Is Remake of a film capable of creating same magic as older one?

yes remakes can create the same magic as that of old one or even more than that. shahrukh's DON is the example

hi arti i don't think there is any magic in any of the remake film becaus all the remake film has been floped till now ike umrao jaan,don so i think that it i not good to make a remake of old film rather than it is good to make a film on new stories,new thoughts,new ideas,like rang de basanti and lage raho munnabhai as they where thr biggest hits of the previous year.

I don't think I have seen any Bollywood films, however I have seen remakes of other films, one of my favourites is John Buchan's 39 steps, I've seen at least 3 different versions, with Robert Donut, Kenneth Moore & Robert Powell, I'm not sure which is my favourite, as I've enjoyed them all. I've also seen some remakes of Agatha Christie films, some of them don't even seem like the same film

not the same magic but till it is a different experience all together don was not that good comparativly too that of amitabh bachan but still it was a good movie to watch faranh aktar has worked really hard on it.

no no magic at all. they r boring, as we know the story..

Well Arti I think Don was a exception. In that movie the film makers hav altogether changed the whole script rather than keeping the same movie as it is, jus picking up sum glimpses from the old movie DON. However in that process they made a big blunder. But if you take the case of Hum Aapke... Hain kaun??? which is a remake of Nadiya Ke Paar u wont find the same.