Do you think Gandhi Got India Independence?

I think Gandhi great act made india independence , i think he is india hero yea

Gandhi was the person who became famous as he was doing something that was totally opposite what the other people were doing that time their are several other people who started with the strugle so according to him he was not the only one! thats my side of thinking

well he had played major role! but i will not say he was the only

Nor Gandhi for India and Quaid-e-Azam for Pakistan got independence, it is bcz of Hitlar's world war II that we got independence.....Hitlar is the man behind our both India and Pakistan independence........Hitlar tuje salam!.......Otherwise they would rule more 100 years......

Yes ! Gandhiji having the qualities like truthfulness, faith , non-violence are the basic weapons of gandhi. With these tools, he himself fight for independence from the britishers. He succeeded in his object. Whenever he faces problems in daily life, he referred the holy book "The Bhagadgita" , Wherever he finds the page, he got solution to the problem. He having good basics of Hinduism. He leads systematic, simple life. He does not wear even shirt, simply covers his body with doti. With these extraordinery quality's all indians called him "father of the nation" He otherwise called as Mahatma.

No ,,,,,,,who told u this ? actually the reason behind indias freedom is the bhagat singh,sukhdev,rajguru,chandrashekhar azaad all of them were used violence and thats why india became freedom if u go throuh the way of gandhi then english pepole still make indians behind prison . thats why i am thinking neither gandhi not nono-violence help us to frrrdom india

GR8 point to discuss...but sorry buddy , i dont have any stong points to say anything on this... it will be very nice if somebody can throw some light on it.....

I think if gandhi would not have been there then we would have been freed very early from the cluthes of british...............

though their is controversy over the independence of India.. but i will it was not surely because of the heavy losses during world war II, this is because India was one of the business hubs from where money could be tapped.. Gandhiji was one of the reasons for the Independence.. the prime force was the non violence principle which was completely a new concept.. the war of non violence didn't have any loop hole to win..

He was not d only one who fought for independence..there r ppl like subhash chandra bose and other freedom fighters which gave indians d hope to fight for it. Cant jus give all d credit to Mahatma Gandhi but yes he played an important role in d independence.

well we called gandhi as a father of our nation...it is ture but sometime..i dont like gandhi ...and dont think that he is responsible for independence..morever bhagat singh and alll freedom fighters are responsible for that

I my view INDIA got freedom due to Bhagat Singh..... Bcoz he laid the foundation of freedom....

first of all ur quetion is not good...do u think only a man can do it?...no gandhi alone but all the freedom fighter got India independence..

well i don't know know whether we get independence due to mahatma gandhi or not but one thing is from non-violence he made many impossible work possible and he also told that progress of people can only be achieved if they follow the path of non-violence and people who were following the path of violence are definately suffering because people who gives the training of making bombs and different weapons are transferring ways of violence to coming generation which can only end with the the end of civilization and

inquilab zindabad.... bhagat singh and his team of freedom fighters are the ones respomsible for independent india ...

i agree partially with u

Its not the individual contribution always its a united work. Lot of people have contributed to that and gandhi was a successful leader among them.

Very nice discussion you have started. Thanks for the same. Yes I agree fully that Gandhiji was the only person who has contributed 90% for our independence. Others were just his helping hand. Though there were lot of egoiests, but even they did not dare to tell no to Mahatmaji on any of his step. Neither it was because of World War-II nor non-believers. He was just a amazing personalty. What he used to say, the people had no choice to follow. Because he always spoke truth, only truth.

I won't give the entire credit to Gandhi but yes to some extent he was responsible. Many people were involved in this independence act like Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Chandra Shekhar Azad, Rajguru, Sukh Dev, etc. Their effort was not futile. Some believed in violence while others did not. Personally I dont believe in Ahimsa.

Yes, i believe he played an important role in the independence