The REASON You Charge a 29% Tariff on an Island with No Exports, Explained

@porwest (98807)
United States
April 7, 2025 7:58am CST
Why would the United States impose a 29% tariff on an island of 2,100 people with no exports? I'm talking, of course, about Norfolk Island, caught between New Zealand and Australia, that has become a discussion topic around here. Let's examine this a bit, so that it is more...digestible. First, let's consider this; Norfolk Island is an island of IMPORTS. In other words, what they use there mostly comes from other countries who make things. A lot of that stuff comes from the United States. How much does Norfolk Island charge the United States for stuff they buy from us? 58%. That's right, there is a 58% tariff on all U.S. goods sold to Norfolk Island. Still, if Norfolk Island doesn't export anything, what's the point of putting a tariff on stuff they don't have, even one at HALF the cost they are expecting us to pay to them? Avoiding future loopholes. Not to say a large number of corporations might find a small island to be an attractive place to one day set up shop and build a factory or two. But some MIGHT. If they could start making stuff in Norfolk Island and ship to the United States duty free, that creates a loophole. Think of it this way. Why is it that one of the tiniest states in the United States is home to such a very large number of companies in terms of where they are incorporated? I'm talking about Delaware with a population of just 1 million people. It's because Delaware has the most favorable terms regarding incorporation. Doesn't matter if your corporate headquarters is in Texas, if you can incorporate in Delaware, you get more favorable terms. Imposing a tariff on Norfolk Island BEFORE they start potentially exporting things closes a future potential loophole some people might decide they want to take advantage of, INCLUDING Norfolk Island themselves who MIGHT decide to advertise their special "duty-free" access to the United States and market themselves as a place to do business. The decision to impose a 29% tariff on a small island with no imports is to ensure fairness, and to consider the future potential of being a special tiny island that gets a free pass if it changes its mind.
7 people like this
4 responses
@NJChicaa (122232)
• United States
7 Apr
okay now explain tariffs on islands with no people and only seals and seabirds
6 people like this
@marguicha (225886)
• Chile
7 Apr
I read yesterday about tariffs of an island with only penguins and seals.
7 people like this
@BarBaraPrz (49192)
• St. Catharines, Ontario
7 Apr
You beat me to it!
4 people like this
@porwest (98807)
• United States
7 Apr
Doesn't matter. ANY place where there is nothing can BECOME a place that has people IF there are incentives for people to live there and make money and enjoy life. Look at all the places across the United States that were once farm fields that are now bustling cities full of homes, shopping centers, roads and businesses.
4 people like this
@JudyEv (350252)
• Rockingham, Australia
8 Apr
There are a lot of 'might's' and 'maybe's' here. You have apoint but in the meantime, America is losing a lot of goodwill. Still, Russia seems to be doing okay without goodwill.
3 people like this
@JudyEv (350252)
• Rockingham, Australia
14h
@porwest All the deals were made by both parties. That's hardly being taken advantage of. The US might want to make some changes but there are better ways of doing it surely.
1 person likes this
@porwest (98807)
• United States
14h
@JudyEv What better way is there to get a better rate on your cable bill than to call them and tell them point blank, "I want a better deal, or I will cancel the one we have?"
1 person likes this
@porwest (98807)
• United States
15h
The question is "why are we losing it?" Because we are calling out those who took advantage of us for decades? Embezzlers don't like the people who catch them in the act and want their money back either AND have to give up the gravy train you know. As I always say, be careful who you call your friends, and watch what they do when you actually make them act like one.
2 people like this
@marguicha (225886)
• Chile
7 Apr
I just read about an island with only pinguins and seals. No human beings. Please explain that. I´m sure that you´ll find an explanation. Although where the penguins will get the money to pay would be something else.
2 people like this
@marguicha (225886)
• Chile
7 Apr
@porwest I understand that we have to think forward and into the future. I think about my age and only hope to live enough so that other people that are as old as I am die before I do so that they stop destroying the planet. Meanwhile I have stopped buying some things I used to buy, as you know. I have had no problem with my shrinking instead of expanding. The hummus I made has proven to be delicious. I will not eat pancake syrup for the next 4 years if I live so long.
@NJChicaa (122232)
• United States
7 Apr
@porwest Yes those penguins really need a Walmart
3 people like this
@porwest (98807)
• United States
7 Apr
I grew up in a town of 11,000 people where it was all mostly farmland. When you go there now it's a full blown city with multiple shopping centers, bustling with people and business and now there's 100,000 people living there. This is only in the span of say, 30 years. If there's money to be made and something can be turned into something... It will happen eventually. And let's say there's some place right now with only penguins and seals and everyone else is having to pay tariffs and this ONE PLACE has none. MIGHT be a good reason to bring some tractors out and start building. One man sees a beautiful cornfield. Another man sees a wonderful place to put a Walmart.
1 person likes this
@akalinus (44280)
• United States
11h
I saw an explanation for this. If no tariff is imposed on the little island, companies will start using it to export goods without paying the tariff.