The Way People Talk To Writers

Photo taken by Andy N – Me reading my poetry live.
Preston, England
June 5, 2019 5:01pm CST
As a writer, I often get people asking me about my writing, ideas, etc. Sometimes the conversation is friendly and intelligent but other times it is less so. 1/. Immediate assumptions that I’m a professional writer. – No, in fact I am unemployed. I occasionally sell stories, poems articles and the occasional book but not enough to get me off welfare. Rather than saying I’m out of work however, I often declare myself a writer. I am obviously not rich as other members of the public sometimes assume too. 2/. Immediate assumptions that I’m famous. – No, like most writers, I am rarely recognized and my writing may be too niche to ever allow me to be a best-seller. 3/. I am happy to talk about my writing, and sign my books except when dining out or using the lavatory, etc. 4/. No, just because I work with someone (when employed or volunteering) I am not giving them a free or heavily discounted copy of my writings. 5/. Asked where my ideas come from, I reply from life and everywhere. We all have ideas. Every choice we make is an idea. 6/. Asked why I don’t write like J K Rowling, I reply ‘because she already does that.” 7/. I don’t mind telling anyone what writing projects I am working on, but not in too much detail. 8/. Asking me how a book I am writing is going on, I don’t mind until it is asked mechanically every time they see me. 9/. Being given ideas for my next book assumes I have no plans or ideas of my own, and the given ideas are often borrowed from other writers, film or TV shows too. 10/. Many gush about buying my book, and even browse copies, but never actually buy a copy. 11/. I don’t know how many copies my current publisher sells for me. They do not notify me of each and every sale. Royalty payment is often per annum, not sale by sale. 12/. Told I don’t look like a writer ??? No idea what a typical writer look like an in fact I look very much like Beat poet Allen Ginsberg. 13/. I dislike people who are dismissive of the genres I say I write in, as if that is not proper writing, whatever that is. 14/. Media people often promise me interviews that never materialize or fail to go out on time. 15/. Some event organizers overcharge attendees, leading to low attendance and rarely share the event proceeds with myself and other writers attending. 16/. Sometimes if seen in pubs or shops I am told that this won’t get my books written, when in fact observing and interacting with people is part of the writing. 17/. People see me writing notes expect me to share my writings with them. No. 18/. Other writers sometimes try to show off by feeling the Muse there and then and having to write. It is just pretentious and insincere. I never do it. Arthur Chappell
9 people like this
9 responses
@LindaOHio (178568)
• United States
6 Jun 19
Thank you for letting us know how you feel. I can understand a lot of it. As a writer myself, I'd like to answer the J. K. Rawlings question from my standpoint: because I don't like the genre! I would like to ask what genres you mainly write about? Thanks! ... and good luck in your writing career!
2 people like this
• Preston, England
6 Jun 19
I do write fantasy and science fiction but my style is not J K Rowling
2 people like this
@LindaOHio (178568)
• United States
6 Jun 19
@arthurchappell Thank you for sharing your opinions.
2 people like this
@thelme55 (77061)
• Germany
5 Jun 19
Very well said. I hope you will be successful in your writing. Who knows you will have a very successful book in the future.
2 people like this
• Preston, England
6 Jun 19
@thelme55 it is certainly a nice dream
2 people like this
@thelme55 (77061)
• Germany
7 Jun 19
@arthurchappell yes, it is. I hope it will come to you what you have dreamed of.
2 people like this
@simone10 (54187)
• Louisville, Kentucky
6 Jun 19
I also wish you much success with your writing. I can see how some of these questions can get really older after a while.
2 people like this
@xander6464 (44245)
• Wapello, Iowa
6 Jun 19
JK who? You look a little like George R.R. Martin, too. But a bit more like Allen Ginsberg.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
6 Jun 19
would that be J K Galbraith (Economist) or J K Simmons the actor?
1 person likes this
@xander6464 (44245)
• Wapello, Iowa
7 Jun 19
@arthurchappell I'm not sure. Whichever one of them wrote about a wizard and I think there was a school of some kind involved, too.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
7 Jun 19
@xander6464 I was a wizard at school, - when it came to maths I did a disappearing act
1 person likes this
@JudyEv (339974)
• Rockingham, Australia
22 Jun 19
People have some really weird ideas about writers. Fancy asking why you don't write like whoever. Pretty crazy.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
24 Jun 19
@JudyEv yes if everyone wrote alike we'd never need a second book on our shelves
1 person likes this
@Ronrybs (19281)
• London, England
6 Jun 19
Just proves what I have always thought, people are weird!
2 people like this
• Preston, England
6 Jun 19
@Ronrybs yes we can be really strange
2 people like this
@LadyDuck (471503)
• Switzerland
6 Jun 19
No matter what you say you do in life there are people who jump to conclusion, that feel it's fine to ask personal questions or ask for "free" suggestions should they want to do the same. People are weird.
1 person likes this
• Bournemouth, England
7 Jun 19
'What do you do about writer's block?' is another common question. I was once introduced as a writer to an obnoxious woman whose first words to me were 'Never heard of you'. Weeks later I was featured on a TV show and she phoned up to ask me out!
@Julie555 (4155)
• Russian Federation
6 Jun 19
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Niche writers are not much recognized, but I wish you to get wide recognition
1 person likes this