Who Really Benefits from Freedom?

Justice
@Shiva49 (26665)
Singapore
December 18, 2017 9:40pm CST
I have lived in few countries and visited some others. I love to interact with ordinary folks to better appreciate their culture and outlook. I find it enriching to understand the concept of their political system and their view of others. I interact without being intrusive. There are always the few who are very open to share their views. The perspectives on freedom are fascinating. Most countries enjoy freedom and democracy but the concept, understanding, and reality vary. People mostly get used to the system in place though the excesses of few end up with them more equal than the rest; in effect, they manipulate the system to their advantage. My conclusion is freedom and democracy has a long way to go before they benefit the common folks. There are always the few out to exploit the loopholes, play around the gray areas, to outwit the system. The ideal world is only in our dreams, but we need to work on the concept of freedom and democracy, fine tune them, for better accountability. There is greater awareness with talk shows et al with people pouring out their frustrations but we are not able to progress much; the more the discussions, the more the division and confusion than conviction for the needed steps. Do you think we can make progress or the present setup is likely to stay with only change of actors and the audiences? I feel the common folks have to assert more for fair play and justice. It is unfair for them to get played out time and time again with leaders getting away with promises they forget when they are in power. Image: Justice from Wikimedia Images
19 people like this
15 responses
@jaboUK (64354)
• United Kingdom
19 Dec 17
I've always liked this quote from John Stuart Mill - 'The freedom of the individual must be thus far limited - he must not make himself a nuisance to other people'.
8 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
20 Dec 17
Good quote, we should free ourselves from those that enslave us and set ourselves free to lead an inclusive life - siva
6 people like this
@marguicha (222844)
• Chile
19 Dec 17
I always told my daughters that a person´s freedom ends when said person steps on the feet of other people. Then the word to be used is licence instead of freedom. I don´t think that big countries have learned that. And I don´t think that the rich and powerful in each country have either.
7 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
19 Dec 17
Yes, sadly, "Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely." I will add wealth to power that corrupts society. Yes, freedom has its limits.We should always be mindful of those deprived for whatever reason. I cannot swing my arms around in the name of freedom unmindful of others around - siva
4 people like this
@yanzalong (18988)
• Indonesia
19 Dec 17
I remember you saying you visited Indonesia. Still wondering about the purpose of your visit. Will you be back again?
4 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
19 Dec 17
I worked in Surabaya for about five years during President Suharto era. Though there was no real democracy, I liked the discipline he enforced. Now I understand there are billboards with him portrayed asking " do you miss me?" I understand some do and yearn for earlier days of governance. I am now retired but still think about those days and the friendly people - siva
4 people like this
@PainsOnSlate (21852)
• Canada
19 Dec 17
Born in the United State and living in Canada now is a good life. The majority have and understand freedom and democracy. Sadly the countries fail a lot of people, the ones who need the help the most.
6 people like this
• Canada
19 Dec 17
@Shiva49 Unfortunately the US is suffering a brainless fake President who does exactly what he wants for his multimillionaire friends and are ignoring children, women, the poor and the average American. Sadly because he was a TV Guy a lot of uninformed voted for him.
5 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
20 Dec 17
@PainsOnSlate It does happen when people want a change and one promises to be different. But then they go overboard to shake the very foundations of societal inclusiveness and unity. Some are loose cannons and we do not know what we are in for. Uniting people, even those who did not support them, is the hallmark of a true leader and not "us and them" take all the time - siva
5 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
19 Dec 17
Yes, but for most countries democracy and freedom are still work on progress. Leaders get elected promising better times but prove worse than the previous incumbents. They promise action against the corrupt but soon find their own are involved. It is musical chair getting played out with leaders in and out and even nepotism rampant. Democracy ends up as voting every five years and then being ignored. Western democracies are accountable but most other countries are grappling with it. Generations have been hoping against hope now for the system to be effective so that common folks interests are not ignored - siva
5 people like this
@JudyEv (339548)
• Rockingham, Australia
19 Dec 17
I think freedom is always restricted in a way because the freedom an individual would like often impacts on someone else's freedom.
