Conflict between Mother and Wife

@john1984 (309)
India
December 10, 2006 12:18am CST
I have a question regarding family matters. There is a continuous tussle between my mother and wife regarding the distribution of work in the house. My mother has burdened my wife with every single house chore. My family consists of more than 15 members, who must be catered for by my wife. She, because of me, follows my mother’s instructions. But of course one should no go beyond limits. Burdening someone with more than their capacity and responsibility is unjust. My mother belongs to a traditional class of women; she believes that all the work should be done by the Bahu (daughter in law). I want to know what you says in this regard. Does it really oblige a lady to take care of not only her husband but also her in laws?
82 responses
@soldenski (2503)
• United States
10 Dec 06
I'll tell you something...you are one lucky guy. If you were married to me...I would have left you along time ago. Your wife is not a maid, taking care of everyone's need's. Why do you have so many people living in your home. When a couple get's married, they start their own life, in their own home, if that's not the case, where you are from, then you should have stayed single and had your mommy take care of you. Give your wife a break, get your own home
@john1984 (309)
• India
10 Dec 06
well, thanks for your advice .But i love my mother too .I didn't want to loose anyone .
• United States
10 Dec 06
I have 2 kids & a third on the way. My husband & I are only 21, but we don't live with our parents. In fact I moved out at 18. We have lived out on our own, together, since I was 20 though. Weird, huh? But our parents get something great outta all this. They get to enjoy "life after the kids leave the nest". Plus they enjoy spending time with our son b/c they don't see him 24/7 & see his hissy fits all the time & tantrums. My adivice, get your own home. It'll be better ALL around & if you "loose" anyone it isn't over having your own life.
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
@reeseyj (906)
• United States
10 Dec 06
no way, Your wife married you not your family. your lucky she's still married to u. When your family is disrespecting her there disrespecting you.She has no obligation to your family only u.
@reeseyj (906)
• United States
10 Dec 06
sorry for the 2 posts. the computer messed up.
• United States
11 Dec 06
he can honnor his mother but his mother has no right telling the wife how to run her house hold nor should his wife be over the house hold work 100% the husband needs to do some of the house work here get off your butt help your wife tell your mom to run her house not yours !!
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
@leonilyn (467)
• Philippines
11 Dec 06
if that is your practice explain it to your wife.. but as we all know nowadays women also works for the living..so you should not practice that tradition anymore..everything now has change..and that is what your mother should understan..my mother do all the chores when she is with us..but she iis not living with us..she just come over occassionaly.
@leonilyn (467)
• Philippines
11 Dec 06
oopsszz... sorry..i dont its too late to cancel...:)
@reeseyj (906)
• United States
10 Dec 06
No way, Your wife married you not your family. Your lucky your wife is still with you . I would not have stayed. Your obligation is to your wife and to her only, you should never let anyone disrespect her. When they disrespect her there disrespecting you. You have your family now, if you live with your parents you need to move out.
@achyuta (2851)
• United States
10 Dec 06
I dont agree this his obligation is to his wife only. That is simply not true. He has obligations to his mother as well. Some middle path has to be worked out. Wife can be replaced. Mother cannot be. :) Thats my take on it. I am however not supporting anyone here.
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
@santaram (1422)
• India
10 Dec 06
we should respect elders so we have to do the work what they order to do not we should order to them any way sad in point of you
@john1984 (309)
• India
15 Dec 06
Thank you frou your response .
• India
10 Dec 06
the world and people are changing daily. our elders should not order at least. it should be a friendly relation. the respect is only in friendly relations not in the relations like this. if it is then its really good. the wife is really great. it should not like the relation of a boss and subordinate. ok.
• United States
11 Dec 06
Solution seems to be simple send your wife to work. or stay home for a week and try the role of ur wife i m sure will get the answer for ur post
@john1984 (309)
• India
11 Dec 06
Thank you chandan , Have a great day .
@balasri (26537)
• India
10 Dec 06
This is a typical Indian joint family dilemma.A mother of my daughter's classmate went through the same problem.As she couldnt go on like that anymore physically and mentaly she left her husband and went to her father's place.That chap after an year wanted to her come back promising to have a seperate home for them.But at what cost?The child lost one years education.The couple lost one year of precious moments.Why?What for?Loving your mother hasnt got anything to do with your personnal life.What period of civilisation are you in.It is unbelievable that you seek advice for your personnal life.
@john1984 (309)
• India
20 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May it will help my friend to get off from this .
@mansha (6298)
• India
10 Dec 06
Did you marry that girl or got ypur mother a maid.I think you are a henpecked son.Mama's darling boy-get some guts in to you tell your mother or bewtter find a maid servant for your home.You are lucky you got a simple girl for your wife-I think you should try doing the same amount of work for her family for rest of your life.Get a maid now and today itself or take your wiffe and shift from this hotel.
