My solution to racism...
By vanny
@vandana7 (100282)
India
September 24, 2016 1:24pm CST
I think weirdly..this is not to offend anybody ...just some thinking
I think it is difficult to monitor thinking. It is difficult to put it in groove saying this is right and that is wrong. If it were possible there would be no rapes, no murders, no crimes...everybody knows they are wrong and still they do it...because it is difficult to monitor even with laws.
Given such a situation, it is I feel Utopian to think that people will not observe color of skin and looks and they will ever be civilized enough to leave that behind. Some may not all. Most will suppress it adequately for their day to day living but feelings will surface when they are wronged by another race. So that film of civility will fall apart in most cases.
I am only being realistic and pragmatic. We can't expect 90 percent of the population to conform to standards of 10 percent, even if those values are signs of society evolving.
Given such a situation, would you be ok with genetic manipulation of genes that govern features that distinguish you from a desirable race?
I would be ok. I mean if I am ok with wearing lipsticks, and I am ok with using creams for better skin, and even straightening my hair, or using fairness creams, or anti aging creams, changing color of my hair, I see nothing wrong with genetic manipulation, especially if we have allowed science to help us with artificial insemination and surrogacy.
Effectively, I am asking research be oriented towards identification of genes that govern characteristics of races, and once that is done change the same gene IF THE PARENTS SO DESIRE in the next generations. That way the problem of racial discrimination would be out for good.
But give science some time please!
17 people like this
21 responses
@skysnap (20153)
•
24 Sep 16
My solution : let evolution do it's work. Let people suffer and then let nature find it's way ;)
200 years back black were treated badly.. now they won't be much any more.
Ever since mughals invaded asia and other places women were given backseat, but not anymore...
so it all comes down to evolution.. we just have to adapt to it..
sometimes not finding solution is the best solution :p
6 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
24 Sep 16
Then we should not have let artificial insemination and surrogacy arrive as well, nor blood transfusions and stem cells retention for developing any organ for child in case it is needed in future. Do you know at times mothers conceive so that they can harvest organ of the unborn baby for the child that is already born but suffering? If that is ok, this suggestion, which has no life being lost, is almost innocuous.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
24 Sep 16
@skysnap .. As long as people have eyes, being civil about skin color is not likely...they may as I mentioned be civil when it is necessary for their purposes, or they have no problem with it. But the moment somebody from different skin color troubles them, those prejudices which are hidden somewhere inside raise their heads like demons. We might as well make light of skin color differences by genetic manipulations and other genetic creams which can improve our skin colors.
2 people like this
@skysnap (20153)
•
24 Sep 16
@vandana7 those discoveries were needed because during the crisis like say nuclear war etc. those discoveries can save humanity from extinction.. so we can't let evolution play it's card there. we got intelligence to save us from that scenario .. sometimes we have to interfere and sometimes we don't ;)
3 people like this
@topffer (42156)
• France
24 Sep 16
I am not against genetic manipulation when it comes to eradicate a decease, but here I do not really understand you : you want to make parents decide if their child will be black, white or yellow ? Or together black, white and yellow ? As I am French might I ask for a green frog skin for my children?
4 people like this
@moirai (2853)
• Philippines
24 Sep 16
No. Genetic manipulation is going a bit too far for me.
Makeup is cosmetic, temporary. Wash it off and you are you again without all the paint.
Genetic manipulation is changing you, but who makes the decision? Your parents? Someone else?
As you say, it is very, very difficult for acceptance. But that is what's needed. Acceptance that we are different from each other, accept our differences, accept those different from us. It is difficult, I repeat. But acceptance is changing yourself, and who makes the decision? You yourself.
4 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
@TheHorse .. Learning Pony is now documented and in electronic mode. Surely for that we cannot compel others to remain in the color of skin they are not comfortable with. If they were comfortable with it, why Michael Jackson would resort to that kind of plastic surgery?
And while we are discussing this, such things may not be what has occurred to me alone. Black researchers may well be working towards it, and trying to change those genes so that blending becomes easier. Whether it gets blessings of law or not, is a different issue. It cannot be stopped once we know how to manipulate genes I think.
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (471508)
• Switzerland
25 Sep 16
No, this is not the right way to eradicate racism. The only way is education. People must learn to respect the others, no matter the color of the skin, but even physical problems. What we are doing to do for those who are handicapped? Kill them as they did in the ancient Greece?
