Love vs. Arranged
By heman20x
@heman20x (234)
India
December 13, 2006 5:27am CST
Whenever we talk of Indian wedding we try to equate it with arrange marriages. In India the social structure is such that we associate Indian marriages mainly with arrange marriages. Most of us have the feelings that arrange marriage is the concept of Indian society. But history tells us that arranged marriages use to happen even in the Victorian age. The history of England tells us that most of the kings and queens had arranged marriages. In India arrange marriages originated when child marriages was customary in the country. Caste system gave birth to arrange marriages, as the upper caste families didn't want their children to marry outside their community and caste. The concept of love marriage was a taboo in ancient India as India always had a tradition of arranged marriages. But after World War II and industrial revolution people's perception started changing and they became familiar with the concept of love marriages. In India the influence of the British culture gave rise to love marriages. The idea, which was once a taboo, became more open and acceptable in the Indian society. But this change was seen only among the educated and high society Indians. The rural parts of the country remained ignorant and unaware of love marriages. In spite of the social changes arranged marriage persisted.
Love or arranged marriages is still a debatable topic in the Indian society. People still debate on the issue, which one is better. What should be the basis of the marriage love or social norms? We are still confused about these issues. Education and media played a vital role in changing the perception of the Indian mind. As people started thinking beyond the social customs and traditions of arranged marriages. They realized that they have the right to choose their life partner without any kind of social pressure. It is after all their life. They can decide without having to rely on parents, relatives and matchmakers. This change in the mental set up of the people gave birth to love marriages. Now in India people are open to love marriages. It is no more forbidden in the society. In our country we are having both love and arranged marriages. If we start comparing love and arranged marriages we will see that both has certain pros and cons. But the common factor in both the concept is physical attraction. When a man and a woman go out on their first date physical attraction is the deciding factor. Same in case of arranged marriage where the relation starts only after the girl or boy likes each other. But there are certain things, which are found in love marriages and not in arranged. Like spending time together and getting to know each other. Because when you have decided to spend the life together it is important you know the person. There should be metal compatibility and understanding among both of you. And this happens when you spend time together. On this people may argue that even after knowing each other for so long than why people get divorced after marriage. It is because when two people are in love they are at their best to impress each other. They behave, they talk and they wear what the other person likes. But it is after marriage that you get to know the real person. There are couples who are still discovering each other even after twenty years of their marriage. This is the actual beauty of a relationship where everyday you discover a new thing about your partner.
In case of arranged marriages the relation starts when the girl and the boy get to know each other in a couple of meeting before the final commitment. Before deciding anything the parents check the family background and financial stability. Which is also very important. As most of the people have an idea that those who go for arranged marriages are not in an advantageous position but it's not so you may get the right person for whom you have been waiting. Even in love marriages after many years of courtship people find their partner not suitable and they break up. So it is not about spending time together but successful marriage is all about understanding and respecting each other's feelings, love and concern. It is argued that love marriages offer more independence and freedom as compared to arranged marriages since both of them knows each other so the social pressure and family pressure is less. If you know somebody before marriage it allows partners to have better respect and understanding for each other's needs and desires. In love marriages expectations are more compared to arrange marriages, as they know each other and want their partner to act in the best possible manner.
Arranged marriages, offer more protection, security to the women. As the parents decides the family. Parents make use of maturity and wise decision while choosing suitable spouses for their children. The mature decision of parents sometimes helps to make the right choice. But it doesn't mean that arranged marriages are ideal marriages. Even in an arranged marriage there is a different sort of social pressure. Social evils like dowry, caste system, matching of horoscopes and community issues are taken at such extreme levels that people don't support arranged marriages. So whether it is love or arranged ultimately it is up to the individual to decide, which one to go for. Love or arranged both is based on empathy, responsibility, commitment, love and concern. So it's not just about initial love and attraction it needs a lot of dedication and effort to sustain a marriage. So there is nothing like an ideal marriage it's all about the way you perceive your marriage. After all you should be happy with your life partner irrespective of love or arranged marriage.
3 people like this
68 responses
@roadromeo (376)
• India
13 Dec 06
well 99% of marriages which are a love marriage have failed and this a proven fact.even love made arrange dose not survive. i would say that arrange marriage is always better bcoz u turn to expolre the person from the very first day of the marriage!!!
@shelonewolf1969 (486)
• United States
13 Dec 06
were did you get that stat at I have never seen a report that stated this rate of devorce .In the USA the total devorce rate is 50% .I would like to see your source for this information or are you just making numbers up ?
@nirmalgold (295)
• India
13 Dec 06
I prefer arranged marriage because if we had any problems our parents relatives and everyone else would respond soundly. But if we love and then marry we could only rely upon friends. It will be happy only if accepted by our parents. I don't hope it will occur in many cases. So it is the best thing to marry and then love.
@benoybose (155)
• India
14 Dec 06
Yes you are correct. I married by Love Marriage. but noe I agree your opinion.
@hiteshnihalani (2121)
• India
29 Dec 06
thank you for creating such a discussion which make easy to reply and discuss further....
love marriage is better where we can know each other...
