Is nagging children to do their own work good or bad?

By vids
@vhpsandi (358)
Mumbai, India
March 29, 2016 12:40pm CST
My kids are now big, but I still have to keep on reminding them to do their own work. I wonder is this become a habit with them, i.e. since they were small kids I had to keep reminding them and I did not stop. So either there is something wrong with this whole policy of nagging, or they are lazy. would it have been better to let them be? and do their work as and when they pleased. This is one parenting sector where I dont know what went wrong where. I just want to know what is right so maybe my daughter or daughter in law could be guided. OH MY GOD, is this a carry over of my obsession?
5 people like this
6 responses
@Daljinder (23236)
• Bangalore, India
29 Mar 16
I would suggest to set up a routine. Since the new session is going to start in April, you should start implementing that routine from the beginning. Make sure they get their play time as well as T. V. time in the day's activities.
2 people like this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
29 Mar 16
But my kids are already big. That is why I am concerned. One is 22, other is 19.
2 people like this
@Daljinder (23236)
• Bangalore, India
29 Mar 16
@vhpsandi Then they need to be responsible on their own. They are adults. Nagging surely would irritate them. Just tell them what you expect from them regarding their scores in exams and leave it at that. If they are working then let them be unless there is risk of losing a job due to their laziness, etc...
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
9 Apr 16
@Daljinder Sometimes I feel the fault is with me, and not them. Maybe if I leave them alone things would be done, I guess should exercise a little patience and a have a little faith in them.
1 person likes this
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
29 Mar 16
Kids need guidance for sure so it is a must to remind and guide them all the time. But I don't resort to nagging because it could annoy and distract their disposition. I always want to be gentle with them because I find it more effective.
2 people like this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
9 Apr 16
You are right being gentle works better, but I guess I need to train myself first /
1 person likes this
@kaka135 (14931)
• Malaysia
2 Apr 16
I personally do not like to be nagged at all since I was a child. My mom liked to nag. Now I have become a mom, and I understand why mothers want to nag, well, not that they like to, but sometimes it seems like it's needed. I still try not to nag, as I really don't like nagging. I believe there is better way other than nagging. I have read that nagging actually becomes a habit, even to the children. They might not do things on their own independently, as they are "waiting" for the mom to nag them, many times, then they will take action. It might not be good for both parents and children. I usually tell my children a few times to do something, I know one time might not be enough, but I'd try to tell them at most 3 times. If not, then I'll just have to apply the consequences we have talked about before this. I think this works better for me and my children. Especially when you mentioned your kids are now big, I think they should be responsible on their own without having you to remind or nag. Well, this is just my own opinion, I guess it's based on my childhood experience, hence I don't like nagging at all. If you are interested, you can just search for "how to stop nagging", there are many advice online that you may take a look at them.
@kaka135 (14931)
• Malaysia
9 Apr 16
@vhpsandi Sorry that you were separated from your parents and sent to another country. I guess some of our parenting styles were influenced by how our parents treated us. Some choose to follow the parents', some choose to use different methods. There are something I knew I wouldn't want to follow my parents even when I was young. They are good parents, but there are just something (or many things) I don't agree with them. I do not purposely choose the different path, I just go with the path I like to walk. Same in parenting. I always like to read about parenting online or offline, but I don't listen to all the experts, I choose those I can resonate with.
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
9 Apr 16
@kaka135 I see what you say. There are so many times that my daughter says 'when I have a kid I won't do what you did with me' and this can be in reference to a varied subjects. So I guess we all follow the basics and the rest is customised
1 person likes this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
2 Apr 16
It's so funny now that you mentioned you were nagged as kid, and hence don't want to do it to your kids. I on the other hand got separated form my parents and sent to a different country ( can take this up later) and had no one to really tell me what to do, I did what I had to and most of times got in trouble because of lack of experience. Guess I am doing the reverse here. But I like the idea of facing consequences of ones action or inaction. thanks Lee Ka.
1 person likes this
@cherriefic (10399)
• Philippines
29 Mar 16
I guess the nagging is a reminder for them that they will still hear even if you are not around. They prefer to hear you say the words before doing anything.
@cherriefic (10399)
• Philippines
29 Mar 16
@vhpsandi They will know what to do. Don't worry.
1 person likes this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
9 Apr 16
@cherriefic thanks.
1 person likes this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
29 Mar 16
yes, maybe I should go on a long vacation.
• United States
30 Mar 16
sadly, 'tis a learnt behavior 'n only one they can break. i ne'er nagged mine when they were young'uns growin' up, but they knew the consequences if'n they didn't tend to their responsibilities. no room fer arguments nor excuses.
1 person likes this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
9 Apr 16
Okay, so you have a set of rules in place and they know the consequences of obey or disobey.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Apr 16
@vhpsandi yes ma'am.
@cacay1 (83505)
• Cagayan De Oro, Philippines
30 Mar 16
Your kids though big now seem independent on you.Better give them way to stand by their own.That also means that you are a loving, caring and over protective parent only few has this kind of treatment to children, that bis why many youths gone astray.
1 person likes this
@vhpsandi (358)
• Mumbai, India
9 Apr 16
So you mean they are going to get worse? God help me!