Do you think that media helps increase crime?
@littlefranciscan (18327)
United States
December 27, 2006 7:40am CST
I am wondering if all the coverage crime gets by media encourages other deranged people to do the same.. What makes people go off? Perhaps they like the publicity..Do you think media should publicize crimes as much as they do? Don't you think it gives others ideas that are looking for things to do like that?
4 people like this
28 responses
@kgwat70 (13388)
• United States
28 Dec 06
I think it does influence some crime to occur as it gives people ideas on what they could do and how to do it. There are a lot of copycat criminals out there so I definitely think the medias coverage can influence more crime. People do like publicity whether in a good way or in a bad way. It only takes one bad apple to make other people do bad things as well.
2 people like this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
Since most people who commit crimes are a bit mental ..all they need is a little stimuli to encourage them to do their crazy ideas:)+
1 person likes this
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
27 Dec 06
Yes I think that's how alot of people get ideas from the media, my husband and I were just talking about that yesterday. we were watching the news, and they show how people can break in homes, by using a special instrument. I told my husband now, that a bad idea, that's just giving people an idea. they even showed how it was done.
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
27 Dec 06
I think media has done so much harm in so many ways..all in the name of money.. Why is it that bad news is the most publicized news?+
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
27 Dec 06
I would imagine anyone who would commit such a crime and see the publicity others like themselves are getting will have the idea of doing something more spectacular..Human nature likes to compete..sometimes it could be like a game for them..To do the greatest crime!+
1 person likes this
@chenjun_yao (814)
• China
27 Dec 06
It's the two sides of one problem. Maybe people are informed how to do crime through the media report. But another, people also can learn how to prevent crime from the media. Then in fact, I also think the negitive is more than the positive!
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
27 Dec 06
I think so too..Yes publicity of a crime shows the crime will be punished..but what about those criminals that love the limelight? Who love the idea of being the center of attention+
1 person likes this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
I don't say that you can't tell of crime and warn etc. but to go on and on afte the crime has ended and has been solved. Enough is enough:)+
@xpriens (27)
• India
28 Dec 06
In a way it is good also....say jst to make people realize wht sort of crimes are there in the society ---- so tht they can take precaution to avoid them at ther neighbourhood or at ther very own place....
If it is not there, still there are minds who'll do it, but we wnt have any combat strategy left with us ---- could be said, "Prevention is better than Cure"...
Though i dnt disagree with the other part, tht they also instill some Mongers to try this craft in there area ---- for publicity or jst for mere grudge, but then, these people won't stop by jst like tht ---- rather they will go for some other or maybe more dangerous patterns of crimes......still this is a very debatable topic to be acted upon....
1 person likes this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
I am not too sure the correct answer on this topic..I have heard some say yes and some say no; but I feel having on cameras and publicized affects different people different ways.+
@xpriens (27)
• India
28 Dec 06
Yup i agree to.....but then u cannot ask media to jst stop tellin all this.....as we the People need to be aware of all this......
though there can be some rules to avoid making it a hot topic, like not exactly giving the details of the Crime....after all, we need to knw who did wht, maybe not the way he did wht...???
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
27 Dec 06
Isn't it a sad reality? I am wondering if such be the case..why do we continue to give these people the publicity they seek? Is it because it makes for a good story and more money into the pockets of the media?_+
1 person likes this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
I stopped watching the News..seems like the news should be called the olds:)+
@Kaorin (756)
• Australia
28 Dec 06
Well, I'm a Media Studies University student and Ive probably done more research on this topic than people that have replied to this thread have had hot dinners. Seriously, it's been my prime research topic for 2 years now.
I can tell you with assurance from my research that there is NO STATISTICAL EVIDENCE that has not been contested or disproved in other studies that says that the media icreases violence. There is no evidence that people blindly mimic what they see on television; in fact, that has been widely disproved since the theory came around in the 1920's. I mean, even if you think of it from a lateral point of view, kids ever day wach violent films and play violent games, and they do not go out and kill someone, or maim someone! There is no evidence that links playing violent games or watching violent films with going out and committing violent behaviour.
The main culprit of violence is family upbringing, friendship circles, religion, childhood, etc. There's many other factors, but television is NOT one of them.
Sorry, I could explain it better, but I'm kind of tired and trying to compact 2 years of research into a few sentences.
