Music Is Not About Perfection But Rather Soul
By Jim Bauer
@porwest (90823)
United States
January 3, 2021 4:18pm CST
"The only way to keep a song alive is to never play it the same way twice."
—Keith Richards of the Rolling Stones
There was a very interesting question asked of Keith Richards, the masterful guitar player from iconic rock band The Rolling Stones. It is a question I think a lot of musicians get asked probably.
How do you remember all of those songs?
Keith Richards smiled and said, "The simple fact of the matter is I don't. But my fingers do. My fingers know where to go and I just follow them. You have to suspend your thoughts, out there, on stage. If you let your thoughts get in the way, it can really muddle things up. So, I rely on my fingers to show me the way. And they remember where to go and they know what to do."
It was an interesting response because I have heard many great musicians, and mostly guitarists, say that they never play the same song the same way twice. And in fact, they say, they can't.
Guitar playing is not ever about perfection. It is more about interpretation. And every time a guitarist picks up a guitar and strums a chord or plays a riff, it is something unique that sounds very familiar, but not at all the same as what was the original inspiration for it, or where it came from.
And ask any musician about whether they get it perfect every time or what they think about trying to? They have one simple answer.
Screw perfection.
Because music is about the moment. It is about emotion. And if you are up there on stage just going through the motions, and trying to perfectly capture each note and worrying about whether or not you are a bit before the beat or a bit after the beat, or if the drummer has sped up a bit or slowed down a bit...
You might as well not be doing it.
Another musician said once, "Even if I make a mistake, the best part is that even though I know it, and the rest of the band knows it—I can be a master of my own screwups and do it in a way that the one person that matters the most doesn't KNOW I screwed up. The audience."
17 people like this
15 responses
@RebeccasFarm (89882)
• Arvada, Colorado
4 Jan 21
He is wise despite his nose problem Keith
2 people like this
@RebeccasFarm (89882)
• Arvada, Colorado
5 Jan 21
@porwest Oh yeah I heard he gave it up..but who knows
1 person likes this
@andriaperry (116936)
• Anniston, Alabama
4 Jan 21
It's like driving for me, sometimes I don't remember the drive home at all
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
5 Jan 21
I think half the listeners do not realize if the note is half up or down. Many also do not realize that the beat is missed or slow or whatever. There is something about perfection. I cannot tell you what it is. Kinda it makes the blood cells vibrate. That is the best I can describe it. People who hear it, realize that. But yes, perfection is not essential component for music. Melody is.
Bahara official full song video from bollywood movie I Hate Luv Storys feat. Sonam Kapoor and Imran KhanSong Name - BaharaMovie - I Hate Luv StorysSinger - S...
1 person likes this
@just4him (317041)
• Green Bay, Wisconsin
5 Jan 21
I've never thought about it but it makes sense.
I think you can say the same thing about a lot of things you do. I'm a writer. Every time I open a manuscript to work on it, I find something I need to add or subtract. There comes a time when I have to tell myself, publish it already.
2 people like this
@porwest (90823)
• United States
8 Jan 21
This is very true. As one writer put it, "You have to know when to stop editing, because we are our worst critics, and perfection is not possible. So either you write, or you edit. And you have to ask yourself if you want to be a writer or an editor."
2 people like this
@kaylachan (69654)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
3 Jan 21
That's true. While it's true you need to practice the craft, music is about living in the moment and enjoying what you do.
@1creekgirl (41424)
• United States
4 Jan 21
True advice. I don't play any instruments, but when I sing and make a mistake, I don't react to it, but keep on and most of the time no one knows. I often like to sing songs that were originally sung by a male because I can make it my own version rather than being compared to a female professional.
1 person likes this
@Namelesss (3365)
• United States
3 Jan 21
True expression is total perfection. But perfection can not be expressed.
1 person likes this
@LindaOHio (178568)
• United States
4 Jan 21
Angie is right. When I used to drive all of the time, I drove on autopilot. Interesting post.
1 person likes this
@Nakitakona (56486)
• Philippines
4 Jan 21
In guitar playing, it's the fingers that do the 'talking."
@Nakitakona (56486)
• Philippines
10 Jan 21
@porwest You don't understand for you are not a guitarist.
1 person likes this
@KerrYssein (12)
•
4 Jan 21
I agree, you cannot feel that music is your home if you don't have a soul for music
1 person likes this