4 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
19 Dec 17
Yeah, there is no full fledged freedom but constrained to conform to societal good and inclusivity. The laws are in place but there are grey areas that few take advantage to get ahead. Most play by the rules though, thankfully - siva
5 people like this
@Ganma7 (3664)
20 Dec 17
Very good writing
4 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
21 Dec 17
Thank you Paula, appreciate your support - siva
1 person likes this
@Ganma7 (3664)
21 Dec 17
@Shiva49 Anytime and always
1 person likes this
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
16 Oct 18
If we had a politician who actually stuck to his campaign promises, the other politicians would get quite unruly and hysterical, and would try all sorts of dirty pool to get in the way.
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
16 Oct 18
That happens with the result the agenda based on which elections are decided are stymied time and time again. People in many countries want less of talk and more of action but it still remains high drama and entertainment and ends up much ado about nothing! siva
@artemeis (4194)
• China
16 Feb 18
I see freedom to be one that is necessary when all the players take up their roles and fulfill them. Like the one in authority remembering to do what they have said to the people and as for the people to exercise their freedom responsibly. In the words of the famous Nelson Mandela: "For to be free is not merely to cast off one's chains but to live in a way that respects and enhances the freedom of others." Simple to put it in words but so difficult given the complexity and manipulating human. To be selfless to major percent of the population just seems non existent while the other handful is simply too little to even bring matters up let alone change the surroundings. Take the biggest democratic country's leader or previous, how many of them made it to be Man of the Year? Hardly, right?
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
16 Feb 18
Unless the vast majority benefits freedom and democracy ring hollow. Now it is few who dictate the agenda even in democracies; whoever we elect to power the boss remains the same - the evil ones with greed and ego written all over them. The words of Mandela are worth remembering for a gracious society. The common folks are now shortchanged as also the law abiding - siva
@rebelann (112780)
• El Paso, Texas
25 Dec 17
The native Americans that the first European colony met were free, they had the kind of government that took into consideration everyone in their tribe including women. This impressed the colonists who developed and wrote our first constitution ..... the problem is we got way too big for our britches and too many feel they have the right to do things that other people feel is wrong and in so doing causes a rift. Women folk have only been so called free since the 1970s, before that decade a married woman was considered her husbands property, kinda like a slave. What bothers me the most is that too few people see the danger in what they call "culling" another species, they seem to think they can do the work of Mother Nature. Being free should never mean you have the right to kill for the glory of killing.
1 person likes this
@rebelann (112780)
• El Paso, Texas
25 Dec 17
The only thing I don't understand about what you've said is "co-creator" @Shiva49 are you under the impression that we helped the powers that be to create?
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
26 Dec 17
@rebelann I mention co-creator in the sense we should help our creator as we are at the apex of all species here on this planet. I believe our efforts merely scratch the surface for our survival while nature nurtures us and that means we have to repay big time to show our gratitude. We have an inner knowing that guides us provided we listen to it. We have the power to control other species and even spread our love and compassion to them. When in doubt I go by "do unto others as you would have them do unto you". In fact, I go a step further let others benefit more and that puts a smile that lasts - siva
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
25 Dec 17
Whatever the system in place few go overboard. They take advantage of gray areas to dominate the rest. Hypocrisy, ego and greed are our ruin. The common folks are bombarded with news, views and interviews but truth is still a casualty. Our leaders split them down the middle and for them it is more of self-preservation. Kindness, compassion and love can never go wrong. Our leaders should know the basics. There is no enmity among the 99% and I have seen it as a fact in my interactions with many on a daily basis. We are part of nature and should align our actions in tune with it. Nurture as a way of life and as a co-creator we find fulfillment in our lives. No need for weapons and wars if the attitude is right - siva
1 person likes this
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
25 Dec 17
Hate to be a dissenting voice, but many people have the mistaken idea that the United States is a democracy. It isn't. It's a constitutional republic. In a democracy, as one said, when two wolves and a sheep are gathered together and vote on what to have for dinner, the sheep is likely to lose. The American Constitution was designed to balance power between three branches of government so that no branch can get out of control. Nevertheless, George Washington, our first president, warned that our form of government would only work as long as the majority of the people were moral. At the time he was President there was a moral consensus among the majority that was based on Judeo-Christian values. Most people believed in the Ten Commandments as the basis for moral law. I see the rest of my response is very long and I'm going to post it separately at
I'm writing this in response to http://www.mylot.com/post/3137721/who-really-benefits-from-freedom posted by @Shiva49 . Many who responded saw the imperfections...