3 people like this
@LadyDuck (471508)
• Switzerland
25 Sep 16
@vandana7 The fact to be "similar" outside will not make us "similar" inside. We still will think differently. Do you want an example? In Italy we are all white, same race, no physical differences. Well, there are northern and southern, we think differently. Do you believe we go well together because we look the same? Wrong, we do not go well together and many would like that Italy would have never been "united".
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
@LadyDuck ... I am learning... no ...thinking inside would continue to differ. But hey, it is like moving with others would become more easier. Earlier may be they would hesitate. But now, they can go to the same churches, and same places for playing games kinda.
2 people like this
@msiduri (5687)
• United States
24 Sep 16
Human beings being what we are, racism isn't about skin color or eye color hair color. It's about the ability to exclude a group. If you take away skin color, we'll find another excuse. I think it far better to treat the root cause of the disease than the symptoms.
Especially when, in treating the "symptoms" you're telling people that the features they would have been born with weren't good enough and had to be changed.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
24 Sep 16
@msiduri ... Don't I know that...we are differentiated based on money we have, or caste...within same religion and same race...lol. But once the skin color differentiation is removed by science, I think people would start to think about the way they differentiate and whether it makes sense at all...I am of course only hoping...but it is worth a try ...
1 person likes this
@rusty2rusty (6763)
• Defiance, Ohio
25 Sep 16
I am against gene manipulation of any type. There is no way I could change the color of my childs skin to a different color and being to explain it without feeding in to the racism. All races have issues. Changing skin won't make it go away. As there will alwasy be someone who is not happy with their or others skin color. All we can do is teach our children and grandchildren better.
3 people like this
@hora_fugit (5862)
• India
24 Sep 16
People have baggage. So they will get offended nonetheless....
As long as it remains a choice, I can sit back and watch. Commenting would be too early.
2 people like this
@hora_fugit (5862)
• India
25 Sep 16
@vandana7 I was writing the story down when my PC became unresponsive and then crashed! Maybe I should not deal with sci-fi....
A gentle touch made her open her eyes. He was sitting beside her, sporting a wide grin.
"How are you feeling now, dear? Just have a look!" - He showed the bundle in his arms.
"My.... our baby!" - And in a moment she was all energized again. Getting up, she demanded him to surrender that little bundle. And he meekly obliged.
[Some motherly emotions follow] and then she noticed it...
"Why is he looking a bit green? Is it.... (oh no, what could be wrong!?)"
"No, no. Don't panic! He is alright. He is... alright. It's just a minor side effect of the experi...."
"Experiments? You did EXPERIMENTS on him? He is just born! How could you even do it?"
She just could not believe it. Given, he was a scientist and scientists are prone to eccentricity... but to subject your own child to this, and that too within hours the kid was born!
He started in defensive tone... "No, I didn't take him to perform any such things. It had been going on all through your pregnancy. Remember the medicines which made you feel strange? Those were..."
She was not really listening. While the child giggled in her arms, mistaking her gaze to be that of undivided attention, her mind was lost in thoughts. All those events, her doubts, everything... flashing before her eyes.
And then that stance too was broken suddenly. She could sense the eeriness...
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
@hora_fugit .. Masterpiece.
@TheHorse what am I to say to this kiddo..lol. He is also from your camp. I don't even have to call DE ...I know he will always be anti vanny...if only there was one person who would see some merit in my reasoning..lol
Anyway...the thought has come, and it was shared...it does not have to be accepted.
1 person likes this
@IreneVincent (15962)
• United States
24 Sep 16
Oh my goodness! I have NEVER thought about genetic manipulation in order to "CURE" racism. First of all, who is going to decide which "racial" features are the MOST desirable?
I think people of ALL cultures are beautiful. And I say "cultures" because to me, there is only ONE race, the HUMAN race.
People in different cultures have different ideas about what makes a person beautiful. In some cultures, for instance, stretching the neck to the extreme, is considered to be attractive. OR in another culture BIG NOSES are considered to be beautiful. Some men like thin women and some like plump women. Some men like really plump women. And some prefer women with blond hair or model figures.
Beauty comes from the inside of a person for the most part. The old saying: "Beauty is only skin deep." holds true. A person could be beautiful or handsome on the outside, but could be cruel and selfish and UGLY on the inside.,
As a person who reads the Bible, I follow what Jesus taught us to love all sorts of people. There is NO "race" or culture that is better than another. All persons who love God and live by HIS standards are beautiful in God's eyes, no matter what color their skin is or what they look like on the outside. Jesus showed love to ALL people when he was on earth.
What does the religion you follow teach about loving your fellow man?
