Homeschoolers - How do you usually respond to the "socialization" comments?
By prismrainbow
@prismrainbow (107)
United States
January 5, 2007 2:35am CST
I'm referring more to offline interactions with people but online in various groups as well. I don't mean the comments from other homeschoolers interested in what types of social activities our kids participate in. I'm talking about the people who's first world out of their mouth when they find out you homeschool is, "But what about socialization? Aren't you worried about the lack of social skills your kid will end up with?"
I'm just curious how other people handle this. Sometimes I just snicker (like "oh my gosh, you can't be serious! If you only knew how overly socialized my kid is!!") and take the time to explain how and why it isn't a concern. Other times I just snicker to myself and shake my head because I don't have the mental energy to repeat it all again - knowing full well that the person still isn't going to get it or believe it when I'm through.
So what about you?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@Ravenladyj (22902)
• United States
19 Jan 07
How did I deal with the naysayers? by putting them in their place with perfect examples...for starters school IS NOT a place of socialization in fact many schools here in the U.S including my kids school DO NOT have recess so they dont get socialing time...secondly they have get togethers with friends and family on a regular basis..when we homeschooled it was back in Canada and we had kids from the neighbourhood over every day after school...we lived across from the park and my kids were there hanging out constantly with the other kids..thirdly, homeschoolers have numerous resources and groups they can join where they get together for field trips and play days etc..and finally its actually been PROVEN that homeschooled children are in fact more well rounded, successful on all levels and are actually BETTER at socializing then public/private schooled children ;-) The info is out there...you jsut have to look for it but ppl who are against it DONT WANT TO look for it because then they'd be proven wrong and would ahve to eat their words LOL...
ppl who claim homeschooled children are social deprived and will end up socially disturbed are uneducated, narrowminded and live with blinders on...
2 people like this
@prismrainbow (107)
• United States
20 Jan 07
Your last paragraph really sums it all up and is so true. I would add one little qualifier though. "are uneducated about homeschooling" because I have seen some very highly educated people be very ignorant about all the aspects of homeschooling.
@Ravenladyj (22902)
• United States
22 Jan 07
"I have seen some very highly educated people be very ignorant about all the aspects of homeschooling"
agreed...and yes I should have said "uneducated re:homeschooling" or something along those lines..very true...
@wahmbrendamh (576)
• United States
20 Jan 07
Well said! In fact, so well said that all I can really say is AMEN!
Brenda Marie
Homeschool 4 Us (My homeschool blog): http://homeschool4us.blogspot.com/
My ebook: "Homeschooling Without The Headaches" http://stores.lulu.com/store.php?fAcctID=812683
@mydogisdaisy (99)
• United States
18 Jan 07
If my son is with me I tell them to ask him...Usually a few minutes later they will cut him off and say ok ok I get the idea. He will go on for hours about his volunteering, the Civial Air Patrol, etc.
When my son is not with me I just shrug my shoulders and tell them its not an issue. If they insist, I then go on and on about all the activities my son gets to participate in.
As homeschooling becomes more popular I am hearing this question less. More often now I am asked how to get started homeschool.
HTH
Crystal
1 person likes this
@wahmbrendamh (576)
• United States
20 Jan 07
My 5yo dd is much the same. She loves trying to explain homeschool to her friends at church. I can't help but smile as I watch it go on.
Brenda Marie
Homeschool 4 Us (My homeschool blog): http://homeschool4us.blogspot.com/
My ebook: "Homeschooling Without The Headaches" http://stores.lulu.com/store.php?fAcctID=812683
1 person likes this
@prismrainbow (107)
• United States
21 Jan 07
Like your blog Brenda. We are eclectic unschoolers also.
Your comment about listening to her explain homeschooling reminded me of questions my son has been asked by other kids. This discussion started about socialization questions between grownups but it is funny to also hear kids trying to imagine what homeschooling is like. Unschooling makes it even more interesting to respond to because we don't follow a "schedule" for learning. If my son decides he needs to learn algebra in the middle of the summer, then we do it! If he wants to do a science experiment on a holiday, we do! I have heard other kids ask him things like, "Do you have recess and what do you do during recess? Go outside to play?" Or comments like, "ewwhh, Monday was a holiday! Why were you doing science schoolwork!?" He'll say something like, "my curiousity isn't limited to 'school hours'. When I want to know about something, it doesn't matter what time or day it is!" So funny to listen to some of these conversations.
1 person likes this
@prismrainbow (107)
• United States
20 Jan 07
Had to smile. I have a non-stop talker too. People are usually sorry they've asked after a few minutes. But the thing most people are probably failing to see in those circumstances is the enthusiasm and love of learning that is driving all that socialization.
I still hear the question quite often. Perhaps it's because I live in a fairly rural and large state so many have the impression that homeschooling means staying home a lot and being isolated. Of course, that's simply not true but it takes some educating for them to realize this.
@wahmbrendamh (576)
• United States
22 Jan 07
It's really too bad that you make such a statement without anything to back yourself up with. It shows just how ignorant some people really are about this subject.
Brenda Marie
Homeschool 4 Us (My homeschool blog): http://homeschool4us.blogspot.com/
My ebook: "Homeschooling Without The Headaches" http://stores.lulu.com/store.php?fAcctID=812683
@wahmbrendamh (576)
• United States
20 Jan 07
You know, maybe I'm lucky or something, but I can't honestly remeber the last time that I was asked this question. I think that as homeschooling grows in popularity we'll be answering this question less and less.
Brenda Marie
Homeschool 4 Us (My homeschool blog): http://homeschool4us.blogspot.com/
My ebook: "Homeschooling Without The Headaches" http://stores.lulu.com/store.php?fAcctID=812683
1 person likes this
@cjsmom (1423)
• United States
11 Jan 07
I am considering homeschooling my son, CJ. I have researched very little as of now but what I have found out is this: If a parent does it correctly and gets into the right group of parents who also homeschool; in their area of course, they can and do have sufficient socialization with other children in their age group, etc.
They get together at functions, go to parks, each other's birthdays. If you get into the right group, you'll be amazed; the children will have a lot more interaction with their peers than they do at a public school.
It's all about research and what's best for the child.
1 person likes this
@prismrainbow (107)
• United States
14 Jan 07
Yes, but the question is not "how" to ensure they are socialized enough but about how to deal with those who assume they are not socialized at all just because they are homeschooled.
You say you are considering homeschooling your son. So imagine you have done mega things to make sure he is getting plenty of socialization and developing good social skills, and not being isolated. Then, every 3rd person you meet looks you in the eye when you say you are homeschooling and says "but what about socialization? Aren't you worried?" - like he must going to be a social misfit because you must stay locked up in the house 365 days/year because you homeschool. So how do you suppose you will react to them and what will you typically say/do?
1 person likes this
@celray (141)
• United States
13 Jan 07
Socializing happens all the time either homeschool or not, I prefer my kid knows how to relate to all kind of people other than only people her own age,what people do not understand is that homeschoolers are not deprived from the world , i take my kids every where i go and they talk and socialize with everyone the same way i do ,also there's all kinds of social activities and afterschool programs they can join.
1 person likes this
@prismrainbow (107)
• United States
14 Jan 07
Yes, WE know this. But the question is what you usually do or say with those people who think all homeschoolers ARE deprived from the world just because they are homeschooled. Do you usually take time to explain it to them (almost feeling like you are explaining more out of needing like you have to justify to everyone that your kids are very socialized and why they are)? Or do you ignore the insinuation and move on, knowing you have better things to do with your time than explaining the socialization skills of homeschoolers to people that may or may not get it even if you take the time to explain?