Accordion or Guitar?

That's a good question. The accordion is very different. I'd like the guitar more probably, and sounds like one I'd give to my husband

I think I would go with the guitar card. My brother in law has an April birthday also. He and my sis are so cute, whenever I give them something they either wear what I have given them or in his case, he brought the personalized mug I gave him to drink coffee out of when I saw them at Christmas. I am glad he likes it, it wasn;t cheap... I was thinking of going up there for the eclipse, but with this ginormous insurance bill think I will wait until this summer. If you could afford it, you could give the accordion for another gift giving occassion.

I think the first one is a bit more simple and a little more unique. However, you know him better than us. Appeal to his love. Although, I think he'd be happy with either or. So long as it's from you.

I say go with the guitar card since he used to play guitar. I'm sure he'll get a kick out of it

I've never seen cards like that! They both sound great, but I guess if he was a guitar player I'd get him that one.

I prefer the accordion.

I am going to go with the guitar, although I am glad you shared a picture of the accordion. I said "guitar" because it is a non seasonal song. He can play it more often.

If he liked to play the guitar, may be he will appreciate more the guitar. Save the accordion for another occasion.

They both sound nice.

What is perfect pitch? When you throw a banjo into the dumpster and it crushes two accordions. You know my answer.

I like both of them. My preference would be the accordion. What is his favorite instrument? That's the one you should give him.

Those are both very cute. I'd buy both and keep one for next year - but make sure you know where to find it when next year comes!!

Your brother would like either one; but I would choose the Happy Birthday and the accordion. Have a good weekend.

Hmm, if he is familiar with Deep Purple that would be the one. If not, maybe unusual is better. Personally, since I'm familiar with the group and playing a song is pretty cool vs just Happy Birthday, I would choose that one.

It appears that giving an accordion card is a somewhat unusual idea. Thus, I go with the accordion. If your BIL loves to play the guitar, though, you might as well give that to him.

I love the accordion, the children may not have seen or heard such music. Good luck with your choice.

They both sound fun.

My instrument was the piano and since the accordion has a keyboard I would go with the accordion,

I like the accordion idea for your brother in law better since music will attract him a lot better than the other card.

I am sure which ever one you choose he will love it. I would like the accordian one because it is different.