Is the United States a true democracy? Discuss!
By John Welford
@indexer (4852)
Leicester, England
March 27, 2021 10:17am CST
That is a question that has doubtless appeared as an exam or essay question many times in the past - but recent events, such as in Georgia, might make many people take a different line in their answers.
I have taken a strong interest in electoral politics for many years. Apart from being a student of history - mainly British, but also including that of other countries including the United States - I have regularly counted votes after elections and have, in the past, campaigned for a political party by knocking on doors and asking people to support a particular candidate.
My experience of the UK electoral system has been based entirely on the premise that every citizen above the age of 18 has the right to vote, and everything is done to ensure that the process of voting is made as easy and straightforward as possible.
There are very few circumstances under which someone is denied the right to vote. Everyone is expected to register in order to appear on the electoral roll for their local area, and being removed from the roll is a very rare occurrence.
When I was knocking on doors, I always encouraged people to exercise their right to vote, and I also made it clear that it was important that they did so, even if they had no intention of voting for candidate I was supporting. That, to me, is the essence of democracy - a high turnout means that the people we elect to office have got there because a large proportion of the residents they represent have made a conscious choice in the matter.
So when I read about efforts in parts of the United States to do everything possible to deny certain people the right to vote, and to make it as awkward and uncomfortable as possible for people to exercise that right, I really do wonder if that country is a democracy at all!
4 people like this
3 responses
@LeaPea2417 (37353)
• Toccoa, Georgia
27 Mar 21
The United States is a Republic.
1 person likes this
@DocAndersen (54402)
• United States
27 Mar 21
actually, the US is a Federalist system that uses many democratic principles. But, in fairness like Communism and Socialism, there has never been a pure democracy.
We tend more towards Republic than true democracy.
But in and of itself democracy is an ideal to strive for.
@indexer (4852)
• Leicester, England
28 Mar 21
But there is nothing to stop a republic being a democracy - as the latter word is understood in modern terms. Even in classical times, there were democratic elements in the Roman Republic, many of which disappeared when the Republic gave way to the Empire and all the major decisions were decided by the man at the top.
The only time when England was a Republic was certainly more democratic than when either King Charles was on the throne, before and after the Commonwealth period. That was because Parliament had won a Civil War and was then the true power in the land. Given that Parliament was certainly not elected on terms that apply today, its claim to be truly democratic would be a weak one, but it was certainly a lot more so than the absolute monarchy that it replaced.
1 person likes this
@indexer (4852)
• Leicester, England
29 Mar 21
@DocAndersen The traditional sense of "republic" is "res publica" - "matters of the people", in other words, not the "matters of a monarch". A republic exists to put the needs of the population first, as opposed to carrying out the wishes of a king or emperor. Surely that must trend towards a republic being a democracy?
However, the point of my original post, which everyone seems to be avoiding, is that democracy is ill-served if the elected representatives take actions to deprive a sector of the electorate of the right to vote, or put obstacles in their way to make voting difficult and thus discourage them from so doing. That is what seems to be happening in Georgia.
1 person likes this
@DocAndersen (54402)
• United States
28 Mar 21
@indexer in the case of the US republic we aren't a true democracy. just a republic in the traditional sense of that word.
@FourWalls (68000)
• United States
27 Mar 21
No. Our form of government is a representative republic. A “true democracy” is three wolves and two sheep voting on what’s for dinner.