Dilemma, and dilemma

@vandana7 (100617)
India
December 13, 2024 4:45pm CST
Ok...so this is personal.. A is an old lady who owns a house. V is her daughter and P is her son. A has willed her property equally to both her children. However, P tries to sell it without the knowledge of A and V, being the son. Y is a distant relative whose help is taken for taking care of A's finances and health. Now P wants Y to help in sale of A's properties. Y feels it is unfair towards the other two. P gets angry with Y for refusing the desired help What would be your solution as Y? Tell P to go to hell?
10 people like this
10 responses
@JudyEv (342112)
• Rockingham, Australia
14 Dec
Yep, tell him to go to hell. What an a**sehole.
4 people like this
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
14 Dec
How can people be fine with taking away what belongs to their parents, without the permission of the parent is something that is absolutely beyond my comprehension.
3 people like this
@wolfgirl569 (108166)
• Marion, Ohio
14 Dec
Here he would not be able to sell it if she owns it yet. And if it's willed to both they would both have to sign to sell after she passes. So yep and if he kept trying maybe talk to an attorney about steps to protect everything
4 people like this
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
14 Dec
But Y is not a party at all....and A has not asked Y to take any such steps. A is not aware of the intended transaction, and Y is forced to keep silent because any such disclosure may lead to arguments and what nots, leading to somebody having major health issues. Y does not want to be the cause of that. She is waiting for P to ask A for signing the Power of Attorney...whatever be the explosion will happen at their end...she would be spared the guilt.
3 people like this
@celticeagle (168256)
• Boise, Idaho
14 Dec
People are so greedy and creepy. Yeah, P should be told to go south.
3 people like this
@celticeagle (168256)
• Boise, Idaho
14 Dec
@vandana7 ......Strength and wisdom. I hopeful for you too.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
14 Dec
I too felt that...but am controlling my anger. I hope god gives me strength to do that, and gives him some wisdom too, because the old lady is in a position to change her Will, and that means, he stands to lose a lot.
3 people like this
@kaylachan (71785)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
13 Dec
Is this an estate sale? In which case all parties have to be legally involved.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
14 Dec
Yes it is. Traditionally, we in India are inclined to obey male members....like chatel if you can imagine...so this lady though a strong willed person will not be able to defy her son. The issue will also not be discussed with others but after the sale, there can be some arguments...which is what is scary. People should stand up what they want upfront, not later.
3 people like this
@kaylachan (71785)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
14 Dec
@vandana7 We have a lot of that here in the U.S. despite women supposedly having equal rights. We do and we don't.
3 people like this
@jstory07 (139974)
• Roseburg, Oregon
14 Dec
Yes tell him to go to h*ll. What a bad thing to try and do.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
14 Dec
Don't people realize that they are doing something bad...sigh...
• India
15 Dec
Tell P - the consequences of his actions. Whether he is willing to risk everything and sell properties. It would be better to sell if possible , with knowledge of A and V. The risks are apparently lesser compared to selling them in secret. Explain to him , his family could have cordial relations with all stakeholders involved even if something happens to him. By hiding the things , nothing is going to be gained. If the relation with V is a challenge , ask P to talk to A and explain why he needs to sell them . Also another strategy would be to tell P not to sell now as the property values could increase and sell them when absolutely needed. With property prices increasing exponently , buying is out of option for most these days. I could think of these two ways.
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
15 Dec
Bulldoze is the word. He tends to behave like that in the family. I am afraid I am not gonna express anything like that because all that he already heard from me before. When he was handing over the charge of his mother to me, I had expressed that I will not participate in any sale of properties as it could lead to rifts. He said no no everything is good, my sister and I are on the same page...blah blah. Then his sister asked me for some link document, and I said I don't have it, and not to ask me to do such things as I have told brother upfront that I will not be handling such matters. She didn't like it, obviously. I told the same to brother, he said I am not controlling you, go ahead if you want to. That itself told me that they are not doing it together. Now, the sister is not asking me anything related to property when the brother is trying to sell. So sister is in dark. Why on earth should I help to procure the document? It will cause rift, and I will be the scapegoat so I told categorically that I told you upfront I am not gonna touch your cupboards why are you asking me...he sent a mail...you are beginning to irritate me. I only asked you to give me a document not conclude the deal...as if rift would not happen if I let him get the document and as if I would not be blamed. Sigh...if he wants, he should ask the sister and mother. They will tell me where they placed it, and I will pull it out and hand it over to them. As simple as that.
1 person likes this
• India
15 Dec
@vandana7 Ask him to talk to his mother and sort what he wants. Tell him you cannot handle finance part of things. Plus, it is better to stay out of financial troubles of this sort. As you rightly pointed , you would become the scapegoat in front of family. From the descriptions, it does look the brother and sister are exactly clean souls. So , prevention is better than cure. Staying out of it is nice!
1 person likes this
@RasmaSandra (80736)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
14 Dec
Just be a bit nicer and tell him to go fly a kite, That should keep him busy,
@LindaOHio (181717)
• United States
14 Dec
Yes, politely tell P why you won't help. Have a good weekend.
1 person likes this
@aureategloom (11398)
• Bosnia And Herzegovina
14 Dec
is that even "possible"? i mean, the lady is alive and the house is not his, how can he sell it? Y should tell P to go to hell, yes. then talk to A and tell her what her son has been doing behind her back and have her change her will and leave everything to V.
1 person likes this
@Dreamerby (5904)
• Calcutta, India
14 Dec
Y should cut off contacts with P.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100617)
• India
14 Dec
That is the plan subject to all other factors falling in place.