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
25 Dec 17
I have responded to your post. Thank you for the elucidation and clarification The United States is generally viewed as the bastion of democracy as it has a political system where "a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections". The above applies to many countries now and they pride themselves as democracies and for having "arrived" at the political system of choice. I agree morality is a casualty as we have moved away from love and compassion in our dealings. It is selfishness of the few that has destroyed the social fabric and made common folks cynical. "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you" is a basic step worth taking - siva
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
25 Dec 17
@bagarad So well said Barbara, thanks. I subscribe to every word and emotion of yours. I have been living away from my birth country for half my life though I visit many times even in a year. The reason is my parents live there, now only my mother. I take turns to look after her. I have followed a dictum I belong to where I live. I am loyal to that country and will never undermine it. In fact, my wife has won many awards over the years from the countries we lived for participating in community bonding. I have moved with all who profess different faiths. I have been educated in Christian and Muslim institutions. I can say the vast majority are for coexistence. I agree it is unbecoming of an immigrant to stand out like a sore thumb and not try to integrate into the welcoming country. If they feel uncomfortable, why go to that country; why not where their own live with same culture and customs? I have my own relatives who are citizens of countries including the United States. They have integrated and involve fully in the society and feel part of the social milieu. No question of undermining the host country which they are part of now. I travel light in conscience. I carry no baggage. I learn from all faiths as I believe there is only one creator by whatever name we may address him. We are humans at the end of the day and those who don't abide by peace are losers and their faith is skin deep and delusional. It is the bounden duty of the majority in every faith to assert against subversion of justice and fair play by the few. There is no "good terrorism". They are acts against humanity and god's children - siva .
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
25 Dec 17
@bagarad So well said Barbara, thanks. I subscribe to every word and emotion of yours. I have been living away from my birth country for half my life though I visit many times even in a year. The reason is my parents live there, now only my mother. I take turns to look after her. I have followed a dictum I belong to where I live. I am loyal to that country and will never undermine it. In fact, my wife has won many awards over the years from the countries we lived for participating in community bonding. I have moved with all who profess different faiths. I have been educated in Christian and Muslim institutions. I can say the vast majority are for coexistence. I agree it is unbecoming of an immigrant to stand out like a sore thumb and not try to integrate into the welcoming country. If they feel uncomfortable, why go to that country; why not where their own live with same culture and customs? I have my own relatives who are citizens of countries including the United States. They have integrated and involve fully in the society and feel part of the social milieu. No question of undermining the host country which they are part of now. I travel light in conscience. I carry no baggage. I learn from all faiths as I believe there is only one creator by whatever name we may address him. We are humans at the end of the day and those who don't abide by peace are losers and their faith is skin deep and delusional. It is the bounden duty of the majority in every faith to assert against subversion of justice and fair play by the few. There is no "good terrorism". They are acts against humanity and god's children - siva .
1 person likes this
• Dallas, Texas
20 Dec 17
Well put. Yes, what you say is true and very deep on a philosophic level. Fundamentally, those who manipulate the system mess things up for everyone else. It is time for people to be held accountable, especially those with the most power and wealth. The people who suffer most are the innocent, the poor, the elderly and this is true of the current administration even here in the USA.
3 people like this
• Dallas, Texas
21 Dec 17
@Shiva49 , That man, Gandhi was a super wise man who has many followers. His legacy will live for centuries as people tend to relate well to real wisdom. You are also very wise. I applaud you your post.