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
• India
10 Dec 06
y v all desis hav this common complaint and not the goras. the oinly remedy is to separate or atleast live in other house in the same apartment
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
@emarie (5442)
• United States
10 Dec 06
well, if tradition is strong in you, and you believe in it..then you shouldn't go much against it...but 15 memebers??? is she taking care of your WHOLE family?? is it possible for you to move out? my family has no real traditions, and if you feel your wife shouldn't put up with this then don't let her...remember its your role as a husband to protect the well being of her...she takes care of everyone...the who will take care of her?? she isn't obligated to take care of her in laws. in some old fashion asian families, the woman moves in with the husband and in-laws...the wife does most of the work, because she is younger, but the parents normally pitch in as well. it all depends on YOUR views...you can tell your mother you don't want your wife to be this over worked and opt to move out into your own place...or will the house fall to pieces if she's gone?? if thats the case then your mother should appreciate your wife a lot better and your wife should be making the desisions on how to do the housework. if your mother wants it done a certian way, then she can do it herself (i don't mean to sound to mean). but if your wife does all the work, then she calls the shots and she's in charge.
@john1984 (309)
• India
10 Dec 06
Thank you for your response . Have a great day .
@sexymuma (1261)
10 Dec 06
maybe you should get a place of your own,but in the mean time talk to the other members of the family because at the end of the day your wife marrried you to look after not the rest of your family,talk to your mum its the 2000's not the 1600's
@john1984 (309)
• India
10 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .Have a great day .
• India
10 Dec 06
hi friend, the problem seems to be common but it has a solution in my mind. To solve this, one can get involved in the work as compaired to the wife as far as burdens to wife, as possible it will give a peace of mind to wife. In case of mother, we do respect and make mother to gain the idea in silet and respectful manner that she is gaining irrelvant burdens in place. If this doesn't succeeds then one should arrange for actions which gain the interests of wife and mother, to be specific ask freely to both of them that they will not argue on each other but get involved with activities such as for wife to manage the things under mother and reverse case at some points later in continuation.
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
@adnan82 (672)
• Pakistan
10 Dec 06
lolzz... MAn . no matter she is ur mom...but try to explain her one thing.......that. ( if u were in the same position as my wife is wat will u do )...thats it..........Ur wife is also a human being.. not a machine. u have 15 members....atleast....6 of them will b females who stay at home...n can work or help ur..wifE out...Ur wife is not an unpaid servant.......IF U R A MAN...STAND FOR UR WIFE.....no matter she is ur mother.....but wrong is wrong.....ur wife shud..work for ur parents.....but...thats not rite....the she should work for every1.....n rest of them stay back n . give orders...... WAt do ya think.. u married a girl...who will b treated as a servant.....
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
• India
10 Dec 06
always support ur mom....
@john1984 (309)
• India
10 Dec 06
well, i am doing the same thing .I don't no what to do .Daily after my job , i have to join one more job .
@mtdewgurl74 (18151)
• United States
10 Dec 06
I myself think that the chores should be distributed equally between all women in the household young and old alike. Why make it so hard on one person. She will be to tired to enjoy life and maybe will start to hate it. So maybe have a talk to your mom if she cares anything about your wifes feelings then she will let up on some of the chores a little. I know yo said it is her belief is the daughter in law does all the work but maybe she could help two gets things done faster so they both can enjoy their days better and maybe not so many tussles between them.. I hope you the best in figureing out what is going to be best for you and your wife. I know you don't want to necessarily want to go up against your mother but if you love your wife you need to be on her side and help support her when she is needing your help in her corner.
@john1984 (309)
• India
15 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .
• United States
10 Dec 06
Well you better just build your own house and move into it with your wife!! and hurry
@john1984 (309)
• India
19 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .May be it will help me to comeout of this problem.
@valmiki9 (1171)
• India
10 Dec 06
This is the tradiion of joint family. It would be advisable for you to move out with your wife and make a seperate establishment. This is because i f your wife becomes sick none of your so called 15 family members will look after her and probably your mother will keep cursing her.
@john1984 (309)
• India
15 Dec 06
Thank you for your response . Have a great day .
• India
10 Dec 06
according to me your mom should treat ur wife as her daughter !!!!!!!!!then family fights will never occur......
@john1984 (309)
• India
10 Dec 06
thank you for your response . Have a great day .
@simplegal (123)
• Philippines
10 Dec 06
I have been in the situation like your wife before and its so hard because there's a competition for your attention. Your mother hardly accept that you love somebody now more than her and your attention is focused on your wife. You have to be independent enough to leave your parents and start a life away from them together with your own family. Believe me everything will put into place and you will have a peace of of mind even without money to spend.
@john1984 (309)
• India
10 Dec 06
Thank you for your response .well, i feel very happy after hearing from experienced person .
• India
21 Dec 06
get along - live happily
i don't have this problem.My mother and wife get along with each other very well.