A North South Divide/ Accents within a country.
@Lindalahughes (220)
United Kingdom
April 17, 2021 8:09am CST
As someone who moved from the south of England to the north, I often get asked where I'm from. Northerners seem to be a bit obsessed with where people are from if they don't sound the same as them. I don't know, maybe it's a city thing?
And most people are cool, they're just generally interested, but of late I've noticed more people getting quite rude about it. Like they think I shouldn't be here.
And it's always older women who get nasty about it.
Does it happen where you're from? Do you get discriminated against because of your accent?
Are there a lot of variations in accent in your country?
7 people like this
7 responses
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
17 Apr 21
We have such a mix of people here in Cambridge that people don't tend to comment on one's accent. I think that my accent is more or less 'BBC' (or Upper Middle Class Southern) and, although I was born and bred here, I don't speak with the local accent, though it depends on who I'm talking with. I would tend to use a slightly different accent when speaking with locals than when speaking with people who speak more like me.
This is the point, I think. I was once asked. when on holiday in Ireland. what part of Ireland I came from because I had obviously picked up some of that lovely Irish roundedness but she couldn't identify where it was from! I was also told (in Paris, France) that I must be Belgian ("Vous etes Belge, n'est-ce pas?") and on another occasion (in the Loire valley) that I spoke with a Spanish accent!
I think that you may have (perhaps unconsciously) picked up something of the local accent - which will be a slight difference in vowels, mostly - and local people detect an anomaly but can't exactly place it as 'here' or 'there'. So they ask!
2 people like this
@Lindalahughes (220)
• United Kingdom
17 Apr 21
I was born and raised in Oxford so technically we're not legally allowed to talk to each other! How strange that people thought you were from so many different places. Yes sometimes it's that but there's a definite hostility and I notice it mostly with those from Liverpool and Manchester. And as I say it's women of a certain age too.
1 person likes this
@MALUSE (69373)
• Germany
17 Apr 21
@Lindalahughes Goodness! Now I've killed off Prince Charles*! :-( I know that he is still a young whippersnapper (from my point of view). I saw him at the train station in Balmoral when he was 16 years old and had come with the Royal Family to spend the summer at the castle there.
*I've resurrected him and corrected the text.
1 person likes this
@Lindalahughes (220)
• United Kingdom
17 Apr 21
@MALUSE Prince Phillip? Prince Charles is still alive. It's a good thing that Germany doesn't have a class system. It's antiquated at best but thankfully it's not as bad as it used to be.
1 person likes this
@MALUSE (69373)
• Germany
17 Apr 21
@Lindalahughes @marguicha Germany has 80+ mill. inhabitants. There are lots of dialects and accents. Some are even impossible to understand for someone living at the other end of the country.
I've lived in different parts of the country. I've learnt that some accents are looked down upon and others are not. Nowadays people move around a lot for their jobs. It's not advisable to only speak your local accent but also the standard language if you want to make a career. Yet, there are examples of people who do speak their local accent and have made a great career.
I speak only the standard language. Very rarely do I meet someone with an extremely fine ear for accents who can tell me where I've lived during my life by listening attentively to my pronunciation. I find this impressive.
2 people like this
@marguicha (222703)
• Chile
17 Apr 21
We know here who are immigrants. They heve different accents although I cannot see the difference between Venezuelans and Colombians. But I can stop at the second people from Argentina, PerĂº and Bolivia.
1 person likes this
@MALUSE (69373)
• Germany
17 Apr 21
@Lindalahughes I'm rather good at doing this and have already surprised people who thought that they didn't have an accent. Hah! I've found them out.
@Lindalahughes (220)
• United Kingdom
17 Apr 21
It is an impressive skill to pinpoint accents. I am terrible at doing it.
@marguicha (222703)
• Chile
17 Apr 21
People also talk differently dependind on their social class here. And now there are lots of different accents due to immigration.
1 person likes this
@marguicha (222703)
• Chile
17 Apr 21
@Lindalahughes Not now. We have covid as the rest of the world. Normally it is.
@RebeccasFarm (89832)
• Arvada, Colorado
17 Apr 21
Oh yes, there are great distinctions and that is putting it mildly.
They can look at you as if you have 3 eyes here if you are from another state.
1 person likes this
@RebeccasFarm (89832)
• Arvada, Colorado
17 Apr 21
@Lindalahughes And there are so many it is mind boggling
1 person likes this
@Lindalahughes (220)
• United Kingdom
17 Apr 21
I LOVE the differences in accents across the USA!
1 person likes this
@Rashnag (30592)
• Surat, India
18 Apr 21
There are different languages spoken in our country. There isn't much discrimination though. Have a good day. Take care