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
21 Dec 17
Thank you. The super rich should pause and ponder - where did their wealth come from? Obviously, from the society and especially the poor who are trusting and even generous to part with what they have. The rich are more calculative. It is better that wealth flows back to the source from where it was generated and not used as a tool to measure success and achievement. Thankfully, the majority remain contented and have time for the little pleasures of life like smelling the roses. Gandhi said "A nation's greatness is measured by how it treats its weakest members.". Ultimately our conscience matters - siva
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
21 Dec 17
@lookatdesktop Thank you Anthony, you are indeed kind and it requires a generous heart to compliment another. Einstein said about Gandhi "Generations to come, it may well be, will scarce believe that such a man as this one ever in flesh and blood walked upon this Earth.” I share my thoughts and feel fulfilled and gratified when they touch others proving we are more alike with similar feelings and aspirations than we care to admit - siva
1 person likes this
@innertalks (21905)
• Australia
19 Dec 17
Oh, to be as free as a bird!
We can all benefit from freedom. Poetry: The freedom of freedom by love Freedom never lives in anyone, until they live within love. This means that only love and its truth, can ever set you up to be free you see. Holding out to remain centred outside, loses your central position in oneness's inside. The truth of life comes alive as much as freedom lives in it, within you too. Only love gives you the freedom to be you. Freeing yourself to be yourself frees love. Love being free within you creates more love. And so thereby you become more free to love.
@innertalks (21905)
• Australia
20 Dec 17
@Shiva49 Loves lives in all life, and yet does that life live in love? Only when it loves. This moves it into love consciously alive as such. At all other times, it lives in the shadow of love, and also the shadow of life barely alive, because to live fully requires one to love fully. This then is the only real freedom. Living fully and loving fully.
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
20 Dec 17
@innertalks We need to elevate ourselves to the consciousness of love, higher consciousness. We need to ignite love or else it will lie dormant like it does mostly. When we do that we live in the oneness of creation and not separate from others - siva
3 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
19 Dec 17
Thanks Steve, Nice poem to drive home the point. We forget the basic ingredient - love - in our thoughts, actions and interactions.Then we go off on a tangent from the right path Selfishness has been our bane and then we lose the plot of oneness and inclusiveness. Freedom does not mean feathering own nest at the cost of others - siva
3 people like this
@YrNemo (20255)
21 Dec 17
This topic is a bit heavy for me right now (I have too many bills and contracts here and there to sort out). I will use my freedom to sneak away, hope you don't mind .
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
21 Dec 17
No problems. Being retired makes it easier for me to ponder about issues and share/unload them wherever I am allowed to! I like to think aloud and appreciate hearing what others have to say - siva
1 person likes this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
22 Dec 17
@YrNemo Yes few do all the time and thereby shortchange the rest - siva
1 person likes this
@YrNemo (20255)
22 Dec 17
@Shiva49 (Some people these days abuse the freedom they have to do bad things.)
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Dec 17
Greed will always try find a way to destroy the wonderful concept of freedom. In the Star Trek movie First Contact, Captain Jean-Luc Picard states: "The acquisition of wealth is no longer the driving force of our lives. We work to better ourselves and the rest of humanity." I'm not sure human beings could ever reach this level of being, but it's a nice dream. I would still rather live in a free country.
2 people like this
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
21 Dec 17
Yeah, we have to press on and have much work to do for an egalitarian society. As long as the rich get richer, and worse, at the cost of the poor, we are sowing seeds of discontent and turning a blind eye to inconvenient truths. Let us put our shoulders to the wheel of positive change. It is a work in progress - siva
1 person likes this
25 Dec 17
Freedom is like a glass, it fills and empties.
@Shiva49 (26665)
• Singapore
26 Dec 17
In a way it reflects our lives, lifestyle and moods too. When our outlook is egalitarian, freedom becomes part of our lives, a way of life. However, some want to corner all the freedom for themselves while denying others! siva