hoping to be safe at work, school, home, etc. but not having it guaranteed anywhere obviously, foods and medicine things that should help them causing more problems - it almost seems selfish to bring children into the world.
While I love my children, I can't think of a benefit to having them. I contributed to the overpopulation, my health is all but destroyed no matter how many different things I try to fix the problem. My mental health is effected by childhood traumas and ridiculous amounts of stress added to by constant worrying of my children. My entire savings was gone because I never fully planned on having children (though I wanted them) let alone having children early (premature) or with so many problems. I am paying nearly $200 (give or take a bit) for speech therapy sessions because my youngest son has major speech problems and I have to take him to a specialist in case he needs surgery which it isn't fully covered but I will work on that. It just seems pointless after talking with her.
All I can do is raise them, hope they remember the values they were taught at home so they don't get in trouble, hope if they move away they still come visit or I get a mother's day or birthday card once a year. I might have grandchildren one day, but it would be no different than having children other than they go back home at the end of the day.
I don't know. What do you think of her question? Do you think there are any actual benefits to having children? Do you think parents speak of being happy or having fun cute moments with their children to make themselves feel better because that is all they truly get out of it?
She told me based on the fact that no parent can truly give a good reason for it. That having children is a long-term investment with little to no reward. You carry a child for nine months or less, spend countless hours, amounts of money, lose sleep, end up stressed, and much more all for a child and you have to hope that they don't completely go on with their lives and leave you alone when they grow up.
1 person likes this
3 responses
@joizee (502)
• Philippines
18 Apr 13
Hi there! I have to commend you for your long post. But it was a good read. Good point as well. Let me share my take.
I am now a mother and I am definitely happy. I have dreamt of becoming a mother since childhood because I have seen how my grandmother and my own mother raised children. I was amused of how they can be tough and soft at the same time. How they balance all the work and still have time for the kids. And now that I am a mother, I understood that amusement I had before.
For true benefits, I may say that we mothers are responsible for population growth. That population is essential for having workforce. The workforce plays a great role in economy and progress of the country. We develop our children to became morally, mentally and physically healthy to face the "outside world", which literally translate to working. So I think that benefit doesn't directly affects us. That is how big scale being a parent can be, as for now.
I think one benefit of having children is someone can take care of you when you grew older and weaker. Perhaps it is more common here in the Philippines than other countries that we take care of your elderly than putting them to nursing homes. Like my mother, she has 5 other siblings but she's the only one who chose to take care of my grandfather. Consequently, my children will have (hopefully) that same idea when I become older because they have the exposure to that culture or custom. Aside from care, financial assistance from children is also common here in the Philippines, especially with first borns. Even though they have their own family and even though they are not required, there's a sense of helping out the family through financial assistance. And lastly, your children are the extension of your life. Your wealth, your values, personalities and even characteristics will be passed on to all those generations. That is making a legacy. It's the pride of the family. It's your pride as a parent.
Personally, I wouldn't ask for financial help or caring of my children. I already have them all my life so I choose to have some for my self and with my husband. If do wish to take me in or live with me instead, it's OK. As long as they will offer me and not me asking for them :)
Thanks for the discussion AidaLily! :)
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
19 Apr 13
I am happy being a mother but I do wish my health was a lot better so that I could do more with my children. It is disheartening to not be able to do as much for something I could have never known until I got pregnant. I knew pregnancies that were hard but no one in my family truly had any problems when pregnant and I was healthy then.
Thank you for your answer on true benefits. When I do see the woman again, I can give her that answer. When she asked, the workforce answer didn't come to mind because I was thinking on a more personal level as in benefits directly for the parent. I do think overpopulation is a problem in some areas but there also needs to be people willing to work to help out the elderly and take over jobs that older people can no longer work due to age.
Here in the USA more children are likely to put their parents in nursing homes after a while though there are some who try to take care of their children. Everyone moves so fast here in a sense that a nursing home is sometimes the only way the can fit things into their busy lifestyle. I can't say financial assistance from children for the parents once the parents are older is common here either or anything like that. A lot of people in this country have a 'What's in it for me?' mentality unfortunately. I do agree with children being an extension of your life and legacy and it was part of the reason I wanted children. I wanted to continue on my family.
I don't ask for financial help and I wouldn't ask for it from my children. My husband wants to charge them rent once they become legal and begin to work to teach them responsibility of needing to managed themselves in the "outside world" and because we wont kick them out if they miss a payment because something happened. His intention is to make it a learning experience for them. I am not sure if I agree but that is probably the part of me that doesn't want them to grow up. :)
Thank you so much for your answer. I feel a lot better knowing when I see her again I can give her an actual answer. :)
1 person likes this
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
20 Apr 13
Just have to keep trying. My youngest child is five years old, and yet I still haven't gotten my health back up. I've done everything the doctor said should work. It makes me wonder if I was one of those women who really shouldn't have had children because I couldn't physically take it. Ah well no need to worry about that. I just can't have anymore which considering I have learned that I hate potty training that is fine with me.
His idea probably will work to get them out of the house voluntarily. An older friend of mine still complains her 23 year old doesn't want to move out or work much. I am sure that if I support my husband's idea, I won't have to worry about that. LOL
1 person likes this
@joizee (502)
• Philippines
19 Apr 13
Actually, I got a bit unhealthy since I gave birth. Now I felt weaker and get hurt very easily. But I have to be mentally strong to counteract pains and now I'm taking food supplements because I feel my eating habits and the food I eat isn't enough to make me stronger.