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
24 Sep 16
God sent only one couple down to earth. They had only one skin color. Their kids could have only one set of skin color. But as things stand...we have different races...I am not bringing religion here...sorry...it is nothing to do with religion at all..
It is to do with practical aspect. What should be, you are right and so is religion. What it is not ...that is reality. We can choose to say it should be like this...but prejudices will periodically surface and ruin the grounds that we had already covered.
But if we find a way that skin color could be changed just like hair color, why not? I mean, why can't we treat it just like any other cosmetic treatment? Parents would take a call I suppose...agreed all characteristics of all races are good in someway or another...but most would prefer to be fair. That is why there are fairness creams, and not darkness creams. Let us face it, that is the truth. If we look truth straight in eyes, we would have better chance of acknowledging other related factors, and moving ahead. Parents get to decide what their child would look like.
3 people like this
@IreneVincent (15962)
• United States
24 Sep 16
@vandana7 You said: "most would prefer to be fair." I disagree. My skin is VERY fair and I don't like it at all. I burn in the sun in just a few minutes. Thousands of people lay out in the sun and go to tanning beds to get darker skin. I think dark skin is better than fair skin.
As for the first man and woman, you said, that "God sent only one couple down to earth and they had only one skin color." Where do you think they were sent from? You may not want to bring in religion and neither do I but the Bible says that God created man from the dust of the earth. And he created woman from man's rib. God didn't send them from anywhere, according to what the Bible says.
In addition to that, how do you know that they were the same skin color. The fact is that humans have melanin as part of their genetic makeup and that is what determines our skin color.
The first man may have been dark skinned and the first woman may have been fair skinned. We really don't know. But, their offspring could be any color of skin.
Just like now, when a dark-skinned person, say with brown eyes, produces a child with a fair-skinned person with blue eyes. That offspring could have any number of skin tones and eye color.
Personally, I think the offspring from this combination are very beautiful. Exceptionally so.
3 people like this
@TheHorse (218846)
• Walnut Creek, California
24 Sep 16
It wouldn't work. In our country (the US) what distinguishes some minorities here is the way some of them dress, act, and talk. It's not the color of their skin or facial features. Remember that Irish, Italians, and Jews were once mightily discriminated against here, and most of them could "pass for white."
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
Pony in the past everything including racial discrimination and hatred moved slowly. Now, grouping can be faster, and false propaganda is more difficult to monitor..given such a thing if we can bring down one barrier, we can focus on other factors more easily as there will be fewer accusations of racial discrimination based on skin color. It is just one aspect of racial discrimination that will disappear. I am not saying racial discrimination will disappear in its entirety.
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26681)
• Singapore
25 Sep 16
My take is younger generation is already having a different take on racism experiencing the negative side connected with it.
Genetic manipulation of genes maybe a far stretch and better to understand its consequences.
That could prove worse than the issue of racism.
My view is religious intolerance is worse than racism with some becoming rabid with fanaticism - siva
2 people like this
@Daljinder (23236)
• Bangalore, India
24 Sep 16
Humans will still find a way to differentiate and discriminate. In this case, pure breed and impure breed might surface. If we are talking about genetic manipulation then maybe do something with genes that control brain cells?
2 people like this
@Loverabbit (3401)
• Karachi, Pakistan
25 Sep 16
I was lately thinking about why you had to type race but yes you can try to give a solution always. I just don't get the point there if you eventually change your race wjat good may come yes you become like one of those who you want to be but would that satisfy, no! Only that would bring is complications maybe nature is better the way it is indeed you can't better govern the world then how it is created. Our efforts to change might push others to change their race too. For instance if you had a guy and he was from a diff race you wanted to please him and you accomplish that with your science but then what? Would the society that is racist would feel cool once you change I don't buy that for those who are to quarrel/ argue/ interfere will always be the same no matter how much you adapt yourself but surely you could give a try
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
@Loverabbit .. No complexion itself is not a curse at all. I refuse to believe it to be a curse. My neighbor is a tad darker than me, and stunner as far as beauty is concerned. Chiselled features. But then, not everybody is blessed with that kind of beauty.
Turning into one of them, we already do that, wittingly or unwittingly. Change is nature's mandate. We have no control on that.
Would there be discrimination based on color of the skin and race at the time of giving job? I think there will be. Simple statement. People do take a call based on what appeals to their eyes.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
I can't possibly change for a guy from another race...I was mentioning in terms of children. lol. Society will remain racist...as Pony (TheHorse) has pointed out.
