Physics
By michemix
@michemix (22)
Mexico
December 21, 2006 11:30pm CST
Does water really have a preferred direction when going down a plughole? We hear all these theories about the plughole, but have rigorous experiments been performed? I once tried observing the water in a basin in an aircraft toilet. I repeated the experiment as I flew between hemispheres and crossed the equator. I even repeated it many times coming back the other way. To my disappointment the water went straight down the plughole without rotating this happened everytime! Perhaps you need a private jet with a whole bath?
2 people like this
20 responses
@Sandy100 (141)
•
22 Dec 06
Hi, the effect is real its called the corillis effect (if i've remebered it correctly). And it influences the direction in which water drains away. This force gets larger the further away you are from the equator, so you need to travel a long distance to get a pronanced effect. However the size of the force is tiny and the water experiences much bigger effects from, the shape of the bowl, turbealnce from washing hands (the way the plug is removed), temperature, etc. For this reason the effect is very hard to observe, however it has been experimentally observed using careful manufactured bowls and electronic plugs so not to influence the water flow placed a long way from the equator.
1 person likes this
@Timinator (739)
• United States
22 Dec 06
I doubt it would be the same on a plane as it is one earth because of the difference in motion. Also, the plane toilets usually suck the water out before it gets a chance to drain. Science has proven that water does prefer to drain in a certain direction though, and this is proven by many scientists and physicists.
@vipul20044 (5793)
• India
22 Dec 06
Hehe really great post
But i dont think that water gushes down in a particular direction
Ofcourse if the surface is inclined it will go all straight down
ANd it will gush due to gravity!
@amirsharipuddin (148)
• Malaysia
22 Dec 06
Wow.. thats very ..very interesting..You've revived my interest in physics all over again, i should thank you.
@Yabba79 (48)
• United States
22 Dec 06
It is not that the water has a preferred direction. This is known as the coriolis effect. This effect is also seen in weather patterns.
@patootie (3592)
•
22 Dec 06
This is a well known phenomena .. and in Southern Hemisphere water swirls the opposite way of the Northern Hemisphere .. isn't it all to do with the magnetic field of the earth??
I know I've read that the boffins are expecting the earths magnetism to change round in the near future .. and if that does happen it's going to play havoc with the way our basins and baths drain as of course all the plughole fittings are directional to improve drainage ... even toilets have flush mechanisms to optimise which way the water flushes round ...
It could all be very interesting ...
@dunetrekker (339)
• United Arab Emirates
22 Dec 06
Yes...water has a preferred direction in going down the plughole BUT it's not because of which earth's hemisphere you do the test but mainly because of the sink's structure. The earth's rotation is too weak to affect it but of course what is sure is that gravity acts upon it that's why it has to go down the drain. Also, the force of gravity will be dependent on the distance from the earth. 'Guess it's one of those science myths .
@mohsin3161 (654)
• Pakistan
22 Dec 06
well slow down a bit you dont require a jet its very diffcult for you to know when equator has passed maybe someother mistake
@smbilalshah (1316)
• Pakistan
22 Dec 06
the laws of fluid dynamics have nothing to do with this.....on brainiac on discovery they once tried this n proved that its just an urban myth
@wyrdsister (584)
• Canada
22 Dec 06
The above two commenters have it right. The first commenter's note about plane facilities is correct - there is suction applied to the drains and therefore you do not see this clockwise or counter clockwise motion.
These motions have to do with the rotation of the Earth and is called the Coriolis Effect. And yes, there have been rigorous experiments done. The second commenter noted there are much greater influences on how water drains, and this tends to counteract the Coriolis Effect in drainage situations. If you want to know more about the Coriolis Effect, Wikipedia has a fantastic entry for it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coriolis_effect
Thanks for asking!
~Wyrdsister