@sowmyanadiminti (539)
• India
13 Dec 06
i prefer love marriage which is arranged....it will be koool really....our parents know mare about us i think....we can take our own decisions but..there's no wrong to tell them first before we deside to do any thing...if we r right then why should our parents oppose us??ther,s no cause to do so after all they want us to be happy....
@deepika_mona (1338)
• India
14 Dec 06
I do agree with u love which is been arranged by both parents n give in a name marrige where both get success in love n arrange n finally get marrige
@1986ankush (1241)
• India
23 Jan 07
thank you for creating such a great discussion.. i am glad to post in this tag.. thank you for sharing with us..
love + arrange..
@kunalgaurr (536)
• India
14 Dec 06
I have an arranged marriage and our (my and my husband views, taste, nature, etc.) nothing matches. Therefore, I believe Love marriage is better than arrange marriage as you decide your partner according to your nature, liking, etc... and if he or she matches the you go along and plan for marriage...
Conflictions come in all marriages but if couples have tuning and if they understand each other. it can be resolved...
But in case of arrange marriage, it's like a blind game you are playing. If you get good partner you won life but if you haven't then your life became hell.. Just imagine your partner doesn't even listen you, your views at all... everyone want to discuss their all moments with spouse but wat if he or she doesn't listen and always give sarcastic comments....
Wat is the guarantee that you will surely get good partner in arrange marraige but in love marriage you can choose on your own... according to your liking, dislikings, choices etc...
@banta78 (4326)
• India
14 Dec 06
I think We should be caught in comlex jargons trying to differentiate between arranged and love marriages. I feel marriage is a sacred social institution which should be respected by one and all. Marriage is all about love and commitment couple have for each other, the commitment they share, whatever the name. Marriage is building block around which society build and if don't respect it and misuxse it it will lead to social anarchy and disorder. I think dowry in marriages should be discouraged as i think we shouldn't try to bribe our way to get married and such a relationaship is doomed.
@banta78 (4326)
• India
14 Dec 06
I think We should be caught in comlex jargons trying to differentiate between arranged and love marriages. I feel marriage is a sacred social institution which should be respected by one and all. Marriage is all about love and commitment couple have for each other, the commitment they share, whatever the name. Marriage is building block around which society build and if don't respect it and misuxse it it will lead to social anarchy and disorder. I think dowry in marriages should be discouraged as i think we shouldn't try to bribe our way to get married and such a relationaship is doomed.
@parvesh333 (498)
• India
14 Dec 06
arrange marriage is all that i believe in.love can be done after that to the person u marry. but have to be very specific while choosing ur partner as its a matter or ur life.
and i even agree with u that its depends individual response
@vishnukompella836 (160)
• India
14 Dec 06
i prefer love after marriage .so that both the bride and groom will have enough time o understand themselves.
thay can also have a perfect idea of daily needs which they daily meet.
they will meet the proper requiite to make apefect decision
and they willbe a perfect couple by some time after the marriage.
@chandrasekharreddy (70)
• India
14 Dec 06
I prefer Arranged marriages, thatmeans i'm not opposite to love marriages.
Arranged marriages represents our culture. Moreover there is lot of interesting life after arranged marriage.
If it is Arranged marriage, we will start loving our partner after marriage and we will try to get her love as much as possible.This will be very interesting in life, trying to impress our better half. Whereas in Love marriages, love episode will be completed before marriage and after marriage life will be routine for them. In future any problems arised means, full family support will be there for arranged marriage couples.
@padhukr (2267)
• India
14 Dec 06
I like arranged marriage.Because arranged marriage is very successful life.The Indian
peoples are mostly like arranged marriage.India is a devolped country.Indian's people
are very cultured
@akhileshnatani (90)
• India
14 Dec 06
I WOULD BE IN FAVOUR OF ONE IN WHICH ALL ARE HAPPY . IN THAT CASE PROBABILITY OF ARRANGE MARRIGE IS MORE AS COMPARED TO LOVE
@simarsp (71)
• India
14 Dec 06
well i prefer love marriage,
coz if ur love is true n u have gd understanding b/w u. then love marrige is teh best . without any doubt, bcoz its easy to spend ur complete life with a person whom u love and who loves u , there is mutual understanding between the two , ,, rather thn wasting it with a unknown person!! well u may find a gd match in arranged n mnay not, but friends in love it s sureee
@ru88en (2997)
• Philippines
14 Dec 06
People may easily conclude that arrange marriage are more likely to fail that marriage made out of love. But marriage made out of love cannot even guarantee of a successful marriage and this is what happening rightnow.
In some culture and tradition, arrange marriage is very dominant. The parents want conceal with the other parents to let their son and daughter get married.
Some of the reasons why parents go for an arrange marriage aside from the tradition itself are to protect their wealth and heritage. Some think that as parents they know better what is good for their son or daughter than the son and daugher herself. And you can think of a lot more reason why some people go for arrange marriage.
Some arrange marriage turn to be successful with others are not. The key factors to successful arrange marriage are 1. the couple love each other also; 2. the couple learn to accept and understand each other, their adjustment skills are superb; 3. they are really what their parents to be happy.
Just remember, any form or type of marriage has an equal change to succied or fail. The outcome is affected by a lot of other factors.
@priyanka2345 (212)
• India
14 Dec 06
i preferr arranged because it will gives more security and more happiness.