The reason for racism are different.
You have say 100 bucks, and 100 people. Everybody gets 1 rupee...
But if you have 100 bucks and 120 people, you may want to marginalize some so that they don't get their full share, while you get more...that is human nature...has nothing to do with you being mean or others being stupid.
So differences such as caste, race, religion, whatever come because of that need to make ourselves secure.
Pony also mentioned that customs and other traditions differentiate folks. True. But people adapt more easily when they feel they belong to the group.
It is insecurity that makes people cling to customs and traditions which are past their use by date sort of. They feel safer with those, and feel others who follow those customs will be around to protect them, and collectively they would be formidable force. So it is pretty much like Mario Puzo's The Godfather system..
If color of skin barrier was removed, moving from one community to another would become easier. Then learning what they do in a particular situation comes about. Thereafter, selection of which of the two systems is better. Take for example conventional commodes and westernized commodes. Merely two decades ago, everybody was using conventional ones here, and only high class homes had modern ones. Now no home has traditional ones. lol. Reason? MNCs.
So exchange of systems and customs becomes easier if we feel we belong to the group. Some of our customs may be better, and they may shed their customs to adopt ours too. :) The point is...break the ice..
1 person likes this
@Loverabbit (3401)
• Karachi, Pakistan
25 Sep 16
@vandana7 ahaa thats a good say so basically your point is to let kids feel secure in and what they indulge with yes that is a good idea but tell me this thing if you have a custom that is fairly better and you are so into adaptation for you believe the new ways are far better maybe you might loose some values that you have already plus I don't think it could make everyone same but if you refer to better comfort only then maybe yes you have a point but again why would anyone choose a custom that you yourself can't value.
Complexion itself is not a curse but what we have made it now has turned people more racist, take news as eg, if the reporter reports something as positive no one pays an ear but if that is reported with exaggeration and negatively it catches more eyes, same goes for racism those who are racist do not care if you belong to a particular tribe or cast only that they need is an argument to show they do better off and that is cause they believe they are superior. If you turn yourself as one of them no good is to flow for everyone be same and no one would be Willing to change their complexion from what is superior to inferior for obviously everyone wants a better of
1 person likes this
@Drosophila (16571)
• Ireland
25 Sep 16
I don't think we should genetically manipulate any human's really.. the line gets blurred otherwise. the attempt in this direction gave rise to eugenics, which formed the foundation of second world war..
so no..
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
What makes you think it is not happening already, and what makes you think we cannot make good use of it. There are many diseases that are inherited. May be if we understand it better, we could cure them. Medicines will soon be based on genetic codes so I am not suggesting something that is rather far fetched. Right?
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
@Drosophila .. Can nothing be done surreptitiously?
1 person likes this
@Drosophila (16571)
• Ireland
25 Sep 16
@vandana7 because I continue to have work in that area, and I know all projects are approved and reviewed by the genetics ethical committee.
remember some of most hideous crimes are committed in the name of "good intentions" or "righteousness". or "doing good". Recent terrorist attacks is a good example of that.
1 person likes this
@akalinus (43196)
• United States
25 Sep 16
I am against genetic manipulation unless it is to wipe out genetic diseases like ALS, muscular dystrophy and other horrible conditions.
. Read "Brave New World" by Aldous Huxley. It is a horrific look at what could happen with manipulation in the future. It is scary.
1 person likes this
@cacay1 (83495)
• Cagayan De Oro, Philippines
25 Sep 16
Racial discrimination is synonymous to bullying.It's hard to stop this long ago and now problem on racial discrimination.
@anya12adwi (9388)
• India
25 Sep 16
but mommie, don't you think, manipulating genes and straightening your hairs or applying lipstick is two different things and totally uncorrelated..???
1 person likes this
@radhruv (135)
• New Delhi, India
25 Sep 16
I don't think science can help to eradicate racism. Genetic manipulation can change outwardly but how can one change the nature of a person. For this the people should be educated so that they respect others irrespective of the skin or gender.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100282)
• India
25 Sep 16
@radhruv .."same skinned people get along well with each other" ...you said it...my theory is, if they have an opportunity to mingle with others, they will and larger group will get along well with each other kind. No...customs are not made to differentiate different people. They arise as a solution to a problem at particular time. They need to be deserted as soon as the problem is overcome, but they are continued in the name of tradition.
@nidhiS1997 (609)
• India
25 Sep 16
Mam ! I think the upper caste is facing racism in present era .. Am saying this because of the reservation system of India ..
1 person likes this