Your husband's idea of "rent" I think can teach the children to be responsible and it might be also their reason to move out voluntarily. LOL. :)
Good luck on us parents! ;)
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
19 Apr 13
Honestly, I don't really care how difficult that your journey to becoming a parent was, I do think that there are a lot of benefits to being a parent.
The first benefit that comes to my mind is that being a parent will really teach a person what undying love is. It doesn't matter what our children do that make us angry or worse, they will never be able to do anything that will make us quit loving them. That is the reason that the saying is "The moment that a child is born, so is a mother."
Another benefit to being a parent is that when you are a parent your children will teach you a lot of things that you would never have learned otherwise.
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
19 Apr 13
No one said anything about not loving their children. It was more or less the true benefits to having them.
In retrospect, it isn't fair to the child if their parent is always stressed out and more as children can pick up on these things. If there are more bad times than good in a child's life then they pick up on that too.
Some parents can just quit loving their children. I am not one of them but they can. How else do you think children and their parents become estranged from one another to the point where either could die and the other wouldn't care?
The point of this discussion, which it seems you probably missed, was that I was asked about the TRUE benefits to parenthood with clarification to not say the "joy and happiness" things that the person asking claimed as "things to make parents feel better".
The fact of the matter is that there isn't any true benefit.
Your first stated benefit isn't true nor would it be a good answer to what I was asked. Why? Because there are some ridiculously bad parents out there that will never teach their kids what undying love is. Undying love doesn't mean they will have a good life either. It just means like I said.. they were taught to care for something other than themselves and once they 'leave the nest' you can only hope something doesn't change that view. As for the undying love a parent might learn, they already learned it before having children whether it was for a parent, grandparent, or heck even a hobby that they just LOVE doing like coming up with creative ways to brighten up the days of sick people. There are people who have undying loves for their careers.
The second stated benefit isn't one either. I can't say that having children has taught me anything I haven't or wouldn't have learned otherwise. If I would have given that woman this answer, I wouldn't be able to clarify. I guess if someone has an easy time with everything and lived a very sheltered life, never had a pet or something then parenthood teaches them a lot. All the basic household chores, managing important things, care for someone other than yourself can be learned with a partner and a pet. Ideological things like love, etc are usually learned if you have the environment to learn it in while you are a child.
So her question was "What TRUE/REAL benefits are there to being a parent?" In that instance, there is no benefit.
As for that saying, it isn't true either.
The moment that a child is born:
-so is a mother OR
-so is that person birthing the child's second chance OR
-so is that parent's meal ticket OR
-so is that new punching bag OR
-so is a parent being trapped in a bad relationship OR
-so is another child going to an orphanage, ETC.
Everyone is different. Such as saying could never account for the majority of parents in the world or their situations.
I might be a mother but I am no where near as idealistic as to believe that every child grows up in the best possible situation and that every child grows up a productive member of society who never does any wrong. I don't have the naivete to believe that all children will take all the good they learned from home and always apply it to their life. I can hope my children can but there is always a chance they wont.
If you have children, you can only hope they don't grow up and meet someone whom they marry and when you are older that person wants to put you in a home or they move far away and you are nothing more than an after thought. A good home life doesn't make that so either since they are now leading their own lives.
On top of rising crime rates, overpopulation, and much more, I do think it is a bit selfish to bring a child into the world currently. It is like you are trying to do this all and you want a child who cares if they have to grow up in this world like this? At least you got your baby.
My journey to becoming a parent wasn't added to this discussion to do anything more than explain why I couldn't give her an answer because what answer could I give but the most logical truthful one which was no. I've never been in the business of lying to myself to make me feel better. As I told her afterwards, I love my children. I am happy to have my children BUT there is no true benefit to being a parent.
@GMont1210 (96)
• Philippines
20 Apr 13
Hello guyz, just to add, another benefit of being a parent is that we are given the chance to participate in God's work. we parents are actually God's sent angels for our kids. we actually have all the opportunity of receiving more of God's blessings because we carry the responsibility of bringing our kids closer to God. So long as we are able to Shepherd our kids to weave the right direction, we are rewarded with more points in God's kingdom. :)
@crossbones27 (49703)
• Mojave, California
23 Apr 13
I do not know about gods work but you do have the chance of shaping society. I do not know much but that is probably pretty powerful in the scheme of things. I just wish more parents would realize it. I do not have kids so take it with a grain of salt.
@profmuhammadakhtar (103)
• Pakistan
18 Apr 13
this is too strange thing she asked that benefit of parenthood its is you now that when a mother do some work or pregnant hher happyness cannot be countable in true if every one considering the benefit of each social work will be foolish choice what is meaning of sympathy why we follow good thing because we feel happy so if u need a happy life and wishes to enjoining life never considering return
@AidaLily (1450)
• United States
19 Apr 13
I think she wanted an answer to the question "What is the point of having them?" but with a more real world answer than she feels most parents give.
I agree that a happy life shouldn't be based on what you can do and get a return on especially when it comes to having children. I think any parent would be put on the spot with that answer and have to think about what she was really asking before they answered. I could've easily said "oh they bring me joy and laughter" or "I love knowing I am teaching them values to go out into the world" but she didn't want a superficial answer.
Those answers are only superficial because pretty much every parent will say them unless they don't want their kids.
However, to truly dig deeper into that and look at the big picture, there is no true benefit to having children overall.