1 person likes this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
Well coming from someone in Media we could not expect any different answer; and your opinion or research is as much appeciated as the othe view.. I don't say media is the cause of crime..but I still hold that copycat crimes happen here in America..and I wonder "is it just coincidental" or did these ciminals copy the ideas from what they saw on tv?+
@momknows (284)
• United States
28 Dec 06
It really seems like the more you read about different crimes in the paper and see them on tv, the more crime hits home. I think alot of people are swayed into crimes to see if they can do it better, not get caught, etc. I think the legal system needs to work out better punishments for the crimes that are being committed and post this in the paper with a follow up story of what will happen when they're caught and let them know they will be caught.
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
I agree but still think the limeliht encourages those who find attention something that fuels them)+
@siddhardh (44)
• India
28 Dec 06
I hope media is focused only on publicity. They dosent encourage crime the educate the public from these crimes and also warning from the situtation that the have to face if they do any crime. But unfortunatly that helps people to get new ideas to do crimes
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
They say crime was not as bad years ago..We simply didn't hear of it as much ..due to poor media.+
@niranjan05 (106)
• India
28 Dec 06
You are right media is asking the people do as the same as criminals do if small boy sees it he tries for it when he become elder he trys for it.and they sow how to escape from poloce and in what way you can cheat the police.media not only doing this but spoiling the whole country.they are so powerful that even crimnals also becomes hero.
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
In our country we have seen how the media could be completely wrong on an election..I think a few years back they claimed someone else won the presidency..turned out they spoke to soon..I think they paint a picture of some of the facts and not all of the facts:)+
@venkaboy (2)
• India
28 Dec 06
(Hi this is my first post in Mylot)
I don't think media is the sole reason for increase in crime rate,
but MEDIA MAGNIFIES IT!!
The absence of media means,
i) only people in close-proximity knows it
ii) the incident is not discussed in various angles, which makes it popular and and urges people to add their own view points to it, (however stupid it could sound)
no helping us, it all happens and we feel the crime rate is high due to 'media'.
1 person likes this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
28 Dec 06
Welcome to mylot..glad you are here! You have very good input thanks for contibutin. Media does instill fear in us while instilling the idea of fame and reconition on the criminal sometimes.:(+
@redyellowblackdog (10629)
• United States
28 Dec 06
Yes, I do think the media helps increase crime. It does so not by covering the story, which must be done as we do need to know what is going on. The media increases crime by protraying the perpetrators in a sympathetic way. People in the media do not seem to understand how simple minded, mallable, and easily influenced some of these violent people happen to be.
Consider that you are a low self esteem loser who feels rotten about life and yourself most of the time. When you read a story about someone else who is pretty much just like you who has been caught committing some violent crime, what kind of advice to you think his own twisted logic whispers in his ear?
How about, " Gee, look at that guy, people feel sorry for him! He had a bad childhood, his parents beat him, he is poor, discriminated against, and etc. He is just like me! I could get people to feel sorry for me, too. People would not see me just as sorry loser. Thed's feel sorry for me. All I have to do is do what he did!"
Now, to normal people the above quote is absolute nonsense and incredibly stupid. That's right it is. However, I have known 3 murderers in my life. Two I knew really well. The third, I knew better than I'd like. That's how I know that people who do these things do think like in the quote!
A normal person has no concept what goes on in the mind of the average criminal unless they have seriously studied and/or associated with some of them.
The mind of the violent criminal is not a tidy organized logical place. The stories of the media enter this chaotic place, the criminal mind, and stir it up even worse than it was!
1 person likes this
@angnima (772)
• Nepal
28 Dec 06
Crime is not the direct product of media.
Media plays major role when there is crime in society.
Mostly, we find media in negative side.
They spread it to earn more. They think
that this is their business.
They never think that some positive news should cover the front page of newspaper.
No, TV channels are working for good news.
1 person likes this
@sundeepm474 (888)
• India
28 Dec 06
Ya i too think the same the media is helping in increasing the crime.They not only showing the crimes they are telecasting the crimes as the episodes in the T.V this increases the crime rate.
@parttimer (127)
• India
28 Dec 06
No. You feel that the crime has increased because it gets covered by the medis extensively. Crime was the same even earlier.
@velkanster (234)
• India
28 Dec 06
yeah offcourse i agree with this the media peoples are making big deal out of small silly things.Apart from this they even clearly depict the things elaborately and how they found the clues in this way they are tempting and pulling the new peoples who does not know the way of living into this kind of things as they told how they found they clue it is easy for these new peoples to avoid that mistakes.So media is just ready to do anything for the sake of publicity thats all. In my view media should stop doing this
1 person likes this