A Serious Question About Religion
By robspeakman
@robspeakman (1700)
June 9, 2013 1:53pm CST
A Serious Question About Religion
Let me start by saying that I am an Atheist, but this is not a post to criticise your faith…. It is a genuine question.
The question came to me after watching the growing unrest in Turkey. Turkey has become known as a moderate Islamic country. Secularists and people of other faiths have always been able to live and move freely.
The protests and unrest started when the Turkish government wanted to clear a park for future development. The protest quickly became a reaction to increasing stricter Islamic doctrine, tighter rules on alcohol, abortion and contraception.
So here is my question.
Is it right to impose a religious ideology on others?
It is wrong to expect a secular person to give up alcohol based on a religious belief that they do not have.
Can we force a person not to use contraception because of another one’s faith?
And regardless of your personal view on abortion, is it right to deny it as a valid medical procedure based on the belief of others.
It would be wrong for a secular country to ban religion and impose Atheist thinking on a nation.
Surely it means more to a faith or a God if the followers embrace the ideology voluntarily?
Let me ask the ones of faith something. Does your belief and faith led lifestyle mean more to you because that is your choice?
Would you be happy if a neighbour was forced to live your lifestyle by governmental decree?
This is not just aimed at Islam, Christianity is also used by others to control society
4 people like this
8 responses
@mike05 (156)
•
13 Jun 13
@robspeakman
because their economy is terrible...not much above Bulgaria.
because they have terrible human rights issues.
there are loads of reasons.
They certainly won't be net contributors.
Check this out....the reason why we should NOT be in Europe.
British Broadcasting CorporationHome Accessibility links BBC News Updated every minute of every day One-Minute World News News Front Page Africa Americas Asia-Pacific Europe Middle East South Asia UK Business Health Science & Environment Technology Enterta
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
10 Jun 13
No, it is not right to impose any religious ideology on anyone, but there's nothing wrong with trying to convince others of your position.
Unless a person is persuaded to abandon their worldly habits, it's a waste of time to expect that they will give up what they enjoy.
If you have to use force, you don't have a good argument for your position which probably means what you're promoting has no value to it.
I'm realistic enough to know that unless we change the hearts of people, abortions are here to stay. However, I don't understand how anyone could even think of doing that to the most innocent among us, not even if the mother's life is threatened. No doctor can guarantee that the mother is going to die if she does not abort her baby.
The beauty of Christianity is that we are not bound to a written law. Instead we are guided by God's Holy Spirit speaking to our spirit. Here's hoping we pay attention.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
25 Jun 13
@mike05 True Christianity is not a religion. It's a faith in Jesus Christ and what He did for us on the cross. We have been made righteous and our sins have been forgive as far as the east is from the west. Religion is a return to bondage. With Christianity the believer is not bound to any written religious law, rather God writes His law on our hearts. Unfortunately, religion has infiltrated the movement and too many don't realize the freedom they have in Jesus Christ. If preachers and teachers of Christianity truly knew and preached the truth of the New Covenant, everyone would want to be Christians.
@robspeakman (1700)
•
25 Jun 13
@6precious102 - You miss the point completely - I thought I would not have to write - PLEASE DO NOT PREACH - IT OFFENDS OTHERS
@buenavida (9984)
• Sweden
10 Jun 13
No human being has the right to force anyone to choose their religion - According to the Bible, God wants people who search him from free will and love to the truth. That is the true Christian view of it.
I like to go to the jw.org site and read articles about how we benefit from following the advice from the Bible, but everyone can choose to follow the advice or not. We all have a free will!!
@madhualan (1)
• Chennai, India
11 Jun 13
yes ,i accept bunavida ,and one thing the truth is NATURE IS GOD but we people are seeing them in different views..
@buenavida (9984)
• Sweden
11 Jun 13
@madhualan Thank you for expressing your opinion and view of life - for me the nature is proof that there is an intelligent and loving Designer behind all the wonders we see in the nature..
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
22 Jul 13
Turkey (using your example) is not ready to join Europe. The have no open mind, they want to go back in time about 100 years or more. They (government) want to break down the churches in Istanbul for example and do not care about the opinion of others. This shows enough that there is no freedom of opinion, speach, etc. The fact so many turkish people are furious (plus breaking down the country) doesn't care them either. Since I like to make up my own mind and want my children to do so as well, I want others to make up their own mind plus live their own lives as well. Pity enough most people are not able too. Mostly because they are brainwashed by parents, schools, states, etc. I would leave a country like that and surely not turn into the islam and let any man tell me how to behave, dress, what to believe. I agree that christianity (Catholics for example) also abuse people and control the society (how come the Pope is free to say what he wants?). To my opinion believe has nothing to do with a church or churchleader. Those who do sit in church are no better believers as the ones who stay at home. I was raised very religious but I do not believe and I always had doubts. The only thing that is clear to me is that most people need something to believe in, they need it to belong to a club so they feel safer.
At this moment I can only say that there is hard to see/find a normal muslim. Someone who is practising his believe in his private life. Since this is how a believe should be. It's something private, something you need for yourself. I also wonder why so many people are forced into it. If you are such a strong believer about your own religion, your own god, you should be happy each day, shining each day and know (have the faith) everything will be alright/fine. There is no need to press others into it or kill in the name of your god.
@shivedi1 (24)
• Jabalpur, India
12 Jun 13
Religion is not something to be believed in, but something to be lived, something to be experienced...not a belief in your mind but the flavor of your whole being. In the name of religion, in the name of morality, in the name of nationality,
people are torturing each other, killing each other. Beautiful names have been found for very pathological, insane things. Insanities are called 'nationalities.' Insanities are called 'moralities.' Beautiful labels on very ugly things.
@pollbusy (34)
• Canada
12 Jun 13
No, it would mean nothing if the government had to force any faith for that matter. Secondly, a person's belief in God should be a personal confession and not an assumption of something heard or being forced into.
When a person decides or recognize their supreme being based on personl experience then then their decision to be true to the God of heaven and earth is a personal decision. Furthermore, not even God force anyone to accept, its a free decision.
@changjiangzhibin89 (16763)
• China
11 Jun 13
It doesn't make sense to force people to adopt a religion.Here respecting and protecting freedom of religion is one of our basic policies.I am an athiest too,but my mother,who is in her 90s,is a convinced Christian.
@Rick1950 (1576)
• Lima, Peru
12 Jun 13
Well, I don't know enough about Islam and its norms. In my opinion religion is the way to lead us to God. Believers have always built communities since ancient time. These communities needs to have an order and discipline, thus they have created certain rules of behaviour for themselves. The Church have its rules, despite its members who have broken them. I think the choice to be part of a religious community is free, and if you become a member you must be able to follow those rules.