Zen Story: "Stumped."

The Zen master was stumped until the day that he died, but he died happy
@innertalks (21921)
Australia
September 5, 2020 9:42pm CST
The Zen master was stumped for over 60 years, but finally, he accepted life's answer to him. The renowned Zen master, Harrumph Horcluda, had been stumped for all of his life by one question. His own master had given this too him, and he had never solved it to his own satisfaction, even though, his master had accepted his answer, and had promoted him to his head position in the new sister monastery to his own one in the province, as the Zen master there. Sixty long years had passed. His own old master had long ago died. The Zen master was now 88, very old for somebody to live to, in those times, but maybe his hanging on to the need for a more inclusive answer to the question, that had him stumped, in its way, had kept his mind actively searching for answers, for all of this long time. The old master was tired, and he walked out into the grounds of his monastery, and he looked at an old tree stump there. "Now, you are stumped, but not stumped, both at the same time." "Maybe, I should just learn to be stumped, and not stumped, at the same time too. I should just leave the stump in place in me, to do its own thing in me too." He sat down on the stump. It was rotten. An ant crawled up his leg, and it bit him painfully on his shin. "There is still some life left in this old stump then," he thought, "just a different type of life, than it originally was." "There is still life in me too," he went on in his mind, "that painful bite certainly proves that to me now." "Harrumph!" he said out loud, and I say, "Hhhaaarrruuummmpphh, once again." The master smiled beautifully to himself. "My name is Harrumph, because my Dad said that word, when I unexpectedly arrived into his life, as an unexpected baby." "All problems are solved in this way by our just saying, "harrumph" to them, and then letting them dissolve away, like this rotting tree trunk, or old stump, until new life finds it again, and brings the answer to us, in an entirely new way, as life will always do so." The old master smiled once again, even wider than his last smile, even more beautifully too. But nobody saw it but himself. Then he simply fell down dead. He was found by his students, right next to this stump, and they could see the reddened bite mark of the ant, still on his leg too. "Harrumph," was the right answer at the time when he was born, and it was still the right answer at the time of his death too. They wrote on his urn, only this one word, "Harrumph" Photo Credit: The photo used here belongs to me, the author, of this piece The Zen master was stumped until the day that he died, but he died happy.
4 people like this
4 responses
@Nakitakona (56486)
• Philippines
6 Sep 20
I overheard my late mother uttering it when she's desperate and uncertain on what to do or to accept what life really is. Our local version is "haahay!" A sign of total surrender to the rancor and rigor of life when nothing could be done in a moment.
2 people like this
@innertalks (21921)
• Australia
6 Sep 20
Yes. Tired, fed up, exasperated, unsatisfied, leads us to harrumph. I didn't know that, "haahay"; maybe different cultures have different expressions for it, yes.
2 people like this
@Shiva49 (26686)
• Singapore
6 Sep 20
@innertalks The Buddha said the first step towards self enlightenment is to learn to let go - siva
1 person likes this
@Nakitakona (56486)
• Philippines
6 Sep 20
@innertalks I said it is our own dialect. It's an expression of exasperation.
2 people like this
@DocAndersen (54402)
• United States
6 Sep 20
what drives the answer and why does it cause the master such anguish? is the unanswered question really his own life and therefore mortality?
2 people like this
@innertalks (21921)
• Australia
6 Sep 20
I left the actual question unanswered, perhaps to get the reader to think about what such a powerfully unanswered question could be. I didn't even elucidate what the actual question was. What is my unanswered question? What is your most unanswered question? If we could answer our most unanswerable question, we would be enlightened. The question in me is: "Why must there be a question, when all that I want is peace?"
@innertalks (21921)
• Australia
7 Sep 20
@DocAndersen Yes, that's why God created the questioner, to probe forth the answers in his psyche, which he wanted to see down on paper, instead of just running around loose in his head. God also appreciates the Dad jokes, as why else would he call himself, "father"? What did God say to the father? What came first the father, or the son? What did the father/dad answer? That's a mother of a question!
@DocAndersen (54402)
• United States
7 Sep 20
@innertalks because. or in the dad joke version because I said so! which came first the question or the answer? Or did the seeker come before either the question or the answer? What is the world without questions?
1 person likes this
@RasmaSandra (79929)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
6 Sep 20
I guess the most important thing is to get through life and be happy.
2 people like this
@innertalks (21921)
• Australia
6 Sep 20
Or, at least to be happy at the end, or by the end of our life, as this master was here...lol...
@Shiva49 (26686)
• Singapore
6 Sep 20
Certain issues can trouble us no end to find a solution to our complete satisfaction but it is better for us to allow it to rest for our peace of mind. Yes, we should not get obsessed with one issue only and spread out our tentacles of reach and be happy and contented. Let others take it further from where we left them - siva
1 person likes this
@innertalks (21921)
• Australia
6 Sep 20
This is hard to do at times, and we should always try to remember the very wise words of that great physicist, Sir Isaac Newton (1642 to 1727) about this type of a thing: "If I have seen further than others, it is by standing upon the shoulders of giants."
@Shiva49 (26686)
• Singapore
6 Sep 20
@innertalks Yes, that was indeed humble of Newton to say it openly rather than take the full credit himself - siva
1 person likes this
@innertalks (21921)
• Australia
6 Sep 20
@Shiva49 Sometimes, we can say something humble, while saying it in such an arrogant way that it loses its flavour though. It is hard to know how Newton really said that, without hearing him actually say it, but we should give him the benefit of the doubt, anyway.
1 person likes this